Jump to content

Rate Power Windows


len(songs)
 Share

Recommended Posts

Couldn't find a thread like this in the last few pages, so have at it. Mine:

 

Same weighted 15 point scale as before (again do NOT try and shoehorn this into a 10 point scale). ** denote best song, italics denote other standouts, <angle brackets> denote worst song, blue text denotes a "lowlight" track.

 

Big Money: 10/15

Grand Designs: 12/15

Manhattan Project: 13/15

Marathon: 13/15

Territories: 11/15

*Middletown Dreams*: 13/15

<Emotion Detector>: 8/15

Mystic Rhythms: 10/15

Edited by len(songs)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Couldn't find a thread like this in the last few pages, so have at it. Mine:

 

Same weighted 15 point scale as before (again do NOT try and shoehorn this into a 10 point scale). ** denote best song, italics denote other standouts, <angle brackets> denote worst song, blue text denotes a "lowlight" track.

 

Big Money: 10/15

Grand Designs: 12/15

Manhattan Project: 13/15

Marathon: 13/15

Territories: 11/15

*Middletown Dreams*: 13/15

<Emotion Detector>: 8/15

Mystic Rhythms: 10/15

too much work to do all that color and italics stuff

 

Good

 

Manhattan Project

The Big Money

 

Meh

 

Everything else

 

This is the album that began an era of antipathy to Rush for me. A lot of these were pretty good on the CA tour but the studio album versions leave me bored.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Couldn't find a thread like this in the last few pages, so have at it. Mine:

 

Same weighted 15 point scale as before (again do NOT try and shoehorn this into a 10 point scale). ** denote best song, italics denote other standouts, <angle brackets> denote worst song, blue text denotes a "lowlight" track.

 

Big Money: 10/15

Grand Designs: 12/15

Manhattan Project: 13/15

Marathon: 13/15

Territories: 11/15

*Middletown Dreams*: 13/15

<Emotion Detector>: 8/15

Mystic Rhythms: 10/15

too much work to do all that color and italics stuff

 

Good

 

Manhattan Project

The Big Money

 

Meh

 

Everything else

 

This is the album that began an era of antipathy to Rush for me. A lot of these were pretty good on the CA tour but the studio album versions leave me bored.

You did it just fine on the "this or that" thread...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wouldn't know how to separate worst and lowlight

 

(I'll try to anyway)

Example: I would put Anagram as "worst" on Presto, but War Paint and Hand Over Fist would get a "lowlight" tab for being, along with Anagram, noticeably weaker than the rest of the album. Basically, "lowlight" can be applied to more than one while "worst" is only one song.

Edited by len(songs)
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Big Money: 9

Grand Designs: 8

Manhattan Project: 8

Marathon: 9

Territories: 9

Middletown Dreams: 9

Emotion Detector: 10

Mystic Rhythms: 10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Big Money: 10

Grand Designs: 9

Manhattan Project: 8

Marathon: 10

Territories: 8

Middletown Dreams: 8

Emotion Detector: 8

Mystic Rhythms: 10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

PW was always a great album, but with the boys giving the album alot of love on the CA tour, I fell in love with it even more, and it may have cracked into my top 5.

 

Good: Emotion Detector, Mystic Rhythms, Territories

Better: Grand Designs, Middletown Dreams

Best: Big Money, Manhattan Project, Marathon

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Marathon (9.6)

2. The Big Money (9.4)

3. Grand Designs (9.3)

4. Mystic Rhythms (9.1)

5. Middletown Dreams (9.0)

6. Manhattan Project (8.8)

7. Territories (8.5)

8. Emotion Detector (8.1)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...