Peart----- You won't believe this :0

[Wil1972]

I think Micky Dolenz deserves more respect.

[HemiBeers]

No Matt Cameron...fail

 

Stewert Copeland...hasn't done shit on the drums beyond the Police. most overrated drummer ever.

 

Charlie Watts...his entire career could be replaced by a drum machine.

 

Max Weinberg -wouldn't be on the list if his nose wasn't stuck up Bruce's ass.

 

Piece of shit list.

 

Excuse me while I clear all the cookies and browser history from this click bait shit site.

Edited December 20, 2018 by HemiBeers

[Entre_Perpetuo]

No Matt Cameron...fail

 

Stewert Copeland...hasn't done shit on the drums beyond the Police. most overrated drummer ever.

 

Charlie Watts...his entire career could be replaced by a drum machine.

 

Max Weinberg -wouldn't be on the list if his nose wasn't stuck up Bruce's ass.

 

Piece of shit list.

 

Excuse me while I clear all the cookies and browser history from this click bait shit site.

 

Matt Cameron might be the most underrated drummer I know.

[Bhawk2112]

The drummer not ranked high enough on this list is Ginger Baker...

[Segue Myles]

I haven't looked at it. But if it doesn't include Phil Rudd, and have him in the top 3 and ahead of Neil, it's a bullshit list.

 

Folks, Neil is NOT a good rock drummer. No feel. No groove. He a robot, programmed to jerk off all over the place.

 

...

[Syrinx]

No Matt Cameron...fail

 

Stewert Copeland...hasn't done shit on the drums beyond the Police. most overrated drummer ever.

 

Charlie Watts...his entire career could be replaced by a drum machine.

 

Max Weinberg -wouldn't be on the list if his nose wasn't stuck up Bruce's ass.

 

Piece of shit list.

 

Excuse me while I clear all the cookies and browser history from this click bait shit site.

 

To each his own, but I completely disagree with your statements on all 3 above!

[Syrinx]

Except for Matt Cameron - a great drummer.

[tks95747]

I haven't looked at it. But if it doesn't include Phil Rudd, and have him in the top 3 and ahead of Neil, it's a bullshit list.

 

Folks, Neil is NOT a good rock drummer. No feel. No groove. He a robot, programmed to jerk off all over the place.

 

...

Not being a drummer, I don't pretend to be able to give any meaningful assessment of Neil as a "rock" drummer. One of my favorite drummers is Gavin Harrison of Porcupine Tree, but what do I know about drumming... Not much. I just love listening to Neil play...

[JohnRogers]

How does Ringo Starr rank so high?

[Entre_Perpetuo]

How does Ringo Starr rank so high?

 

Being the drummer of the most popular musical act of the last century might have a lot to do with it. It's not like he sucks anyways.

[JohnRogers]

How does Ringo Starr rank so high?

 

Being the drummer of the most popular musical act of the last century might have a lot to do with it. It's not like he sucks anyways.

He doesn’t suck but he isn’t great either.

[Entre_Perpetuo]

How does Ringo Starr rank so high?

 

Being the drummer of the most popular musical act of the last century might have a lot to do with it. It's not like he sucks anyways.

He doesn’t suck but he isn’t great either.

 

Depends on your definition of great. A great drummer imo knows when to play what, and always plays to serve the tune. Peart is surprisingly a great example of this, as his complex and machinelike style compliment the overall complexity of Rush's songs perfectly. Meanwhile, Ringo's extremely straightforward approach (with a slight quirk caused by a lefty playing a right handed kit setup) compliments the Beatles' very straightforward songs quite well. And when their songs aren't so straightforward, Ringo provides a simple backbone for the rest of the instruments to revolve around. I'm not saying the tunes would suck with a more technically skilled drummer, but I think Ringo's simplistic approach actually adds to their quality in a way many other drummers couldn't. Besides, I doubt you could find many drummers out there who are willing to bash his work, even the most technically proficient of them.

Edited December 20, 2018 by Entre_Perpetuo

[Permanent-Rush]

No Matt Cameron...fail

 

Stewert Copeland...hasn't done shit on the drums beyond the Police. most overrated drummer ever.

 

Charlie Watts...his entire career could be replaced by a drum machine.

 

Max Weinberg -wouldn't be on the list if his nose wasn't stuck up Bruce's ass.

 

Piece of shit list.

