The big bands debut clash: Led Zeppelin VS Black Sabbath?

[Texas King]

Two great debuts, but I give a nod to BS, which is one of the most groundbreaking records.

What you think?

[Rick N. Backer]

Sabbath.

 

You could run this matchup all the way to Never Say Die v. In Through the Out Door actually.

[Tony R]

Two great debuts, but I give a nod to BS, which is one of the most groundbreaking records.

What you think?

 

I think they tie in terms of groundbreaking.

 

 

[custom55]

Both albums are amazing but, "Behind The Wall Of Sleep" ? Priceless. Edited November 20, 2016 by custom55

[Segue Myles]

I don't like the debut Sabbath album.

 

No I'm denying it's great. I just don't enjoy it.

 

As for Led Zeppelin, I may not enjoy everything they have done but that debut is one of the enjoyable things I have ever heard!

[RUSHHEAD666]

Sabbath.

 

You could run this matchup all the way to Never Say Die v. In Through the Out Door actually.

 

Hahaha! Reminds me of my poll!

 

NEVER SAY DIE DESTROYS IN THROUGH THE OUT DOOR!

[djflex]

Black sabbath

 

 

I doubt i will ever vote zep for anything

[RUSHHEAD666]

Black sabbath

 

 

I doubt i will ever vote zep for anything

 

Overrated or overplayed?

[RUSHHEAD666]

I love the Mighty Zep but man they are overplayed.

 

Stairway To Heaven and Freebird kill my soul. I'm over War Pigs too.

[Lucas]

By the time House Of The Holy would come around, I'd go for Led Zep . . .

 

But as for the debuts, Black Sabbath

[treeduck]

Sabbath.

[djflex]

Black sabbath

 

 

I doubt i will ever vote zep for anything

 

Overrated or overplayed?

 

I just really never got into them that much. Im no hater or anything just never took off with me .

[Rick N. Backer]

Sabbath.

 

You could run this matchup all the way to Never Say Die v. In Through the Out Door actually.

 

Hahaha! Reminds me of my poll!

 

NEVER SAY DIE DESTROYS IN THROUGH THE OUT DOOR!

 

Paranoid v. II?

 

Sabbath Bloody Sabbath v. Houses of the Holy?

 

Pretty good match ups.

[geezer]

SABBATH. First theee notes of the album are enough to win this contest (and many more)

[EagleMoon]

I prefer Led Zeps debut but I can appreciate Sabbath.

[Babycat]

Black Sabbath.

[Stormtron]

Black Sabbath

[Rod in Toronto]

I love both, and I´m more acquainted with Zeppelin. Debut-wise though, Sabbath gets the edge.

[Hatchetaxe&saw]

Sabbath, because the 2 slow blues covers(Shook Me & Quit You) on LZ 1 are utter shite.

[Laurabw]

Def Black Sabbath.

[goose]

I love both, and I´m more acquainted with Zeppelin. Debut-wise though, Sabbath gets the edge.

Pretty much the same, here. Zep's debut is a little dodgy to me, for the reasons Hatchet noted. Edited November 21, 2016 by goose

[ReRushed]

Sabbath for the debut. Zeppelin for overall.

[goose]

Sabbath for the debut. Zeppelin for overall.

Me, too. Zep produced a wider, more interesting range of music.