Time Machine or The Wall

[cygnus_thegodofbalance]

QUOTE (ZivotSon @ Jun 3 2010, 03:01 PM)

Theatrically speaking, The Wall tour will blow the Time Machine tour away. That said, the music for The Wall is essentially being proformed by a cover band. Without Gilmour's voice and guitar, it really isn't the real thing. Waters may sing most of the vocals on that record, but Gilmour sang lead on most of the better songs. Pink Floyd after Waters was able to still flourish because Gilmour replacing Waters' lead vocals actually made those songs sound better. You wouldn't even notice a real difference on songs like Brain Damage or Shine On. Sadly, Wright's great harmony vocals on gone forever.

That's why I don't really like The Wall Live in Berlin that much. It's far too theatrical, and it's not even Pink Floyd.

[Rush Cocky]

Rush has 87% of the vote.

 

I'm stunned.

[SpiritOfRush]

QUOTE (greg2112 @ May 12 2010, 04:28 PM)

No contest, step into the TIME MACHINE!!! I like Dark Side, Animals and WYWE, but the Wall is dreadful, self-indulgent and depressing-PASS. (im already ducking from the flamers!)

I happen to agree. The Wall is ok but their other stuff (as you mentioned) is way better...but it's not even close to RUSH (for me).

[Jake2112]

QUOTE (Tigershark2112 @ May 20 2010, 01:38 PM)

A good friend once told me that "Yes is a poor man's Rush". That statement made me want to die from laughter.

I always thought Canadians said Triumph was the poor man's Rush?

But I love Triumph either way