Jump to content

TRF rank all 168 Rush songs


YYZumbi
 Share

Recommended Posts

How the hell is Malnar #164?

I think this list has been about not forgetting songs more than ranking the best or worst. Even with the list repeated again and again, songs have been sloppily repeated.

 

A TRUE ranking from all 168 is too much to do. But ranking songs on each album is easily doable.

 

Ah! Even Johnny knows this list could never be a TRUE ranking of Rush songs. :yes: :) :cool: ;) ;) ;)

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

How the hell is Malnar #164?

I think this list has been about not forgetting songs more than ranking the best or worst. Even with the list repeated again and again, songs have been sloppily repeated.

 

A TRUE ranking from all 168 is too much to do. But ranking songs on each album is easily doable.

 

This list is a red herring, and I'm not talking about the Commies here. In this case at least. Its also straw man, a false dilemma and is not Empirically valid. Venn is turning in his grave.

 

That's the spirit! :)

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

My list is worse than yours...and makes absolutely no sense

Thank god it's over

15) The Trees (Disembodied Spirit)

45) Losing It (Disembodied Spirit)

101) O Barista..er..Baterasta..the drum solo in Rio (Disembodied Spirit)

111) Broon's Bane (Disembodied Spirit)

124) Virtuality..net boy..net girl (Disembodied Spirit)

137) Moto Perpetuo (Disembodied Spirit)

148) Need Some Love (Disembodied Spirit)

 

158) The Big Wheel (Disembodied Spirit)

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

How the hell is Malnar #164?

I think this list has been about not forgetting songs more than ranking the best or worst. Even with the list repeated again and again, songs have been sloppily repeated.

 

A TRUE ranking from all 168 is too much to do. But ranking songs on each album is easily doable.

 

This list is a red herring, and I'm not talking about the Commies here. In this case at least. Its also straw man, a false dilemma and is not Empirically valid. Venn is turning in his grave.

 

That's the spirit! :)

 

Still waiting for Lucas to come in here and try to play devils advocate to my devils advocate, like he does in damn near every post I make here.

 

Maybe he is a commie too. Jersey is a Red state ferfecksake. ;)

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

My list is worse than yours...and makes absolutely no sense

Thank god it's over

15) The Trees (Disembodied Spirit)

45) Losing It (Disembodied Spirit)

101) O Barista..er..Baterasta..the drum solo in Rio (Disembodied Spirit)

111) Broon's Bane (Disembodied Spirit)

124) Virtuality..net boy..net girl (Disembodied Spirit)

137) Moto Perpetuo (Disembodied Spirit)

148) Need Some Love (Disembodied Spirit)

 

158) The Big Wheel (Disembodied Spirit)

 

If there really is a God, "he" wouldn't let bollocks like this happen.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

My list is worse than yours...and makes absolutely no sense

Thank god it's over

15) The Trees (Disembodied Spirit)

45) Losing It (Disembodied Spirit)

101) O Barista..er..Baterasta..the drum solo in Rio (Disembodied Spirit)

111) Broon's Bane (Disembodied Spirit)

124) Virtuality..net boy..net girl (Disembodied Spirit)

137) Moto Perpetuo (Disembodied Spirit)

148) Need Some Love (Disembodied Spirit)

 

158) The Big Wheel (Disembodied Spirit)

 

I weep. That list will keep me tossing and turning all night long.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

How the hell is Malnar #164?

I think this list has been about not forgetting songs more than ranking the best or worst. Even with the list repeated again and again, songs have been sloppily repeated.

 

A TRUE ranking from all 168 is too much to do. But ranking songs on each album is easily doable.

 

This list is a red herring, and I'm not talking about the Commies here. In this case at least. Its also straw man, a false dilemma and is not Empirically valid. Venn is turning in his grave.

 

That's the spirit! :)

 

Still waiting for Lucas to come in here and try to play devils advocate to my devils advocate, like he does in damn near every post I make here.

 

Maybe he is a commie too. Jersey is a Red state ferfecksake. ;)

 

Did you hear that Lucas? DD called us commies.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was able to get my first 8 choices ones that I liked then the last 4 were just fill ins from albums I didn't like so much.

 

13) The Camera Eye

25) Headlong Flight

37) Earthshine

61) Between The Wheels

70) Afterimage

83) The Body Electric

97) The Manhattan Project

117) Test For Echo

127) We Hold On

141) Bravest Face

154) Good News First

165) Faithless

 

 

 

You snagged Earthshine from me! Manhattan Project also. I was aiming for Good News First as one of my last picks...I'm rare in that I like that song.

