Supergroup Challange

[losingit2k]

Here's the Challange, create three super group and you must include one and only one of the members of Rush for each group!

 

Addendum: Group Members must be living!

 

Group One:

Neil Peart (Percussions) Rush

Robert Berry (Vocals-Add Instumentation) - Solo - 3

Jordon Rudes (Keyboards) - Dream Theater

Steve Vai (Guitars) Solo - David Lee Roth -

Tony Levin (Bass) Liquid Tension - Peter Gabriel- King Krimson

 

 

Group Two:

Geddy Lee (Bass/ Vocals) - Rush

Mike Portnoy (Drums) Dream Theater -Transatlantic -OSI- Liquid Tension

Keith Emerson (Keyboards) ELP

Trevor Rabin (Guitars) solo - Yes

 

Group Three:

Alex Lifeson (Guitars) Rush

Randy Jackson (Vocals/ Backup Guitars) Zebra

Billy Sheehan (Bass) Mr. Big- David Lee Roth

Phil Collins (Drums/ Vocals) Genesis

Jon Lord (Keyboards) Deep Purple

 

 

 

As you see I kinda went with a sound for each! I actually had Paul Rogers for vocals on the first group but decided to go with Robert Berry instead just for the tonality!

 

Anyway have fun!

 

[ColdFireYYZ]

1.

Geddy Lee - Bass/Vocals (Rush)

Robbie Kriegar - Guitars (Doors)

Rick Wakeman - Keys (Yes)

Gavin Harrison - Drums (Porcupine Tree)

 

2.

Neil Peart - Drums (Rush)

Keith Emerson - Keys (ELP)

Mick Jones - Guitar (Foreigner)

Roger Waters - Bass, Vocals (Pink Floyd)

 

 

3.

Alex Lifeson - Guitars (Rush)

Greg Lake - Bass, Lead Vocals (ELP)

Phil Ehart - Drums (Kansas)

Tony Kaye - Keys (Yes)

[Ted Barchetta]

Drums: Neil Peart

Drums also: Keith Moon

Drums too: Bill Bruford

Drums again: The Guy From Styx

 

That would sound really awesome.

[sgbam42]

Here's my three.

 

Group 1

Neil Peart (Drums)-Rush

Les Claypool (Bass)-solo-Primus

Slash (Guitar)-solo-Velvet Revolver-Slashs Snakepit-GNR

David Lee Roth (Vocals)-Van Halen

 

Group 2

Geddy Lee (Vocals/Bass)-Rush

Eddie Van Halen (Guitar)-Van Halen

Lars Ulrich (Drums)-Metallica

 

Group 3

 

Alex Lifeson (Guitar)-Rush

Flea (Bass)-Red Hot Chili Peppers-Janes Addiction

Steve Gadd (Drums)-solo

Serj Tankian (Vocals)-My Chemical Romance

 

 

[DoubleAgent204]

Group 1

---------

Geddy Lee (Bass/Vox/Keys) (Rush)

Adam Jones (Guitar) (Tool)

Brann Dailor (Drums) (Mastodon)

 

 

Group 2

------------

Neil Peart (Drums)(Rush)

Devin Townsend (Guitar/Vox) (SYL/Solo)

Adrian Smith (Guitar) (Iron Maiden)

Jason Newsted (Bass) (ex-Metallica/ex-Voivod)

 

Group 3

-----------

Alex Lifeson (Guitar)(Rush)

Toni Iommi (Guitar) (Black Sabbath/Heaven & Hell)

Ronnie James Dio (Vox)(Dio)(Heaven&Hell) RIP

Ryan Martinie (Bass)(Mudvayne)

Mario Duplantier (Drums)(Gojira)

 

 

[thelocator]

[apetersvt]

Neil Peart

John Entwistle (I know Im cheating)

Jimmy Page

 

Alex Lifeson

Les Claypool

Mike Portnoy

 

Geddy Lee

Steve Howe

Bill Bruford

 

-FYI: No singing or keyboards in any of these bands as they only play instrumentals (even Geddy). Long live the Power Trio

[thelocator]

I think that I'll deliver a second round of ensembles tomorrow, since I already have quite a number of 'specialty' groups in mind...It's cool to diversify a wee tad, mixing up the musical directions of these bands, and potentially adding/subtracting a keyboard player or a second guitarist if ya'll think the situation warrants it...Go for it...It's your own particular delusion...No one can place boundaries on your delusions...

 

Ya know what I always wanted to see someone experiment with? Holy Ship! I almost gave away a really spectacularly good idear...I believe that I posess the 'entry' that will win this thing, now that I give some serious thought to the rules...I have a particularly daring and courageous mixture of men in mind.

