OMG!! GEEZER! Don't take this the wrong way but I LOVE YOU!!!! Of course!! I love Peter!! But exactly!! What FISH did with Marillion in the Eighties was immaculate. I mean seriously let's really get right down to the Lothian Heart of the matter...... Gabriel with Genesis. LEGEND. PERFECT. From Genesis To Revelations Trespass Nursery Cryme Foxtrot Selling England By The Pound The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway Six records with Genesis. The debut album is good, but not a prog classic. JMO So that's five albums with Gabriel Genesis. All Masterpieces. Now enter the Marillion Fish Era...... Script for A Jester's Tear Fugazi Misplaced Childhood Clutching At Straws That's four immaculate perfect albums too. Oh, and to make it more even, don't forget about "The B Sides Themselves." Marillion wrote many songs that were not on those four records. "Lady Nina" and "Freaks." "Three Boats...." too. "Grendel?" I mean I think it's a fair argument to discuss early Marillion VS early Genesis. Amazing prog. I love it all like a whore with a "Warm Wet Circle." Bring it on gang! Fish in Marillion > Gabriel Genesis Oh and the FISH solo albums blow away Peter's boring ass shite. Peter went POP! Signed, "Don't Give Up" I LOVE 'Don't Give Up', but mainly because of Kate Bush!