Led Zeppelin Album Elimination - Final Round

[toscanobarga]

This really should have been a IV vs. PG contest, but either way 2 great albums are in the final round.

 

I'm voting off II.

[Lucas]

III, Houses and II are my favorites

 

So IV gets my vote here

[ReRushed]

I understand the IV is overplayed and overrated arguments. But it is a really, really, really good album. Some albums transcend its genre or fan base for good reason. IV is a perfect example.

 

Goodbye II.

Edited December 12, 2016 by ReRushed

[Blue J]

Between these two, it's the first one- which is the second one.

 

II ;)

[YYZumbi]

II

[Disembodied Spirit]

I want Coda back

[goose]

I want Coda back

Oooooooh, yeah! :7up:

 

[Blue J]

I want Presence and III back

 

Me too...but then I'd have to choose between them.

 

:|

[Stormtron]

IV

[Wil1972]

So which group are we voting on next? This has been fun. (I voted II BTW.)

[Digital Dad]

So which group are we voting on next? This has been fun. (I voted II BTW.)

 

Whomever we vote on will be wrong.

[Chronos]

Voting off II, my second-favorite Zep album after IV.

[custom55]

I'm thinking...... back later.

 

 

http://i178.photobucket.com/albums/w276/custom55/80e6a9bd-1590-4804-a46a-d9935686ea02_zpskc3flp69.jpg

Edited December 12, 2016 by custom55

[Segue Myles]

Feedback

[Lorraine]

Neither one is the best LZ album.

 

I protest this bogus poll.

[ReRushed]

Neither one is the best LZ album.

 

I protest this bogus poll.

Recount!

 

You will have to raise $3,000,000.00, though.

[Segue Myles]

Neither one is the best LZ album.

 

I protest this bogus poll.

 

This is why I vote Feedback

 

The best Led Zeppelin album is The Soft Parade.

[Blue J]

Neither one is the best LZ album.

 

I protest this bogus poll.

Recount!

 

You will have to raise $3,000,000.00, though.

 

Hahaaaa!

[Blue J]

Neither one is the best LZ album.

 

I protest this bogus poll.

 

Which one is, in your opinion?

[Lorraine]

Neither one is the best LZ album.

 

I protest this bogus poll.

Recount!

 

You will have to raise $3,000,000.00, though.

 

You raise the money.

 

I'll riot and smash some windows. That's always effective. :eyeroll:

Edited December 12, 2016 by Lorraine

[ReRushed]

Neither one is the best LZ album.

 

I protest this bogus poll.

Recount!

 

You will have to raise $3,000,000.00, though.

 

You raise the money.

 

I'll riot and smash some windows. That's always effective. :eyeroll:

As long as III or Presence doesn't win I'm content.

[Lorraine]

I really would love to see how the same poll would do on an LZ fan forum.

[Rick N. Backer]

IV is one of the all time great rock albums, of course. But you wanna know something? It doesn't have a song that reaches the peaks of Whole Lotta Love and Heartbreaker. Even the album's one "down" moment, Moby Dick, actually has an amazing riff driving it.

 

I'm voting for II. It's going to lose, and I can see why, but it remains my favorite Zeppelin album.

[ReRushed]

IV is one of the all time great rock albums, of course. But you wanna know something? It doesn't have a song that reaches the peaks of Whole Lotta Love and Heartbreaker. Even the album's one "down" moment, Moby Dick, actually has an amazing riff driving it.

 

I'm voting for II. It's going to lose, and I can see why, but it remains my favorite Zeppelin album.

I think "Heartbreaker" is overrated. I'll take the riff and groove of "Black Dog" any day of the week. "Whole Lotta Love" is a production marvel wrapped around an all-time riff, but I would say the production on "When the Levee Breaks" is as innovative and impressive. That drum sound is massive. Anyway, to each his own. It's all great music.*

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

* Ripped off or not.

[Segue Myles]

IV is one of the all time great rock albums, of course. But you wanna know something? It doesn't have a song that reaches the peaks of Whole Lotta Love and Heartbreaker. Even the album's one "down" moment, Moby Dick, actually has an amazing riff driving it.

 

I'm voting for II. It's going to lose, and I can see why, but it remains my favorite Zeppelin album.

I think "Heartbreaker" is overrated. I'll take the riff and groove of "Black Dog" any day of the week. "Whole Lotta Love" is a production marvel wrapped around an all-time riff, but I would say the production on "When the Levee Breaks" is as innovative and impressive. That drum sound is massive. Anyway, to each his own. It's all great music.*

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

* Ripped off or not.

 

All of this. Footnote included!!

 

A*