Entre_Perpetuo Posted April 11, 2021 Posted April 11, 2021 Another randomly generated poll! Yes - Close To The Edge vs. Thin Lizzy - Jailbreak Last time I expected a blowout win for Boston over Genesis and have been very surprised by a tie. This time I'm expecting a pretty strong win for Yes, but I know there are a lot of Lizzy fans on here as well.
_hi_water._ Posted April 11, 2021 Posted April 11, 2021 Yes, yes indeed, I yes indeed did choose Yes.
Entre_Perpetuo Posted April 11, 2021 Author Posted April 11, 2021 Are you serious, Clark? Yep! It was randomly generated after all!
Your_Lion Posted April 11, 2021 Posted April 11, 2021 I love Thin Lizzy, but Close to the Edge is one of my all-time favourite albums. It's perfect. 1
Nova Carmina Posted April 11, 2021 Posted April 11, 2021 Damn your eyes, son! These close ones cause anguishing. The tiebreak for me was "which would I turn up, if it came on in random play?" and that's always gonna be Lizzy. I love Yes -- don't @ me, Yesfriends! -- but Lizzy just sounds like rock and roll to me. 1 and 1a for this one. 3
blueschica Posted April 12, 2021 Posted April 12, 2021 A tough one! Are you sure these are randomly generated :lol: they seem very difficult :) I love Close to the Edge, but I went with Jailbreak, it's a personal favorite. Voted Yes for the band, though, only because Thin Lizzy was so short lived, we never got to hear their full potential. 2
Entre_Perpetuo Posted April 12, 2021 Author Posted April 12, 2021 A tough one! Are you sure these are randomly generated :lol: they seem very difficult :) I love Close to the Edge, but I went with Jailbreak, it's a personal favorite. Voted Yes for the band, though, only because Thin Lizzy was so short lived, we never got to hear their full potential. Well it's about as randomly generated as I want it to be. What I do is I pull up my record collection on rateyourmusic.com, then I have the internet roll me a d23 to determine which page I'll pick an album from, then I have it roll a D25 for the particular album. However I have made the personal ruling that if it picks something either I or the community here doesn't know all that well or if it picks one of the like couple of 45s I have in that list, I get to re-roll once. 2
blueschica Posted April 12, 2021 Posted April 12, 2021 A tough one! Are you sure these are randomly generated :lol: they seem very difficult :) I love Close to the Edge, but I went with Jailbreak, it's a personal favorite. Voted Yes for the band, though, only because Thin Lizzy was so short lived, we never got to hear their full potential. Well it's about as randomly generated as I want it to be. What I do is I pull up my record collection on rateyourmusic.com, then I have the internet roll me a d23 to determine which page I'll pick an album from, then I have it roll a D25 for the particular album. However I have made the personal ruling that if it picks something either I or the community here doesn't know all that well or if it picks one of the like couple of 45s I have in that list, I get to re-roll once. Cool! Sounds like an interesting system! The results have brought some good polls so far. 1
Entre_Perpetuo Posted April 12, 2021 Author Posted April 12, 2021 So this is a really hard one. I may not be quite right in my assessment of my own feelings, but I feel bad for Lizzy getting the short end of the stick here, and when I think about it, from a certain perspective their discography is just more consistent than Yes'. There's not a single Yes album I've heard that I don't enjoy, but I have to admit that Big Generator and Tormato feel a bit hollow in a catalogue that includes Close To The Edge and The Yes Album. Thin Lizzy's catalogue just doesn't really have that problem. Even the weaker records that I've heard are pretty narrowly separated from the stronger ones. So I'm giving TL my vote for the best band if only for that reason (and that they're also way cooler), but Close To The Edge is closer to my heart that Jailbreak. 1
Entre_Perpetuo Posted April 12, 2021 Author Posted April 12, 2021 A tough one! Are you sure these are randomly generated :lol: they seem very difficult :) I love Close to the Edge, but I went with Jailbreak, it's a personal favorite. Voted Yes for the band, though, only because Thin Lizzy was so short lived, we never got to hear their full potential. Well it's about as randomly generated as I want it to be. What I do is I pull up my record collection on rateyourmusic.com, then I have the internet roll me a d23 to determine which page I'll pick an album from, then I have it roll a D25 for the particular album. However I have made the personal ruling that if it picks something either I or the community here doesn't know all that well or if it picks one of the like couple of 45s I have in that list, I get to re-roll once. Cool! Sounds like an interesting system! The results have brought some good polls so far. Surprisingly! :) 1
zepphead Posted April 12, 2021 Posted April 12, 2021 Much as I love Thin Lizzy, they are just not in the same league as Yes IMO.
treeduck Posted April 12, 2021 Posted April 12, 2021 Much as I love Thin Lizzy, they are just not in the same league as Yes IMO. 2
pjbear05 Posted April 12, 2021 Posted April 12, 2021 I love Thin Lizzy, but Close to the Edge is one of my all-time favourite albums. It's perfect.Yep, same here. 1
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now