THE WALL faces THE WALL, which wall is better and which wall must fall?

[treeduck]

Do you prefer the Pink Floyd album The Wall or the KANSAS song The Wall?

[Entre_Perpetuo]

I'm going to vote for the Kansas song just to be contrarian because no matter how much PF hate can be mustered around here, I really don't see The Wall losing.

[Cyclonus X-1]

I don't like either of these bands, but Kansas' The Wall is excellent, one of only two songs by them that I actually like.

[The Cat 3]

Kansas’ “The Wall” was the original and has a more positive storyline, so that’s where my vote goes.

 

(Ask me again tomorrow and I’ll say the opposite).

 

 

[custom55]

PF The Wall. You really appreciated the music more when you see it performed live. Once with Floyd and once with Roger.

 

 

 

http://youtu.be/45LXFFOqHsY

Edited August 25, 2020 by custom55

[treeduck]

I don't like either of these bands, but Kansas' The Wall is excellent, one of only two songs by them that I actually like.

Here's the 1977 live version for you then Mike, just for a bit of contrast, even though you're not big on live albums.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=neuVZHVINHw

[_hi_water._]

Love both, but Kansas song has a lot more qualities than Pink Floyd's overall The Wall album (jeez overall and wall... unintentional rhyme)

[J2112YYZ]

Pink Floyd.

 

Didn't even know that Kansas song existed until today.

[Lorraine]

[treeduck]

Pink Floyd.

 

Didn't even know that Kansas song existed until today.

Where've you been?

[treeduck]

http://youtu.be/j2pGBv9Ly6A

[Lorraine]

http://youtu.be/j2pGBv9Ly6A

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fRBsQqfOVXg

[treeduck]

http://youtu.be/j2pGBv9Ly6A

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fRBsQqfOVXg

http://youtu.be/hCahx5T8eJk

[Lorraine]

[J2112YYZ]

Pink Floyd.

 

Didn't even know that Kansas song existed until today.

Where've you been?

 

Never been a Kansas fan.

[JohnnyBlaze]

I'm going to vote for the Kansas song just to be contrarian because no matter how much PF hate can be mustered around here, I really don't see The Wall losing.

 

Floyd is losing now.

[treeduck]

I'm going to vote for the Kansas song just to be contrarian because no matter how much PF hate can be mustered around here, I really don't see The Wall losing.

 

Floyd is losing now.

They've been losing all along.

[treeduck]

http://youtu.be/3gCWOb7V-b0

[Entre_Perpetuo]

I'm going to vote for the Kansas song just to be contrarian because no matter how much PF hate can be mustered around here, I really don't see The Wall losing.

 

Floyd is losing now.

 

Dang I didn't see that coming, lol. In that case let me switch my vote back over to PF. I love that Kansas song but I don't actually think it's better than the entirety of Pink Floyd's The Wall. Was just trying to show it some love I didn't think it would get.

[JohnnyBlaze]

I'm going to vote for the Kansas song just to be contrarian because no matter how much PF hate can be mustered around here, I really don't see The Wall losing.

 

Floyd is losing now.

 

Dang I didn't see that coming, lol. In that case let me switch my vote back over to PF. I love that Kansas song but I don't actually think it's better than the entirety of Pink Floyd's The Wall. Was just trying to show it some love I didn't think it would get.

 

The Pink Floyd hate or indifference is strong on TRF.

[treeduck]

I'm going to vote for the Kansas song just to be contrarian because no matter how much PF hate can be mustered around here, I really don't see The Wall losing.

 

Floyd is losing now.

 

Dang I didn't see that coming, lol. In that case let me switch my vote back over to PF. I love that Kansas song but I don't actually think it's better than the entirety of Pink Floyd's The Wall. Was just trying to show it some love I didn't think it would get.

Traitor! :madra:

[JohnnyBlaze]

http://youtu.be/3gCWOb7V-b0

http://c1.staticflickr.com/9/8324/8131705849_8b0bd223ed_b.jpg

 

Is that Lurch?

 

[treeduck]

I'm going to vote for the Kansas song just to be contrarian because no matter how much PF hate can be mustered around here, I really don't see The Wall losing.

 

Floyd is losing now.

 

Dang I didn't see that coming, lol. In that case let me switch my vote back over to PF. I love that Kansas song but I don't actually think it's better than the entirety of Pink Floyd's The Wall. Was just trying to show it some love I didn't think it would get.

 

The Pink Floyd hate or indifference is strong on TRF.

I have all their albums but I just find it hard to even think about considering to listen to them.

[treeduck]

http://youtu.be/3gCWOb7V-b0

http://c1.staticflickr.com/9/8324/8131705849_8b0bd223ed_b.jpg

 

Is that Lurch?

Yep.

[JohnnyBlaze]

I'm going to vote for the Kansas song just to be contrarian because no matter how much PF hate can be mustered around here, I really don't see The Wall losing.

 

Floyd is losing now.

 

Dang I didn't see that coming, lol. In that case let me switch my vote back over to PF. I love that Kansas song but I don't actually think it's better than the entirety of Pink Floyd's The Wall. Was just trying to show it some love I didn't think it would get.

Traitor! :madra:

 

See, but he’s not anymore. He actually wanted to vote for Floyd but was a traitor by voting Kansas.