Jump to content

Vocal Coach Reacts to Geddy's Singing

snowdogged

By snowdogged
in Rush

 Share

Recommended Posts

snowdogged

snowdogged

Posted
Posted (edited)

To my surprise, she actually seems to think his vocals are pretty good here.

Edited by snowdogged
  • Like 1
Lorraine

Lorraine

Posted
Posted

I don't think she knows what he used to sound like. She ought to listen to the album cut then go back and listen to this 2010 version.

 

Love that song no matter which version though! :)

  • Like 4
GeddysMullet

GeddysMullet

Posted
Posted
One thing that has never been in doubt is that Geddy knows how to sing properly and knows how use his voice effectively, whether you like the way it sounds or not.
  • Like 1
treeduck

treeduck

Posted
Posted

One thing that has never been in doubt is that Geddy knows how to sing properly and knows how use his voice effectively, whether you like the way it sounds or not.

Mullie you're back in the saddle once again!

Lorraine

Lorraine

Posted
Posted (edited)

Who the hell would recommend she listen to this live version?

 

Shame Rush fans!

 

 

 

SHAME!

 

SHAME!!

Edited by Lorraine
  • Like 2
Fridge

Fridge

Posted
Posted
The request was from Patreon followers...ie paying customers......no way was she going to risk upsetting them
goose

goose

Posted
Posted

Really????? the yodel voice crack-y marble mouthed version!!!!!

 

That was made to piss ME off, lol

 

Mick

Maybe this will bring you in off the ledge...

 

  • Like 4
bluefox4000

bluefox4000

Posted
Posted

Really????? the yodel voice crack-y marble mouthed version!!!!!

 

That was made to piss ME off, lol

 

Mick

Maybe this will bring you in off the ledge...

 

 

This is the version she should have reacted to IMO

 

best one.

 

Mick

Lorraine

Lorraine

Posted
Posted

Really????? the yodel voice crack-y marble mouthed version!!!!!

 

That was made to piss ME off, lol

 

Mick

Maybe this will bring you in off the ledge...

 

 

:7up:

  • Like 1
J2112YYZ

J2112YYZ

Posted
Posted

The request was from Patreon followers...ie paying customers......no way was she going to risk upsetting them

 

Oh, I totally get that. My issue is with the fans who picked this particular version.

  • Like 3
SusanMistyT

SusanMistyT

Posted
Posted

One thing that has never been in doubt is that Geddy knows how to sing properly and knows how use his voice effectively, whether you like the way it sounds or not.

 

Amen to THAT!!! I just had it with folks who complained about his voice so much. It not liked the fans (some of them) could do it better!! I LOVE his voice not matter what age our beloved Geddy is...I love his 80s era voice so...and plus, Geddy been singing since he was very young child anyway, it was during 1968-69 he started to used that soaring and high vocals!!! And welcome back!!!!

GeddysMullet

GeddysMullet

Posted
Posted

One thing that has never been in doubt is that Geddy knows how to sing properly and knows how use his voice effectively, whether you like the way it sounds or not.

 

Amen to THAT!!! I just had it with folks who complained about his voice so much. It not liked the fans (some of them) could do it better!! I LOVE his voice not matter what age our beloved Geddy is...I love his 80s era voice so...and plus, Geddy been singing since he was very young child anyway, it was during 1968-69 he started to used that soaring and high vocals!!! And welcome back!!!!

 

I love Geddy's voice the way I'd love a friend who comforts me when I'm down.

:wub:

Narps

Narps

Posted
Posted
I listened to about 10 seconds and sadly had to shut it down. Out of sheer boredom I have actually been checking things like this out lately. None from her however...
Lorraine

Lorraine

Posted
Posted

I listened to about 10 seconds and sadly had to shut it down. Out of sheer boredom I have actually been checking things like this out lately. None from her however...

Listen to this one Narps:

  • Like 2
Narps

Narps

Posted
Posted

I listened to about 10 seconds and sadly had to shut it down. Out of sheer boredom I have actually been checking things like this out lately. None from her however...

Listen to this one Narps:

Ahhh this may have been the "Daniel Boone coonskin hat" hairdo days but his voice had matured to as perfect as it ever was. I was oh so close to jumping from the balcony. Officially talked down. Thanks...
  • Like 1
Lorraine

Lorraine

Posted
Posted

I listened to about 10 seconds and sadly had to shut it down. Out of sheer boredom I have actually been checking things like this out lately. None from her however...

Listen to this one Narps:

Ahhh this may have been the "Daniel Boone coonskin hat" hairdo days but his voice had matured to as perfect as it ever was. I was oh so close to jumping from the balcony. Officially talked down. Thanks...

I love that version too. From the good old days. :cheers:

  • Like 1
SusanMistyT

SusanMistyT

Posted
Posted

One thing that has never been in doubt is that Geddy knows how to sing properly and knows how use his voice effectively, whether you like the way it sounds or not.

 

Amen to THAT!!! I just had it with folks who complained about his voice so much. It not liked the fans (some of them) could do it better!! I LOVE his voice not matter what age our beloved Geddy is...I love his 80s era voice so...and plus, Geddy been singing since he was very young child anyway, it was during 1968-69 he started to used that soaring and high vocals!!! And welcome back!!!!

 

I love Geddy's voice the way I'd love a friend who comforts me when I'm down.

:wub:

 

I know!! Ps I LOVE your username!!!

Narps

Narps

Posted
Posted

I listened to about 10 seconds and sadly had to shut it down. Out of sheer boredom I have actually been checking things like this out lately. None from her however...

Listen to this one Narps:

Ahhh this may have been the "Daniel Boone coonskin hat" hairdo days but his voice had matured to as perfect as it ever was. I was oh so close to jumping from the balcony. Officially talked down. Thanks...

I love that version too. From the good old days. :cheers:

Yep. The last show I went to before I took my kids in more recent years was in 1987. A great mixture of old and "new" Rush in those years and Ged could still bring it...
Fridge

Fridge

Posted
Posted

One thing that has never been in doubt is that Geddy knows how to sing properly and knows how use his voice effectively, whether you like the way it sounds or not.

 

Amen to THAT!!! I just had it with folks who complained about his voice so much. It not liked the fans (some of them) could do it better!! I LOVE his voice not matter what age our beloved Geddy is...I love his 80s era voice so...and plus, Geddy been singing since he was very young child anyway, it was during 1968-69 he started to used that soaring and high vocals!!! And welcome back!!!!

 

Whether fans could sing better than Geddy...is a moot point. They are not the ones exploiting their talent for commercial gain.

 

I realise that that there are some fans who think our favourite Canadian power trio are beyond criticism, but there are many of us who don't think that way, and it is an inescapable fact that there has been a big drop off in quality (not just vocals) since the late 80s.

 

They had an unbelievable golden run from 76-82 which is way more than most bands acheived, but their output has to be judged without confirmation bias, and sadly they were a shadow of their former selves for a long, long time.

 

Don't agree?...fine, it's called opinion and I promise not to be upset :-)

  • Like 5
zappafrank

zappafrank

Posted
Posted

...it is an inescapable fact that there has been a big drop off in quality (not just vocals) since the late 80s.

 

They had an unbelievable golden run from 76-82 which is way more than most bands acheived, but their output has to be judged without confirmation bias, and sadly they were a shadow of their former selves for a long, long time.

 

Don't agree?...fine, it's called opinion and I promise not to be upset :-)

 

 

...just saying

  • Like 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...