Which Is Your Favourite...The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway, Quadrophenia or The Wall?

[The Cat 3]

So, which of these three great albums is your favourite?

 

Share your thoughts on the album(s) and the reason for your choice.

 

I confess..I can't quite decide which is tops for me.

 

 

 

http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51AWBMGft3L._SY300_.jpg

[invisible airwave]

Quad

[Union 5-3992]

Quadrophenia, the other two don't hold my attention as well all the way through

[djflex]

The wall

 

 

[Ancient Ways]

The wall. The other 2 sound very dated to my ears. I don't care for the concept in the lamb...

[Segue Myles]

I don't like any of them.

 

Except for most of one:

 

Lamb.

[Maverick]

The Wall, because I am intelligent and civilized.

[Bigbobby10]

The Wall gets my vote,

 

Quadrophenia is very close second though

[Digital Dad]

Lamb

 

Cuz I dont need a reason so neener.

Edited April 15, 2016 by Digital Dad

[Geddy's Soul Patch]

Lamb gets my vote. The Wall is a close 2nd

[Lucas]

Over the next few days, I'm going to listen to them all - start to finish

 

 

[Lucas]

I'm about 35 minutes in Quadrophenia

 

I'll tell ya right now, it's ain't going to be this one

[Segue Myles]

I'm about 35 minutes in Quadrophenia

 

I'll tell ya right now, it's ain't going to be this one

 

You also think it's overrated hogwash?

[Lucas]

I'm about 35 minutes in Quadrophenia

 

I'll tell ya right now, it's ain't going to be this one

 

You also think it's overrated hogwash?

 

Ya know, I like to go back and listen to things that I might not have given the chance or simply overlooked

 

This is probably the most tedious thing I have listened to in ... ummm ... listened to ever

[Segue Myles]

I'm about 35 minutes in Quadrophenia

 

I'll tell ya right now, it's ain't going to be this one

 

You also think it's overrated hogwash?

 

Ya know, I like to go back and listen to things that I might not have given the chance or simply overlooked

 

This is probably the most tedious thing I have listened to in ... ummm ... listened to ever

 

Agreed.

 

I don't dislike it anywhere near as much as I do The Wall.

Edited April 15, 2016 by Segue Myles

[Lucas]

I'm about 35 minutes in Quadrophenia

 

I'll tell ya right now, it's ain't going to be this one

 

You also think it's overrated hogwash?

 

Ya know, I like to go back and listen to things that I might not have given the chance or simply overlooked

 

This is probably the most tedious thing I have listened to in ... ummm ... listened to ever

 

Agreed.

 

I don't dislike it anywhere near as much as I do The Wall.

 

ok, that's thankfully over

 

I've got a pile of paperwork to do for work .. I'll start it now

 

Lamb Lies Down, here I come . . . .

Edited April 15, 2016 by Lucas

[Digital Dad]

Honestly all of em are f***ing great. I devoured the Wall. Quadro has some of the greatest moments in all Who music.

 

But Lamb, there is just something about it...

 

 

The story on the inside cover is cool too. So mysterious, so bizarre.

Edited April 15, 2016 by Digital Dad

[Digital Dad]

Your progressive hypocrites hand out their trash

It was mine in the first place so I'll burn it to AAAAAAAAAAAAAASSSSSHHHHHH

[Segue Myles]

I think it lovely that art is so diverse it Divides opinion.

 

I want to revisit Lamb because of this thread. I remember liking it a lot.

[Digital Dad]

if you think thats its pretentious

You've been taken for a ride

Look across the mirror son

Before you choose, decide

[Segue Myles]

So, which of these three great albums is your favourite?

 

Share your thoughts on the album(s) and the reason for your choice.

 

I confess..I can't quite decide which is tops for me.

 

 

 

http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51AWBMGft3L._SY300_.jpg

 

Your threads always entice me to try new things, or revisit stuff that left me cold.

 

I look forward to many more!

[Lucas]

ok, about an hour in Lamb, and I'll tell ya right now, this is the winner hands down

 

I will still listen to The Wall in its entirety, but of the three albums here, I am most familiar with The Wall and I have never liked anything about it

 

Some of the musical sections here on Lamb Lies Down are fantastic - Tony Banks is great and IMHO should have been more a focal point ... The music is so good in sections I am able to overlook Peter Gabriel's god awful annoying voice

 

.

 

.

Edited April 15, 2016 by Lucas

[Lucas]

RGLT, another great thread .. Apologies if I am coming across as critical ....

 

But truth be told, Snow Goose would kick butt in this contest

 

.

 

 

.

Edited April 15, 2016 by Lucas

[Segue Myles]

In all honesty, Genesis are one band I have yet to really delve into HARD. I have heard nearly all the Gabriel era, and it is by far my favourite era for the band. I just need to get on with it and enjoy the music.

 

Because they are terrific. No doubt about it!

[Digital Dad]

Segs, I have been a Genesis fan since I first heard Misunderstanding in 1980. Thats about 5 years before I got into Rush and about 5 years before I even knew what Progressive Rock was. Been a fan of both, basically ever since.

 

And of course Another Brick was a HUGE song around the same time. That would have made me about 7 years old. Parents owned the Wall album and I used to stare at the inside cover and read they lyrics for hours just devouring it.