RPG: Genesis vs. The Miracle

[Entre_Perpetuo]

Well darn, here I am usually silently complaining the random poll generator never picks many of my favorite albums, and here it goes and pits two albums I love dearly from my favorite bands up against each other... tough call to make here... tough call Edited July 6, 2021 by Entre_Perpetuo

[invisible airwave]

What my avatar would pick.

[The Cat 3]

Genesis

 

Queen

 

I Want it All

[bluefox4000]

Genesis-The much better album over all

Queen-this was a TOUGH choice love both bands Queen edged it though.

I want it all-A kick ass anthem on a weak sauce album (sorry EP, LOL)

 

Mick

[Entre_Perpetuo]

Genesis-The much better album over all

Queen-this was a TOUGH choice love both bands Queen edged it though.

I want it all-A kick ass anthem on a weak sauce album (sorry EP, LOL)

 

Mick

 

Hey it's okay I know The Miracle is out there for the few of us who love it!

[zepphead]

An interesting choice.

 

Both albums are from bands in their later stages.

 

As such I voted as follows -

 

Album - The Miracle. Not their best but still pretty good. As for the Genesis album, by this stage I had lost all interest in them.

 

Band - Taking Gabriel/Hackett era Genesis into account, Genesis take it.

 

Song - I Want It All easily.

Edited July 6, 2021 by zepphead

[Nova Carmina]

Yeah, pretty much what Zepphead said ^^^!

 

Genesis (although this is about the eighth or ninth Genesis album I would pick up to listen to)

Genesis (taking the whole arc into account, and not merely the version of the band at the time of this album)

"I Want It All" is a great song, and wins the "all" battle easily.

[ReRushed]

Genesis for the sweep.

 

"That's All" is one of my all-time favorite pop songs. I love Phil Collins' Ringo inspired drumming.

[invisible airwave]

Not a big fan of The Miracle but I Want It All still rocks to this day.

[chemistry1973]

That's All is a brilliant pop song.

 

I Want It All is Queen trying to find it's footing in the 80s.

[Segue Myles]

Genesis

 

And I hate I Want It All

 

Shit song

[stoopid]

Genesis

 

And I hate I Want It All

 

Shit song

 

But That's All is one of their worse, IMO. lol To add insult to injury, the rest of that album is super strong. Comes off as the obligatory 'single'.

 

Genesis, Genesis, Queen.

Edited July 9, 2021 by stoopid

[Derek19]

I've liked Genesis, and Queen, but Genesis more, and I prefer Queen's "I Want It All" over Genesis' "that's All".

[Chicken hawk]

Genesis for me.

 

BUT i got into Queen more after i saw the big movie " Bohemian Rhapsody" I love Queen .