 

Oh, you didn't hear? losingit2k is offering up an 'all-expense paid trip' to RockCamp this year (held in Beirut) for the winner bearing the overall best Rush, spin-off ensemble...He says the perfect Rush spin-off group does exists, and is out there...We merely need to list the members and claim the prize. Simple as pie...Only restriction this year is that Kiss members are no longer considered musicians, since they've jumped the shark too many times to forgive.

 

 

[losingit2k]

QUOTE (thelocator @ Sep 5 2010, 03:37 AM)

I think that I'll deliver a second round of ensembles tomorrow, since I already have quite a number of 'specialty' groups in mind...It's cool to diversify a wee tad, mixing up the musical directions of these bands, and potentially adding/subtracting a keyboard player or a second guitarist if ya'll think the situation warrants it...Go for it...It's your own particular delusion...No one can place boundaries on your delusions... Ya know what I always wanted to see someone experiment with? Holy Ship! I almost gave away a really spectacularly good idear...I believe that I posess the 'entry' that will win this thing, now that I give some serious thought to the rules...I have a particularly daring and courageous mixture of men in mind. Oh, you didn't hear? losingit2k is offering up an 'all-expense paid trip' to RockCamp this year (held in Beirut) for the winner bearing the overall best Rush, spin-off ensemble...He says the perfect Rush spin-off group does exists, and is out there...We merely need to list the members and claim the prize. Simple as pie...Only restriction this year is that Kiss members are no longer considered musicians, since they've jumped the shark too many times to forgive.

I Have to admit your responses are always elaborate and entertaining! But you got one thing incorrect. The "All expense trip" is to the new democratic state of Iraq! This spin off Rush group will highlight the concert I'm producing there for the kind citizens of that wonderfully peaceful nation!

 

I can promiss that the concert will have many pyrotechnics!

 

 

 

[L. Wince]

Bass/Vocals - Geddy Lee

Guitar - Alex Lifeson

Drums - Neil Peart

[L. Wince]

QUOTE (sgbam42 @ Sep 4 2010, 08:54 PM)

Serj Tankian (Vocals)-My Chemical Romance

Serj is from System of a Down

[L. Wince]

Heres my kinda Serious answer:

 

1.

Neil Peart - Drums (Rush)

J. Loren - Vocals/Violin (Hurt)

Billy Howerdel - Guitar (A Perfect Circle)

Tim Commerford - Bass (Rage Against The Machine/Audioslave)

 

2.

Alex Lifeson - Guitar (Rush)

Eddie Vedder - Vocals (Pearl Jam)

Danny Carey - Drums (Tool)

Krist Novoselic - Bass (Nirvana)

 

3.

Geddy Lee - Bass (Rush)

Chris Cornell - Vocals (Soundgarden/Audioslave)

Aaron Fink - Guitar (Breaking Benjamin)

Evan Johns - Drums (Formerly of Hurt)

[losingit2k]

I do like the Alex Lifeson with Eddie Vedder combination! That would work very nicely!

 

[SilverSurfer]

Group 1

Geddy Lee (Bass/vocals)

Bill Bruford (Drums/percussion)

Brian May (Guitar)

Tony Banks (keys)

 

Group 2

Neil Peart (percussion)

Peter Gabriel (vocals)

David Gilmour (guitar)

Tony Levin (Bass)

Rick Wakeman (Kys)

 

Group 3

Alex Lifeson (Guitar)

Jon Anderson (vocals)

John Paul Jones (Bass)

Keith Emmerson (Keys)

Gavin Harrison (Percussion)

[RSRD]

1- neil-drums

frank sinatra -vox

duke ellington

 

2- alex-guitars

Alex - vocal

entwisle-bass

bonham-drums

 

3- Ged- bass/vox/keys

drum machine

 

 

[losingit2k]

QUOTE (SilverSurfer @ Sep 5 2010, 11:10 AM)

Group 1 Geddy Lee (Bass/vocals) Bill Bruford (Drums/percussion) Brian May (Guitar) Tony Banks (keys) Group 2 Neil Peart (percussion) Peter Gabriel (vocals) David Gilmour (guitar) Tony Levin (Bass) Rick Wakeman (Kys) Group 3 Alex Lifeson (Guitar) Jon Anderson (vocals) John Paul Jones (Bass) Keith Emmerson (Keys) Gavin Harrison (Percussion)

I love your second group! Very nice combination of musicians in there!

 

[priest_of_syrinx]

Group 1:

Alex Lifeson - Guitar

Danny Carey (Tool) - Drums

Chris Squire (Yes) - Bass

 

Group 2:

Geddy Lee - Bass

Ty Tabor (King's X) - Guitar

Per Wiberg (Opeth) - Keyboards

Mike Patton (Faith No More/Mr. Bungle) - Vocals

 

Group 3:

Neil Peart - Drums

Pat Metheny - Guitar

Mike Silverman (That 1 Guy) - Bass and a ton of other sounds and samples

 

[thelocator]

All following Supergroup combos occuring during the eras between -1974 and like 1981, while Rush members are still in their 20's.