 

Excuse me while I clear all the cookies and browser history from this click bait shit site.

 

Matt Cameron might be the most underrated drummer I know.

 

Bill Berry?? I see him on no ones top ten list cept mine and my best friend's, and as far as I know he has only been mentioned in a top ten once, IN THE PARAGRAPH BEFORE THE LIST EVEN STARTED!!

Edited December 20, 2018 by Permanent-Rush

[Entre_Perpetuo]

No Matt Cameron...fail

 

Stewert Copeland...hasn't done shit on the drums beyond the Police. most overrated drummer ever.

 

Charlie Watts...his entire career could be replaced by a drum machine.

 

Max Weinberg -wouldn't be on the list if his nose wasn't stuck up Bruce's ass.

 

Piece of shit list.

 

Excuse me while I clear all the cookies and browser history from this click bait shit site.

 

Matt Cameron might be the most underrated drummer I know.

 

Bill Berry?? I see him on no ones top ten list cept mine and my best friend's, and as far as I know he has only been mentioned in a top ten once, IN THE PARAGRAPH BEFORE THE LIST EVEN STARTED!!

 

He’s no slouch, but he’s never caught my ear.

[Syrinx]

How does Ringo Starr rank so high?

 

Being the drummer of the most popular musical act of the last century might have a lot to do with it. It's not like he sucks anyways.

He doesn’t suck but he isn’t great either.

 

Depends on your definition of great. A great drummer imo knows when to play what, and always plays to serve the tune. Peart is surprisingly a great example of this, as his complex and machinelike style compliment the overall complexity of Rush's songs perfectly. Meanwhile, Ringo's extremely straightforward approach (with a slight quirk caused by a lefty playing a right handed kit setup) compliments the Beatles' very straightforward songs quite well. And when their songs aren't so straightforward, Ringo provides a simple backbone for the rest of the instruments to revolve around. I'm not saying the tunes would suck with a more technically skilled drummer, but I think Ringo's simplistic approach actually adds to their quality in a way many other drummers couldn't. Besides, I doubt you could find many drummers out there who are willing to bash his work, even the most technically proficient of them.

 

Yes, yes, yes! As I stated earlier drumming is not about playing the most complex patterns possible - unless you are in a band like Rush. The drummer is there to set the time and to complement, but not to overplay and overshadow the rest of the band. I think non-drummers have a different view of who is best. As a long time drummer, I have come to realize that I get the best feedback from other musicians when I keep a steady beat and again don't overplay. Musicians appreciate a rock steady drummer. Ringo Starr is on the list because he may be the most influential drummer of all time! I believe more kids took up drumming after seeing the Beatles on Ed Sullivan than any other time. His oyster black Ludwig kit remains the most iconic drum set ever. The original bass head used on Ed Sullivan sold for over $2 million and his actual first Ludwig kit sold for over $2.1 million. Ringo was perfect for the Beatles. His drumming on their albums (and as the story goes he didn't play on all songs), was exactly what those songs needed. Ringo Starr and Charlie Watts both belong on any greatest drummers lists.

[tks95747]

How does Ringo Starr rank so high?

 

Being the drummer of the most popular musical act of the last century might have a lot to do with it. It's not like he sucks anyways.

He doesn’t suck but he isn’t great either.

 

Depends on your definition of great. A great drummer imo knows when to play what, and always plays to serve the tune. Peart is surprisingly a great example of this, as his complex and machinelike style compliment the overall complexity of Rush's songs perfectly. Meanwhile, Ringo's extremely straightforward approach (with a slight quirk caused by a lefty playing a right handed kit setup) compliments the Beatles' very straightforward songs quite well. And when their songs aren't so straightforward, Ringo provides a simple backbone for the rest of the instruments to revolve around. I'm not saying the tunes would suck with a more technically skilled drummer, but I think Ringo's simplistic approach actually adds to their quality in a way many other drummers couldn't. Besides, I doubt you could find many drummers out there who are willing to bash his work, even the most technically proficient of them.

 

"The drummer is there to set the time and to complement, but not to overplay and overshadow the rest of the band. . ."

 

So, are you suggesting that Neil "overplayed" or "overshadowed" Alex and Ged? IMO, he did not. I think they were all complimentary to each other. If there was a drummer that overplayed or overshadowed the rest of the band, in my opinion, it would have been Portnoy in DT (although they all overplay)...

[Entre_Perpetuo]

How does Ringo Starr rank so high?

