ok ladies, here's the most important question ever.

[Lorraine]

Speaking from someone who's been cheated on, this thread is disturbing

 

Even though almost every person said "if he was single?"

Hey for my dream date he doesn't even have to be single. Im awesome like that.

 

 

I didn't read any responses when I posted that. Just the op which reminds you that they're married. And says nothing about it being a fantasy! Whatever floats your boat I guess. Just my opinion.

 

It is comforting to know the boys can resist all the sluts they probably meet though. Pretty cool they've all been happily married for so long!

 

"All of the sluts"? That's a little harsh isn't it? I have to wonder how many women went after Geddy or Alex because they knew little about their personal lives or that they were even married to begin with.

 

Who says I'm talking about them?? I just mean women that go after guys that know they're in a happy marriage. I'll just call them home wreckers if you prefer..

 

In other words, you're talking about a totally different situation than anything being discussed in this thread. Lighten up, man.

 

Lighten up? Who says I'm pissed off? Lol

and I thought the thread was about sleeping with married guys in Rush??

 

I certainly didn't say you were pissed off. From your contributions to this thread, I'd probably describe you as uptight rather than pissed off, but given that it's your own phrase, perhaps pissed off would be a better description after all.

 

I just wonder why you have to come in here and get all "disturbed" and righteous about "sluts" and "homewreckers" when it should be clear to anyone with a functioning brain that this thread is just a bit of harmless fun. It's not like we're in here plotting to take the guys in Rush away from their wives. I don't see why it's necessary for you to read it if all it does is rile you up and make you feel the need to judge people and try to make them feel bad about themselves.

 

Maybe you aren't plotting...

 

*goes back to plotting*

 

Leave it to you, Gangster! :laughing guy: ;)

[MMCXII]

Speaking from someone who's been cheated on, this thread is disturbing

 

Even though almost every person said "if he was single?"

Hey for my dream date he doesn't even have to be single. Im awesome like that.

 

 

I didn't read any responses when I posted that. Just the op which reminds you that they're married. And says nothing about it being a fantasy! Whatever floats your boat I guess. Just my opinion.

 

It is comforting to know the boys can resist all the sluts they probably meet though. Pretty cool they've all been happily married for so long!

 

"All of the sluts"? That's a little harsh isn't it? I have to wonder how many women went after Geddy or Alex because they knew little about their personal lives or that they were even married to begin with.

 

Who says I'm talking about them?? I just mean women that go after guys that know they're in a happy marriage. I'll just call them home wreckers if you prefer..

 

In other words, you're talking about a totally different situation than anything being discussed in this thread. Lighten up, man.

 

Lighten up? Who says I'm pissed off? Lol

and I thought the thread was about sleeping with married guys in Rush??

 

I certainly didn't say you were pissed off. From your contributions to this thread, I'd probably describe you as uptight rather than pissed off, but given that it's your own phrase, perhaps pissed off would be a better description after all.

 

I just wonder why you have to come in here and get all "disturbed" and righteous about "sluts" and "homewreckers" when it should be clear to anyone with a functioning brain that this thread is just a bit of harmless fun. It's not like we're in here plotting to take the guys in Rush away from their wives. I don't see why it's necessary for you to read it if all it does is rile you up and make you feel the need to judge people and try to make them feel bad about themselves.

 

Chill. All I said was the topic was disturbing to me.

Just based on my perspective.. You don't have to agree.

[Maverick]

Speaking from someone who's been cheated on, this thread is disturbing

 

Even though almost every person said "if he was single?"

Hey for my dream date he doesn't even have to be single. Im awesome like that.

 

 

I didn't read any responses when I posted that. Just the op which reminds you that they're married. And says nothing about it being a fantasy! Whatever floats your boat I guess. Just my opinion.

 

It is comforting to know the boys can resist all the sluts they probably meet though. Pretty cool they've all been happily married for so long!

 

"All of the sluts"? That's a little harsh isn't it? I have to wonder how many women went after Geddy or Alex because they knew little about their personal lives or that they were even married to begin with.

 

Who says I'm talking about them?? I just mean women that go after guys that know they're in a happy marriage. I'll just call them home wreckers if you prefer..

