POLL: Are You Experienced or Led Zeppelin I?

[Texas King]

Take your pick between these two classic debuts.

 

I dig both albums, but I have to pick AYE, because it sounds much more original.

[GeddyLeeRoth]

Experienced. Zep I was an awesome beginning, but Jimi and The Experience were fully realized on their first album. One of the all-time greatest debuts, along with Zep I, Doors, GnR, VH, KISS... Edited February 18, 2020 by GeddyLeeRoth

[bluefox4000]

Going Zep here. as i said in the other poll i respect Hendrix but his actual albums kinda straight bore me.

 

I LOVE Zep's Debut though.

 

Mick

[apetersvt]

Love both so much. For me, it's like choosing between Caress Of Steel and Hemispheres (my two fav Rush albums).

 

I'll go with Zep. I can play along with Jimmy on most of it. I don't try to keep up with Jimi.

[treeduck]

Are you Experienced - It's just a better album with better songs.

[Babycat]

Led Zeppelin.

[ReRushed]

Are you Experienced - It's just a better album with better songs.

Agreed.

[RushFanForever]

Geddy Lee likes both according to here and here.

[driventotheedge]

I voted Jimi but both are so fukking good.......

[Mithrandir]

Zep by a bit.

[Rick N. Backer]

Completely a function of mood.

[Entre_Perpetuo]

This is pretty close. I’ll say Zep 1 definitely isn’t my favorite Zep, but Zep as a whole probably means more to me than Jimi, as amazing as the Experienced debut is. I’m not sure which one I necessarily prefer.

[HemiBeers]

Jimi was more revolutionary and creative than Jimmy Page. Really not close.

[_hi_water._]

Jimi

[invisible airwave]

[custom55]

Led Zeppelin

 

 

BUT

 

 

this is funny

 

Edited February 2, 2021 by custom55

[Entre_Perpetuo]

This is pretty close. I’ll say Zep 1 definitely isn’t my favorite Zep, but Zep as a whole probably means more to me than Jimi, as amazing as the Experienced debut is. I’m not sure which one I necessarily prefer.

 

By now I know for sure. Zep I is kinda weak to me in places. II improved on it in every way. Are You Experienced is the same level pretty much all the way through, and that level is fantastic.

[zepphead]

Zeppelin