Who is Smarter, Neil "the Professor" Peart or the Astrophysicist Brian May PHD?

[treeduck]

Who is smarter???

[Maverick]

BM.

[Mr. Not]

May because he has the PHD and Peart is the highschool dropout

 

That's how it works.

 

(really though, it's probably May)

[treeduck]

Peart is the fake professor who is just a heavy metal snob in actuality! He's a posh biker!

[Mr. Not]

Who would make a better Rabbi, Geddy or May?

[EagleMoon]

Brian May any day of the week. Except maybe Saturday evenings when he's in the bubble bath.

[Relayer2112]

I enjoy Neil's playing much more, but Brian is the smarter dude.

[Hatchetaxe&saw]

Dr. Bri.

[condemned2bfree]

Patrick moore says; Bri's ya guy

[Rod in Toronto]

I enjoy Neil's playing much more, but Brian is the smarter dude.

 

Spot on!

[blueschica]

Gotta go for the PhD in Astrophysics, but maybe it's a right brain - left brain thing? One is awesome in science and one in literary endeavors; both in music :) Edited May 21, 2015 by blueschica

[treeduck]

Some miserable sneaks are voting for their idol Peart knowing full well it's dastardly lie and then skulking off in a cowardly manner without posting! get back in here and defend your voting choice! :madra:

[x1yyz]

Just because May has more schooling doesn't mean he is smarter. I won't vote because I have no way of knowing who is smarter.

[treeduck]

 

Just because May has more schooling doesn't mean he is smarter. I won't vote because I have no way of knowing who is smarter.

May's schooling was done on the road with QUEEN!

Edited May 21, 2015 by treeduck

[The Cat 3]

May all the way!

[Ancient Ways]

Define "smarter."

[Tombstone Mountain]

Define "smarter."

Really. I know a ton of people with more degrees than a thermometer, but lack the ability to even "teach"...and they're professors. I'm going with Neil's lyrics as an indicator of intelligence. Brian May, if he graduated with a Phd had to write, lemme read his stuff then I'll tell you my opinion. Anybody have his dissertation and thesis?

Edited May 22, 2015 by Tombstone Mountain

[Tombstone Mountain]

Just because May has more schooling doesn't mean he is smarter. I won't vote because I have no way of knowing who is smarter.

May's schooling was done on the road with QUEEN!

So it was mail order? Neil did schooling on the road. All three had Berlitz training in French.

[goose]

Did Neil build his own drums from scratch? Ok, then. Brian.

[treeduck]

Did Neil build his own drums from scratch? Ok, then. Brian.

That's true May is just a naturally intelligent guy, and he built that guitar when he was just a kid. What was Peart doing then?? Shoveling cow shit?? Not even that probably!

[treeduck]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PiGnzVPViTg

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3cGcXUOLaBg

[driven_to_xanadu]

Brian May. Peart is a wannabe intellectual..

[x1yyz]

Define "smarter."

Really. I know a ton of people with more degrees than a thermometer, but lack the ability to even "teach"...and they're professors. I'm going with Neil's lyrics as an indicator of intelligence. Brian May, if he graduated with a Phd had to write, lemme read his stuff then I'll tell you my opinion. Anybody have his dissertation and thesis?

 

The Internet tells me he completed his PhD at Imperial College London in 2007. His dissertation is "A Survey of Radial Velocities in the Zodiacal Dust Cloud" and is apparently only available via purchase, although some of it can be read here.

[RUSHHEAD666]

Peart is the fake professor who is just a heavy metal snob in actuality! He's a posh biker!

 

So basically it's true then. Mike Portnoy is Neil Peart 2.0

[RUSHHEAD666]

MAY DAY!