 

In other words, you're talking about a totally different situation than anything being discussed in this thread. Lighten up, man.

 

Lighten up? Who says I'm pissed off? Lol

and I thought the thread was about sleeping with married guys in Rush??

 

I certainly didn't say you were pissed off. From your contributions to this thread, I'd probably describe you as uptight rather than pissed off, but given that it's your own phrase, perhaps pissed off would be a better description after all.

 

I just wonder why you have to come in here and get all "disturbed" and righteous about "sluts" and "homewreckers" when it should be clear to anyone with a functioning brain that this thread is just a bit of harmless fun. It's not like we're in here plotting to take the guys in Rush away from their wives. I don't see why it's necessary for you to read it if all it does is rile you up and make you feel the need to judge people and try to make them feel bad about themselves.

 

Chill. All I said was the topic was disturbing to me.

Just based on my perspective.. You don't have to agree.

 

Here's a thought: stop reading and posting in this thread.

[MMCXII]

Speaking from someone who's been cheated on, this thread is disturbing

 

Even though almost every person said "if he was single?"

Hey for my dream date he doesn't even have to be single. Im awesome like that.

 

 

I didn't read any responses when I posted that. Just the op which reminds you that they're married. And says nothing about it being a fantasy! Whatever floats your boat I guess. Just my opinion.

 

It is comforting to know the boys can resist all the sluts they probably meet though. Pretty cool they've all been happily married for so long!

 

"All of the sluts"? That's a little harsh isn't it? I have to wonder how many women went after Geddy or Alex because they knew little about their personal lives or that they were even married to begin with.

 

Who says I'm talking about them?? I just mean women that go after guys that know they're in a happy marriage. I'll just call them home wreckers if you prefer..

 

In other words, you're talking about a totally different situation than anything being discussed in this thread. Lighten up, man.

 

Lighten up? Who says I'm pissed off? Lol

and I thought the thread was about sleeping with married guys in Rush??

 

I certainly didn't say you were pissed off. From your contributions to this thread, I'd probably describe you as uptight rather than pissed off, but given that it's your own phrase, perhaps pissed off would be a better description after all.

 

I just wonder why you have to come in here and get all "disturbed" and righteous about "sluts" and "homewreckers" when it should be clear to anyone with a functioning brain that this thread is just a bit of harmless fun. It's not like we're in here plotting to take the guys in Rush away from their wives. I don't see why it's necessary for you to read it if all it does is rile you up and make you feel the need to judge people and try to make them feel bad about themselves.

 

Chill. All I said was the topic was disturbing to me.

Just based on my perspective.. You don't have to agree.

 

Here's a thought: stop reading and posting in this thread.

 

No I shouldn't have posted in the first place! I'm just responding to comments about me now lol..

[MMCXII]

ended up here again and reading.. ya my comments seem a little harsh in hindsight. my last relationship ended hard because she cheated in the worst way and it was still fresh in my mind.. fantasizing about unattainable rock stars is a little different though.. sorry to be a thread spoiler..!

[JohnnyBlaze]

Well we all know I'm a Geddy gal, but the reason I respect so much is because they are devoted to their wives and children.

That is what makes them more appealing to me.

 

But, I'd have some wine with Geddy...well...*wink*

Exactly Lin...

I think this question was posed as in a what if they weren't married and there was an opportunity to have them in raw and salacious ways who would you take to your boudoir.

 

I think while Im attracted to Alex... it's that guitar playing that has my heart. My evening with him would prolly be lots of guitar playing and me crying for more more guitar! Him grumbling about "this demanding chick" Having some wine and laughs that make me piss my pants laughing and eventually get so trashed I pass out and Alex would be wondering WTF is wrong with this chick.

 

True Life

 

YaYa, you should see me watching the dvd's of Geddy....

And, in my daydreams.....well.

Plus, I've always said...yeah out loud (well) "Geddy you can play me like that bass"

 

Hey, I'm only human. LOL

Heh... I know what you mean. I find myself watching Exit Stage Left going... "oh Al... baby just 5 mins alone... PLAY ME THAT SONG!!!!"

Luckily Im pretty sure D has a "man-Crush" on Alex too so he gets it.