 

 

-Heavy Metal-

 

Ronnie James Dio - vocals

Glenn Tipton - guitar

Alex Lifeson - guitar

Steve Harris - bass

Cozy Powell - drums

 

-Jazz/Rock Fusion-

 

Pat Martino - guitars

Geddy Lee - 6-String Bass

Michael Brecker - tenor saxophone

Joey DeFrancesco - organ

Steve Gadd - drums

 

-Progressive Rock-

 

Ian Anderson (Jethro Tull) - vocals, flute, acoustic guitar

Kerry Livgren - (Kansas) - guitars/piano

Kerry Minnear - (Gentle Giant) keys, vibraphone, moog

Greg Lake - (ELP) - lead bass

Neil Peart- (Rush) - drums/percussion

 

 

[MMCXII]

...great, now I gotta follow three bands all over the country

[losingit2k]

QUOTE (MMCXII @ Sep 5 2010, 01:57 PM)

...great, now I gotta follow three bands all over the country

Dude it's just hypothetical! No one truely wants to see Rush disband! Just side projects!

 

[MMCXII]

QUOTE (losingit2k @ Sep 5 2010, 04:50 PM)

QUOTE (MMCXII @ Sep 5 2010, 01:57 PM) ...great, now I gotta follow three bands all over the country Dude it's just hypothetical! No one truely wants to see Rush disband! Just side projects!   I know but I still can't get into it... I mean, why dilute the ultimate power trio?

[thelocator]

[Snow-Dog2112]

Group 1

1. Geddy Lee (Vocals/Bass/Keyboards)-Rush

2. Nicko Mcbrain (Drums)- Iron Maiden

3. Kirk Hammett (Lead Guitar)- Metallica

 

Group 2

1. Alex Lifeson (Lead Guitar/Backing Vocals)- Rush

2. Steve Harris (Bass/Backing Vocals)- Iron Maiden

3. Sammy Hagar (Lead Vocals)- Sammy Hagar, Van Halen, Chickenfoot.

4. Eric Singer (Drums/Backing Vocals)-Kiss+ a lot of other bands (lol)

 

Group 3

1. Neil Peart (Drums)- Rush

2. Dave Murray (Lead Guitar)- Iron Maiden

3. Paul Stanley (Lead Vocals/Rhythm Guitar)- Kiss

4. Jason Newsted (Bass/Backing Vocals)- Flotsam and Jetsom, Metallica, Ozzy Ozborne.

[Ted Barchetta]

Group with Ged:

 

Geddy Lee - Bass/Keys

Steve Howe - Guitars

Barriemore Barlow - Drums/Percussion

Peter Gabriel - Vocals/Funny Noises/Costumes

 

Assemblage with Alex:

 

Alex Lifeson - Lead/Rhythm Guitars

Jimmy Page - Lead/Rhythm Guitars

Chris Squire - Bass/Vocals

Tony Banks - Keyboards

Keith Moon - Drums/Passing out in the middle of songs/General Tomfoolery

Freddie Mercury - - Lead Vocals/Funny Hats

 

Peart's Posse:

 

Neil Peart - Drums/Percussion/Being A God

Pete Townshend - Rhythm/Lead Guitar/Vocals

Dave Gilmour - Rhythm/Lead Guitar/Lead Vocals

Me - Bass/Keys (Hey. Wouldn't you like to be in a band with three of your musical heroes?)

 

 

 

[losingit2k]

QUOTE (Ted Barchetta @ Sep 6 2010, 12:29 AM)

Group with Ged: Geddy Lee - Bass/Keys Steve Howe - Guitars Barriemore Barlow - Drums/Percussion Peter Gabriel - Vocals/Funny Noises/Costumes Assemblage with Alex: Alex Lifeson - Lead/Rhythm Guitars Jimmy Page - Lead/Rhythm Guitars Chris Squire - Bass/Vocals Tony Banks - Keyboards Keith Moon - Drums/Passing out in the middle of songs/General Tomfoolery Freddie Mercury - - Lead Vocals/Funny Hats Peart's Posse: Neil Peart - Drums/Percussion/Being A God Pete Townshend - Rhythm/Lead Guitar/Vocals Dave Gilmour - Rhythm/Lead Guitar/Lead Vocals Me - Bass/Keys (Hey. Wouldn't you like to be in a band with three of your musical heroes?)

I love your third group! And yes I would but since I'm a keyboardist it would just be me joining Rush!