 

I wanted to name more from my favorite album GUP, my favorite from the album RSA got snagged just before I was going to pick it. I really have to try and listen to Snakes & Arrows more caused I've never liked that album which is at the bottom of my list.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My list is worse than yours...and makes absolutely no sense

Thank god it's over

15) The Trees (Disembodied Spirit)

45) Losing It (Disembodied Spirit)

101) O Barista..er..Baterasta..the drum solo in Rio (Disembodied Spirit)

111) Broon's Bane (Disembodied Spirit)

124) Virtuality..net boy..net girl (Disembodied Spirit)

137) Moto Perpetuo (Disembodied Spirit)

148) Need Some Love (Disembodied Spirit)

 

158) The Big Wheel (Disembodied Spirit)

 

O Barista@!!!

 

BWAHAHAHA

 

1) The Fountain of Lattes

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

How the hell is Malnar #164?

I think this list has been about not forgetting songs more than ranking the best or worst. Even with the list repeated again and again, songs have been sloppily repeated.

 

A TRUE ranking from all 168 is too much to do. But ranking songs on each album is easily doable.

 

This list is a red herring, and I'm not talking about the Commies here. In this case at least. Its also straw man, a false dilemma and is not Empirically valid. Venn is turning in his grave.

 

That's the spirit! :)

 

Still waiting for Lucas to come in here and try to play devils advocate to my devils advocate, like he does in damn near every post I make here.

 

Maybe he is a commie too. Jersey is a Red state ferfecksake. ;)

 

Did you hear that Lucas? DD called us commies.

WHAHAHAHA...GOTCHA!!!!

 

In the name of McCarthy I say unto thee.

 

Have I left no sense of decency???

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was able to get my first 8 choices ones that I liked then the last 4 were just fill ins from albums I didn't like so much.

 

13) The Camera Eye

25) Headlong Flight

37) Earthshine

61) Between The Wheels

70) Afterimage

83) The Body Electric

97) The Manhattan Project

117) Test For Echo

127) We Hold On

141) Bravest Face

154) Good News First

165) Faithless

 

 

 

You snagged Earthshine from me! Manhattan Project also. I was aiming for Good News First as one of my last picks...I'm rare in that I like that song.

 

I wanted to name more from my favorite album GUP, my favorite from the album RSA got snagged just before I was going to pick it. I really have to try and listen to Snakes & Arrows more caused I've never liked that album which is at the bottom of my list.

 

Listen to it like you would listen to album...all 4 sides. they are short sides which makes it even easier.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pretty much sums up where I'm stuck

 

- Cygnus X1

- The Necromancer

- Garden Road

- A Passage To Bangkok

- Bastille Day

- Something For Nothing

- Lakeside Park

- Before And After

- Finding My Way

- Tears

- In The Mood

- Take A Friend

- Rivendell

- Fancy Dancer

 

 

... and I just received a marriage proposal from Narps

 

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

My list is worse than yours...and makes absolutely no sense

Thank god it's over

15) The Trees (Disembodied Spirit)

45) Losing It (Disembodied Spirit)

101) O Barista..er..Baterasta..the drum solo in Rio (Disembodied Spirit)

111) Broon's Bane (Disembodied Spirit)

124) Virtuality..net boy..net girl (Disembodied Spirit)

137) Moto Perpetuo (Disembodied Spirit)

148) Need Some Love (Disembodied Spirit)

 

158) The Big Wheel (Disembodied Spirit)

 

I weep. That list will keep me tossing and turning all night long.

Apple rejected this as a playlist stating

Files may be corrupt and should not be played in the order: Please do anything else

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pretty much sums up where I'm stuck

 

- Cygnus X1

- The Necromancer

- Garden Road

- A Passage To Bangkok

- Bastille Day

- Something For Nothing

- Lakeside Park

- Before And After

- Finding My Way

- Tears

- In The Mood

- Take A Friend

- Rivendell

- Fancy Dancer

 

 

... and I just received a marriage proposal from Narps

 

I heard he was looking, but I didn't realize he'd find someone so soon.

 

Congrats! :cheers: If you need a bridesmaid, here I am. :)

 

 

;) ;) ;) ;)

Edited by Lorraine
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

How the hell is Malnar #164?

I think this list has been about not forgetting songs more than ranking the best or worst. Even with the list repeated again and again, songs have been sloppily repeated.

 

A TRUE ranking from all 168 is too much to do. But ranking songs on each album is easily doable.

