Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

It's upsetting to me to see how many people would actually be okay with replacing Neil...

Do you have a favorite sports team? If so, NONE of the players on that team were present when your grandfather was cheering for the same team. You still love the team just as much. I don't see why bands can't continue the same way.

 

Menudo was a good example of this.

 

I think KISS intends to do the same thing...read something Gene said over the summer... they intend to continue to licence the charachters after Gene and Paul retire. So the band can live on. Because KISS is bigger than any of them. Or something to that effect.

Gene is the king of rock & roll marketing, and will squeeze every nickel he can out the Kiss brand. His/their main motivation has always been the all mighty dollar - crappy music, & over the top theatrics, by semi-talented "artists/musicians". As opposed to Rush, whose main motivation was just making great music. Incredibly complicated compositions played by highly accomplished, talented, and true musicians. There is a difference.

 

Oh, I agree. A purely creative band is a mich different thing.

 

Was simply pointing out that some entites have or are planning to stay on the shelf past their expected lifespan.

Posted

Oh please. Anyone can start a rumor.

 

This is from a man that works in music, and that doesn't speak if it's not necessary.

It's certainly a rumour, but of the best kind ;)

 

Like I said. Anyone can start a rumor.

Posted

Oh please. Anyone can start a rumor.

 

This is from a man that works in music, and that doesn't speak if it's not necessary.

It's certainly a rumour, but of the best kind ;)

 

Like I said. Anyone can start a rumor.

 

Of course. Rumours create religions.

 

  • Like 2
Posted

It's upsetting to me to see how many people would actually be okay with replacing Neil...

Do you have a favorite sports team? If so, NONE of the players on that team were present when your grandfather was cheering for the same team. You still love the team just as much. I don't see why bands can't continue the same way.

 

See Yes.

Posted (edited)

It's upsetting to me to see how many people would actually be okay with replacing Neil...

Do you have a favorite sports team? If so, NONE of the players on that team were present when your grandfather was cheering for the same team. You still love the team just as much. I don't see why bands can't continue the same way.

Okay, so then picture this. You play in a band until you're in your sixties. You put literal years of work into all the material your band puts out, slaving over albums and tours for decades on end. You decided after forty some-odd years that you're done, hooray. Then some prick joins your other buddies and replaces you in the band, which uses the same name it did when you were there. Essentially, the aforementioned prick is taking credit for all the work that you did. What did he do for the band until this point? Nada. It's someone writing his name on your project when you did all the work. Sports teams are different—you don't see Van Halen trading Eddie to U2 for The Edge, do you? Music doesn't work that way. They're two totally different things. :)

Edited by Disk98
Posted
Weren't there a lot more posts in this thread? Did they get deleted? Big Brother?
Posted

Weren't there a lot more posts in this thread? Did they get deleted? Big Brother?

Neil hacked the TRF server and started deleting stuff. Careful what you say.

Posted (edited)

And I was all ready to start a rumor that they agreed to play five nights in a row in the Pacific Northwest early next year.

 

:sigh:

 

Oh well. Next time.

 

On to R50!

Edited by Lorraine
  • Like 1
Posted

And I was all ready to start a rumor that they agreed to play five nights in a row in the Pacific Northwest early next year.

 

:sigh:

 

Oh well. Next time.

 

Onto R50!

 

Yep, Neil will be well-rested by then. :LOL:

  • Like 1
Posted

What happened that posts got deleted?

 

I am not sure, as I don't recall how long this thread once was. I would have thought the "Is Neil a selfish prick?" thread would be a better target for that myself, but.... :huh:

Posted

What happened that posts got deleted?

 

I am not sure, as I don't recall how long this thread once was. I would have thought the "Is Neil a selfish prick?" thread would be a better target for that myself, but.... :huh:

 

or the drunk girls thread. :facepalm: But, what do we know? :huh:

  • Like 2
Posted

Did posts really get deleted?

 

Yes. They disappeared.

Posted
How is this STILL A THING?
Posted

How is this STILL A THING?

 

You mean the title of the thread or what was actually discussed? :LOL:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...