QUOTE (grimachi @ Jul 14 2010, 06:51 PM) I would really love for the guys to sit down and consciously write an epic piece. I just don't think their writing style leads to that type of product any longer.
Over the years (I do not know when it started) they have developed into this multi-jam piecemeal writing style. The first I ever remember them referencing this style was Vapor Trails. Ged and Al get together and just start jamming until that particular idea runs its course. then they will go onto another and then another. Then Ged will go and sit at Pro Tools and piece together different jams that go together or rearrange "this with that" until you have a rough draft for the demos.
While not epic pieces in and of themselves, I cannot picture Limelight, Tom Sawyer, or epics like La Villa, Xanadu, or Jacob's Ladder written that way. Even songs like Territories, MHP, and on through to songs on Counterparts all seemed, to me anyway, like thought was actually placed in developing ideas and direction for each song.
Now that I think about it, I started really noticing a difference in Test for Echo.
Great observation, although I think a few songs off Snakes harken back to the PeW/MP era, even if just a little bit. This new producer (Nick Raskulienczxxxxxxx or whatever) is s self-confessed fan and seems to be pushing them in the right direction. I agree with everything you've said about VT and T4E. Man I'm listening to really hifi rip of the Dutch pressing of Signals at this very moment and would probably go nuts for a new album sounding anything like this.