Steevo Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 I am so SICK of people saying sloppy, no technique blah blah...what about FEEL/CREATIVITY FCOL, not everyone has to sound like a damn metronome. Yes to Page and Yes to Hendrix, they command more in their little finger than most players today. And please leave the Kurt Cobains out of it, they're not even worth mentioning in this, and I love Nirvana. I still say Clapton is way overrated though, sorry, especially when you compare him to the creative genius of Page or Beck. No offence Ancient, just the way I see it fwiw. 2
Steevo Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 Hammet too, a lot of his solos have the same shape - sound the same? Oh he's awful; predictable and boring. Wanna take an axe to his damn wah as well. As far as metal, he is the clear winner! Ok, that's enough rage for one day...
goose Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 I am so SICK of people saying sloppy, no technique blah blah...what about FEEL/CREATIVITY FCOL, not everyone has to sound like a damn metronome. Yes to Page and Yes to Hendrix, they command more in their little finger than most players today. And please leave the Kurt Cobains out of it, they're not even worth mentioning in this, and I love Nirvana. I still say Clapton is way overrated though, sorry, especially when you compare him to the creative genius of Page or Beck. No offence Ancient, just the way I see it fwiw.Clapton has great tone and technique, but I don't see him as a tremendous innovator. Page gets dogged as having ripped off the classic bluesmen...but how does Clapton get a pass? Eric is obviously an amazing talent, but his godly status among the rock critics makes him the most overrated for me. 1
Mr. Not Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 (edited) Slash... Definitely Slash. Maybe the guitarists of Metallica too, James and Kirk. There's one time I can listen to Metallica: when someone else is covering them. Edited May 13, 2013 by Mr. IsNot
Enemy Within 77 Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 Sammy Hagar, he is definately overratedWhat? You hardly hear anything of Hagar's playing. If anything he's underrated- not a guitar god, but the man can play. 1
MMCXII Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 Jimmy Page. He might have been a creative genius in the studio and a great guitar player but he doesn't belong on the top of every "best guitarist" list like he seems to be.. 1
treeduck Posted May 13, 2013 Author Posted May 13, 2013 Jimmy Page. He might have been a creative genius in the studio and a great guitar player but he doesn't belong on the top of every "best guitarist" list like he seems to be.. http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-KtSB1ImLapM/TxTi5MaJibI/AAAAAAAAAeE/97mtTdMY_P0/s1600/Spock_Finds_You_Illogical.jpg 2
bathory Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 Jimmy Page. He might have been a creative genius in the studio and a great guitar player but he doesn't belong on the top of every "best guitarist" list like he seems to be.. http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-KtSB1ImLapM/TxTi5MaJibI/AAAAAAAAAeE/97mtTdMY_P0/s1600/Spock_Finds_You_Illogical.jpg hahah, no shit! he talks about how great jimmy page is and then says he's not a great guitarist? 1
Tombstone Mountain Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 Sammy Hagar, he is definately overratedWhat? You hardly hear anything of Hagar's playing. If anything he's underrated- not a guitar god, but the man can play.It was obvious that he pushed EVH as well in terms of upping his game. Hagar is no slouch 1
bathory Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 I feel like most of you don't understand what the word overrated means...this thread isn't for guitarists you simply dislike. 1
Tombstone Mountain Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 John Petrucci, fantastic technique but no feel or soul. Just beats out Satriani.Holdsworth fits this bill as well.
bathory Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 I'm not sure if you guys have soul-meters, but I don't think any of you can honestly tell me that you can tell whether or not a guitarist has "soul" or not... 2
bathory Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 guys like petrucci, malmsteen and holdsworth really seem to enjoy what they're doing. they've dedicated their lives to playing guitar! and somehow you all have the magical power to read their souls. 2
Tombstone Mountain Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 guys like petrucci, malmsteen and holdsworth really seem to enjoy what they're doing. they've dedicated their lives to playing guitar! and somehow you all have the magical power to read their souls.I'm writing in response to OP statements about Ted Nugent, whom I don't enjoy all that much. He's soul-less, his chops suck, and he's way overrated according to the OP. Well, I disagree. The OP has given us displays of Holdsworth's virtuosity plenty of times, yet I can't think of one memorable thing he wrote. I've spent lotsa dollars and much tim trying to appreciate his music. Can anyone give me something of Holdsworth's that will make me think he's nothing more than some shredder who's "a really great phraser"? Where's the feel? Where's the soul? His guitar playing is stunning in terms of playing weird shit. But according to Treeduck he's speaking an " advanced harmonic language". But it's so far out there people sleep during his shows. Or should I say, guitarists who drag they're significant other to see him play. Please give me some stuff that will help me see the light...I'm not for slamming AH...I'm just applying the same light TD did on the Nuge, to Allan Holdsworth. As the great musicians from the band Poison once lamented "Gimme something to believe in"
Rick N. Backer Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 Yngwie does absolutely nothing for me. Great call. He has absolutely zero feel for a song. He and Ronnie James Dio did a cover of Dream On. Horrible. Because of Malmsteen. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tZamjrXCDvo
Rick N. Backer Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 Along the same lines as Malmsteen, I'll nominate Steve Vai. All the dexterity in the world. Completely bloodless though. Which is why, incidentally, Joe Perry doesn't belong on this list. Perry may not be a virtuoso by the standard of EVH, Vai, Malmsteen, etc., but he's written some great tunes, and plays what's appropriate for them. And I don't hear many people overrating his playing ability.
Turbine Freight Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 Along the same lines as Malmsteen, I'll nominate Steve Vai. All the dexterity in the world. Completely bloodless though. Which is why, incidentally, Joe Perry doesn't belong on this list. Perry may not be a virtuoso by the standard of EVH, Vai, Malmsteen, etc., but he's written some great tunes, and plays what's appropriate for them. And I don't hear many people overrating his playing ability. :goodone: 1
geddyforlife Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 I WAS going to say Keith Richards but then I looked up the definition of overrated and realized Keith didn't fit.
geddyforlife Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 (edited) Wes Borland Edited May 13, 2013 by geddyforlife
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now