I always wanted to know: What EXACTLY is a man-crush? It's not like D would give Lifeson a handjob just because he absolutely tears it up on La Villa Strangiato, right?

[crimsonfrippy]

ended up here again and reading.. ya my comments seem a little harsh in hindsight. my last relationship ended hard because she cheated in the worst way and it was still fresh in my mind.. fantasizing about unattainable rock stars is a little different though.. sorry to be a thread spoiler..!

 

I'm so sorry that happened to you. I've been there. It sucks.

 

 

Sending hugs your way.

 

Take care,

 

frippy

[Retrospective]

Well we all know I'm a Geddy gal, but the reason I respect so much is because they are devoted to their wives and children.

That is what makes them more appealing to me.

 

But, I'd have some wine with Geddy...well...*wink*

Exactly Lin...

I think this question was posed as in a what if they weren't married and there was an opportunity to have them in raw and salacious ways who would you take to your boudoir.

 

I think while Im attracted to Alex... it's that guitar playing that has my heart. My evening with him would prolly be lots of guitar playing and me crying for more more guitar! Him grumbling about "this demanding chick" Having some wine and laughs that make me piss my pants laughing and eventually get so trashed I pass out and Alex would be wondering WTF is wrong with this chick.

 

True Life

 

YaYa, you should see me watching the dvd's of Geddy....

And, in my daydreams.....well.

Plus, I've always said...yeah out loud (well) "Geddy you can play me like that bass"

 

Hey, I'm only human. LOL

Heh... I know what you mean. I find myself watching Exit Stage Left going... "oh Al... baby just 5 mins alone... PLAY ME THAT SONG!!!!"

Luckily Im pretty sure D has a "man-Crush" on Alex too so he gets it.

I always wanted to know: What EXACTLY is a man-crush? It's not like D would give Lifeson a handjob just because he absolutely tears it up on La Villa Strangiato, right?

 

What, that's not a thing?

[MMCXII]

ended up here again and reading.. ya my comments seem a little harsh in hindsight. my last relationship ended hard because she cheated in the worst way and it was still fresh in my mind.. fantasizing about unattainable rock stars is a little different though.. sorry to be a thread spoiler..!

 

I'm so sorry that happened to you. I've been there. It sucks.

 

 

Sending hugs your way.

 

Take care,

 

frippy

 

Thank you!

[Ya_Big_Tree]

Well we all know I'm a Geddy gal, but the reason I respect so much is because they are devoted to their wives and children.

That is what makes them more appealing to me.

 

But, I'd have some wine with Geddy...well...*wink*

Exactly Lin...

I think this question was posed as in a what if they weren't married and there was an opportunity to have them in raw and salacious ways who would you take to your boudoir.

 

I think while Im attracted to Alex... it's that guitar playing that has my heart. My evening with him would prolly be lots of guitar playing and me crying for more more guitar! Him grumbling about "this demanding chick" Having some wine and laughs that make me piss my pants laughing and eventually get so trashed I pass out and Alex would be wondering WTF is wrong with this chick.

 

True Life

 

YaYa, you should see me watching the dvd's of Geddy....

And, in my daydreams.....well.

Plus, I've always said...yeah out loud (well) "Geddy you can play me like that bass"

 

Hey, I'm only human. LOL

Heh... I know what you mean. I find myself watching Exit Stage Left going... "oh Al... baby just 5 mins alone... PLAY ME THAT SONG!!!!"

Luckily Im pretty sure D has a "man-Crush" on Alex too so he gets it.

I always wanted to know: What EXACTLY is a man-crush? It's not like D would give Lifeson a handjob just because he absolutely tears it up on La Villa Strangiato, right?

BAHAHAHA!!!

Uhh no... I dont think it goes to that. That would be more on the Lust side... he would prolly drool and be in AWESTRUCK of his magnificence tho.

MMMmmm La Villa...

[Retrospective]

To answer the question at hand:

 

I'd take Neil from 1980. Just watched an interview from that year and made that decision right on the spot.

 

Alex from late 80's, early 90's. Around PoW-HYF-Presto-ish?

 

And Geddy whenever he was a skinny little thing with tight jeans.

 

The end.