 

Being the drummer of the most popular musical act of the last century might have a lot to do with it. It's not like he sucks anyways.

He doesn’t suck but he isn’t great either.

 

Depends on your definition of great. A great drummer imo knows when to play what, and always plays to serve the tune. Peart is surprisingly a great example of this, as his complex and machinelike style compliment the overall complexity of Rush's songs perfectly. Meanwhile, Ringo's extremely straightforward approach (with a slight quirk caused by a lefty playing a right handed kit setup) compliments the Beatles' very straightforward songs quite well. And when their songs aren't so straightforward, Ringo provides a simple backbone for the rest of the instruments to revolve around. I'm not saying the tunes would suck with a more technically skilled drummer, but I think Ringo's simplistic approach actually adds to their quality in a way many other drummers couldn't. Besides, I doubt you could find many drummers out there who are willing to bash his work, even the most technically proficient of them.

 

"The drummer is there to set the time and to complement, but not to overplay and overshadow the rest of the band. . ."

 

So, are you suggesting that Neil "overplayed" or "overshadowed" Alex and Ged? IMO, he did not. I think they were all complimentary to each other. If there was a drummer that overplayed or overshadowed the rest of the band, in my opinion, it would have been Portnoy in DT (although they all overplay)...

 

That’s not at all what they were suggesting. They mentioned that Rush with Neil are the exception to the “rule” that drumming isn’t about playing the most complex patterns in the previous sentence to the one you quoted. Don’t take people’s words out of context.

[toymaker]

Don't suppose someone would care to list the drummers here so I don't have to go through the whole thing myself . . . I get irritated by those "they didn't know they were being photographed" and "why Hollywood won't hire ______ anymore" and "you won't believe what __________ looks like now" things.

[Entre_Perpetuo]

Don't suppose someone would care to list the drummers here so I don't have to go through the whole thing myself . . . I get irritated by those "they didn't know they were being photographed" and "why Hollywood won't hire ______ anymore" and "you won't believe what __________ looks like now" things.

 

Alex Van Halen

Tommy Lee

Phil Collins

Carmine Appice

Janet Weiss

Chad Smith

Roger Taylor

Tommy Aldridge

Jeff Porcaro

Danny Carey

Terry Bozzio

Maureen “Moe” Tucker

Max Weinberg

Mike Portnoy

Dave Grohl

Ringo Starr

Ian Paice

Mitch Mitchell

Stewart Copeland

Keith Moon

Bill Bruford

Charlie Watts

Ginger Baker

Neil Peart

John Bonham

[Permanent-Rush]

^

 

Terima kasih banyak!!

 

Though IMO I believe Bill Berry should be on that list, and is better than most of those drummers, just my opinion here folks don't get offended!!

[toymaker]

Many thanks, EP!!

[Tony R]

^

 

Terima kasih banyak!!

 

Though IMO I believe Bill Berry should be on that list, and is better than most of those drummers, just my opinion here folks don't get offended!!

He’s not anywhere near the class of most of those drummers really. If you enjoy his playing that’s enough.

 

I’d say Gavin Harrison is better than many of those. I think as a technician Moon should be lower as should Starr and Grohl, but it isn’t just about technique hence why Peart doesn’t always come top.

 

[tangy]

^

 

Terima kasih banyak!!

 

Though IMO I believe Bill Berry should be on that list, and is better than most of those drummers, just my opinion here folks don't get offended!!

He’s not anywhere near the class of most of those drummers really. If you enjoy his playing that’s enough.

 

I’d say Gavin Harrison is better than many of those. I think as a technician Moon should be lower as should Starr and Grohl, but it isn’t just about technique hence why Peart doesn’t always come top.

 

Indeed and for phil collins to be rated one above tommy lee....

[vaportrailer]

^

Terima kasih banyak!!

 

 

You speak Indonesian?! :o Anda pintar!

Selamat Hari Natal! (dan Tahun Baru) :cheers:

[Permanent-Rush]

^

Terima kasih banyak!!

 

 

You speak Indonesian?! :o Anda pintar!

Selamat Hari Natal! (dan Tahun Baru) :cheers:

 

Ya, saya berbicara Bahasa Indonesia, untuk seorang sedikit sementara sekarang!! Saya melakukan untuk seorang teman-teman!! :cheers:

Edited December 24, 2018 by Permanent-Rush