 

Ah! Even Johnny knows this list could never be a TRUE ranking of Rush songs. :yes: :) :cool: ;) ;) ;)

"Even Johnny knows"?!!! What do mean "even"??!!! :LOL:

I was bitching about this ranking system way back in the early pages along with Digital Dad. I just wasn't as adamant. :LOL:

And I was bitching about the Top 500, Top 1000 lists in the Music Forum weeks or even months ago. You can't really do a RANKING without some kind average score or collective effort. Of course, you can have your own PERSONAL 168 but then it's just you ranking and not TRF.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pretty much sums up where I'm stuck

 

- Cygnus X1

- The Necromancer

- Garden Road

- A Passage To Bangkok

- Bastille Day

- Something For Nothing

- Lakeside Park

- Before And After

- Finding My Way

- Tears

- In The Mood

- Take A Friend

- Rivendell

- Fancy Dancer

 

 

... and I just received a marriage proposal from Narps

 

May you live Trumpily Donald after. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

How the hell is Malnar #164?

I think this list has been about not forgetting songs more than ranking the best or worst. Even with the list repeated again and again, songs have been sloppily repeated.

 

A TRUE ranking from all 168 is too much to do. But ranking songs on each album is easily doable.

 

This list is a red herring, and I'm not talking about the Commies here. In this case at least. Its also straw man, a false dilemma and is not Empirically valid. Venn is turning in his grave.

 

That's the spirit! :)

 

Still waiting for Lucas to come in here and try to play devils advocate to my devils advocate, like he does in damn near every post I make here.

 

Maybe he is a commie too. Jersey is a Red state ferfecksake. ;)

 

Did you hear that Lucas? DD called us commies.

 

whoa, sorry I didn't chime in sooner -- I was standing in line for bread and toilet paper

 

Digital Dad has exposed us !!!!

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

How the hell is Malnar #164?

I think this list has been about not forgetting songs more than ranking the best or worst. Even with the list repeated again and again, songs have been sloppily repeated.

 

A TRUE ranking from all 168 is too much to do. But ranking songs on each album is easily doable.

 

You start that thread and make the rules for it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

How the hell is Malnar #164?

I think this list has been about not forgetting songs more than ranking the best or worst. Even with the list repeated again and again, songs have been sloppily repeated.

 

A TRUE ranking from all 168 is too much to do. But ranking songs on each album is easily doable.

 

Ah! Even Johnny knows this list could never be a TRUE ranking of Rush songs. :yes: :) :cool: ;) ;) ;)

"Even Johnny knows"?!!! What do mean "even"??!!! :LOL:

I was bitching about this ranking system way back in the early pages along with Digital Dad. I just wasn't as adamant. :LOL:

And I was bitching about the Top 500, Top 1000 lists in the Music Forum weeks or even months ago. You can't really do a RANKING without some kind average score or collective effort. Of course, you can have your own PERSONAL 168 but then it's just you ranking and not TRF.

 

Dude the post just got to me at the right time. Or the wrong time, depending on your point of view.

 

The other top lists were more like, this is what you should check out, they say so right at the top. The tenor of this particular thing was different. Basically he just said this is the best song. Bang. pretty comical if you are an objective thinker like me. If I hadn't seen it that night I probably wouldn't have even bothered with it. It was just too easy to mock.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pretty much sums up where I'm stuck

 

- Cygnus X1

- The Necromancer

- Garden Road

- A Passage To Bangkok

- Bastille Day

- Something For Nothing

- Lakeside Park

- Before And After

- Finding My Way

- Tears

- In The Mood

- Take A Friend

- Rivendell

- Fancy Dancer

 

 

... and I just received a marriage proposal from Narps

 

May you live Trumpily Donald after. :)

 

Did I say I was going to accept ?!?!?!?!

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

How the hell is Malnar #164?

I think this list has been about not forgetting songs more than ranking the best or worst. Even with the list repeated again and again, songs have been sloppily repeated.

 

A TRUE ranking from all 168 is too much to do. But ranking songs on each album is easily doable.

 

This list is a red herring, and I'm not talking about the Commies here. In this case at least. Its also straw man, a false dilemma and is not Empirically valid. Venn is turning in his grave.

 

That's the spirit! :)

 

Still waiting for Lucas to come in here and try to play devils advocate to my devils advocate, like he does in damn near every post I make here.

 

Maybe he is a commie too. Jersey is a Red state ferfecksake. ;)

 

Did you hear that Lucas? DD called us commies.

Lorraine, if you were on a beach in Thailand with Lucas on a completely clear blue sky day with sun beams beaming and said, "What a lovely blue sky!", it's possible that Lucas would play devil's advocate and say, "Well, it's nice and all but it's not completely blue. I see a very slight hint of grey in there." :LOL:

Edited by JohnnyBlaze
  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...