Jump to content

Heart: Albums Elimination (Round 2)


  

13 members have voted

  1. 1. Immune (Pick Up To TWO):

    • Dreamboat Annie (1975)
    • Magazine (1977)
    • Little Queen (1977)
    • Dog & Butterfly (1978)
    • Bébé le Strange (1980)
    • Private Audition (1982)
    • Passionworks (1983)
      0
    • Heart (1985)
    • Bad Animals (1987)
    • Brigade (1990)
    • Desire Walks On (1993)
    • Jupiters Darling (2004)
  2. 2. Eliminate (Pick Up To TWO):

    • Dreamboat Annie (1975)
      0
    • Magazine (1977)
      0
    • Little Queen (1977)
      0
    • Dog & Butterfly (1978)
      0
    • Bébé le Strange (1980)
      0
    • Private Audition (1982)
    • Passionworks (1983)
    • Heart (1985)
    • Bad Animals (1987)
    • Brigade (1990)
    • Desire Walks On (1993)
    • Jupiters Darling (2004)


Recommended Posts

While Bad Animals, Brigade, and Desire Walks On should all leave next,

 

please actually go listen to Jupiter's Darling. It's not their best by any means, but it is by far their best since at least 1985.

 

It's far too early for it to go.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

While Bad Animals, Brigade, and Desire Walks On should all leave next,

 

please actually go listen to Jupiter's Darling. It's not their best by any means, but it is by far their best since at least 1985.

 

It's far too early for it to go.

 

This brings back the question I bought up in the David Bowie elimination thread. Why would someone vote against or for an album they have not heard? Surely, everyone voting has heard Jupiter's Darling already. Otherwise, why vote against it?

 

I do agree that the album is a very nice return to form for them and it certainly should last a little bit longer. I'm surprised Desire Walks On is getting so many elimination votes. It's certainly better than the couple albums before it and Heart was starting to say goodbye to their pop days with it and getting more back to being themselves again.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

While Bad Animals, Brigade, and Desire Walks On should all leave next,

 

please actually go listen to Jupiter's Darling. It's not their best by any means, but it is by far their best since at least 1985.

 

It's far too early for it to go.

 

This brings back the question I bought up in the David Bowie elimination thread. Why would someone vote against or for an album they have not heard? Surely, everyone voting has heard Jupiter's Darling already. Otherwise, why vote against it?

 

I do agree that the album is a very nice return to form for them and it certainly should last a little bit longer. I'm surprised Desire Walks On is getting so many elimination votes. It's certainly better than the couple albums before it and Heart was starting to say goodbye to their pop days with it and getting more back to being themselves again.

 

I voted to eliminate Desire in a strategic move to protect Jupiter, but it's better than Brigade or Bad Animals in my view.

 

And it was a pointless endeavor. So I'm switching the vote since it looks like it won't matter

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...