Pink Floyd vs. Yes

[The Owl]

This is a really hard choice for me. I am giving the edge to Floyd, but it's still really hard.

 

The third choice is kind of a joke, that group was still Yes in all but name. (And that album is really good as well)

[rushgoober]

As much as I love and am crazy about Yes...

 

 

 

... Pink Floyd

[raygun47]

Floyd today...probably Yes tomorrow. Love 'em both.

[fledgehog]

i can't decide. at all.

[Fridge]

Yes, and it's not even close

[The Rocinante]

Pink Floyd, no contest.

 

Why include ABWH? IMO it's just a shitty version of classic-era Yes, they never did anything worthwhile.

[GeddyRulz]

Tough pick, both great.

 

I confess I like listening to Yes more, although Floyd is proably the better (and more historically important) group.

 

I went with what I like: Yes.

[moltenlava]

Wow. This one is real difficult, but have to go with the YES. 'Quantity' wins out here. Both are of high quality, but YES just has more stuff. Of all the many, many things I listen to, YES is probably my overall favourite band. Love all eras, almost equally.

 

 

[Hatchetaxe&saw]

Ooh, I love both, but it has to be Yes.

[PhilCastro]

for Yes

[TheRocinanteKid]

Pink Floyd; They never made anything as horrible as the clusterfuck of albums that is anything after 90125.

 

Both great bands at one time or another though.

[ReRushed]

Gotta go with Floyd on this one. They have better and more consistent albums.

[Turn Me On Dead Man]

I can't decide because I haven't listened to many Yes albums. I'm a HUGE fan of the Floyd, though.

[LoneStar Boogie]

YES...no contest. At their best, nobody was better.

[Maestro]

Ah-Ha, to (but, why not both?)

[theworkingman]

Can't choose.

[moltenlava]

QUOTE (fledgehog @ Aug 8 2008, 11:29 PM)

i can't decide. at all.

You don't have to anymore. Life is like a Chinese Restaurant. Pick one from Column A and one from B. But, save room for the fried ice cream. I heard it's to die for.

 

 

 

[Finding IT]

QUOTE (rushgoober @ Aug 8 2008, 11:17 PM)

As much as I love and am crazy about Yes... ... Pink Floyd

Well welcome to the light. Thought this day would never come.

[Finding IT]

QUOTE (LoneStar Boogie @ Aug 9 2008, 10:54 AM)

YES...no contest. At their best, nobody was better.

Not even SRV?

[Finding IT]

I like Jon Anderson's voice ... for driving rodents out of the neighborhood.

 

Not even close for me. Floyd.

[PanaceaFish]

I love both Floyd and Yes so it was hard to choose...

 

But in the end, Yes won my vote..

[Show Don't Tell]

Pink Floyd.

 

No comparison.

[rushbass]

Love them both, but gotta go with YES!

[moltenlava]

Who would win in a knife fight, Richard Wright or Richard Wakeman?

 

 

 

[Joshua]

Damn. Can't decide. Unable to vote.