Jump to content

Giving Each Song a Rating...


Mr. Not
 Share

Recommended Posts

Alright, after much listening, here you go.. My opinion remains the same:

 

 

 

Caravan

5/10

 

BU2B

2/10

 

Clockwork Angels

7/10

 

The Anarchist

7/10

 

Carnies

6/10

 

Halo Effect

3/10

 

Seven Cities of Gold

5/10

 

The Wreckers

2/10

 

Headlong Flight

10/10

 

BU2B

1/10

 

Wish Them Well

9/10

 

The Garden

8/10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 118
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

caravan 10 Bu2b 10 clockwork angels 10 the anarchist 8 carnies 7 halo effect 5 seven cities of gold 8 the wreckers 8 headlong flight 8 Bu2b2 7 wish them well 7 the garden 10

 

for me whats interesting is that, all the tracks around 10 were written in the first batch before the time machine tour

 

for me its like they went off and lost the flow, coz if the tracks in the second batch after the time machine tour were of the same quality as Bu2b, caravan, clockwork angels and the garden then i think we'd be talking about the best rush album ever

 

still a great one though

Edited by lifeson90
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Caravan - 8/10

 

BU2B - 8/10

 

Clockwork Angels - 9/10

 

The Anarchist - 9/10

 

Carnies - 8/10

 

Halo Effect - 4/10

 

Seven Cities Of Gold - 8/10

 

The Wreckers - 8/10

 

Headlong Flight - 9/10

 

BU2B2 - 2/10

 

Wish Them Well - 5/10

 

The Garden - 6/10

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Caravan - 8/10

BU2B - 10/10

Clockwork Angels - 9/10

The Anarchist - 10/10

Carnies - 8/10

Halo Effect - 8/10

Seven Cities of Gold - 7/10

The Wreckers - 9/10

Headlong Flight - 10/10

BU2B2 - 5/10

Wish Them Well - 7/10

The Garden - 9/10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Caravan - 10/10

BU2B - 10/10

Clockwork Angels - 10/10

The Anarchist - 10/10

Carnies - 9/10

Halo Effect - 9/10

Seven Cities of Gold - 10/10

The Wreckers - 10/10

Headlong Flight - 10/10

BU2B2 - 8/10

Wish Them Well - 9/10

The Garden - 10/10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (rushlady23 @ Jul 22 2012, 10:50 AM)
Caravan - 10/10
BU2B - 10/10
Clockwork Angels - 10/10
The Anarchist - 10/10
Carnies - 9/10
Halo Effect - 9/10
Seven Cities of Gold - 10/10
The Wreckers - 10/10
Headlong Flight - 10/10
BU2B2 - 8/10
Wish Them Well - 9/10
The Garden - 10/10

That's what I like to see! trink39.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Caravan - 8/10

 

BU2B - 8/10

 

Clockwork Angels - 10/10

 

The Anarchist - 7/10

 

Carnies - 7/10

 

Halo Effect - 7/10

 

Seven Cities Of Gold - 9/10

 

The Wreckers - 8/10

 

Headlong Flight - 10/10

 

BU2B2 - 2/10

 

Wish Them Well - 6/10

 

The Garden - 10/10

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Caravan - 9/10

BU2B - 7/10

Clockwork Angels - 5/10

The Anarchist - 10/10

Carnies - 9/10

Halo Effect - 7/10

Seven Cities of Gold - 8/10

The Wreckers - 7/10

Headlong Flight - 7/10

BU2B2 - 3/10

Wish Them Well - 9/10

The Garden - 5/10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Caravan - 5/10

BU2B - 6/10

Clockwork Angels - 7/10

The Anarchist - 6/10

Carnies - 4/10

Halo Effect - 3/10

Seven Cities of Gold - 4/10

The Wreckers - 3/10

Headlong Flight - 5/10

BU2B2 - 3/10

Wish Them Well - 4/10

The Garden - 6/10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Caravan - 9/10

BU2B - 8/10

Clockwork Angels - 10/10

The Anarchist - 7/10

Carnies - 8/10

Halo Effect - 9/10

Seven Cities of Gold - 5/10

The Wreckers - 9/10

Headlong Flight - 10/10

BU2B2 - 7/10 (not by itself, but for it's role in the whole album)

Wish Them Well - 8/10

The Garden - 10/10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Caravan = 8/10

 

BU2B = 6/10

 

Clockwork Angels = 3/10

 

The Anarchist = 10/10

 

Carnies = 6/10

 

Halo Effect = 8/10

 

Seven Cities of Gold = 4/10

 

The Wreckers = 9/10

 

Headlong Flight = 7/10

 

BU2B2 = 1/10

 

Wish Them Well = 7/10

 

The Garden = 10/10

 

THE ALBUM OVERALL = 7/10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Caravan

7/10

 

BU2B

8/10

 

Clockwork Angels

6/10

 

The Anarchist

9/10

 

Carnies

6/10

 

Halo Effect

3/10

 

Seven Cities of Gold

6/10

 

The Wreckers

7/10

 

Headlong Flight

9/10

 

BU2B

1/10

 

Wish Them Well

3/10

 

The Garden

4/10

Edited by Pound of Obscure
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Caravan - 10/10

BU2B - 9/10

Clockwork Angels - 10/10

The Anarchist - 9/10

Carnies - 9/10

Halo Effect - 9/10

Seven Cities of Gold - 10/10

The Wreckers - 10/10

Headlong Flight - 10/10

BU2B2 - 7/10

Wish Them Well - 8/10

The Garden - 10/10

 

2.gif 1022.gif 2.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Caravan - 8/10

BU2B - 10/10

Clockwork Angels - 9/10

The Anarchist - 10/10

Carnies - 9/10

Halo Effect - 8/10

Seven Cities of Gold - 7/10

The Wreckers - 8/10

Headlong Flight - 8/10

BU2B2 - 6/10

Wish Them Well - 8/10

The Garden - 10/10

Edited by Jeffrey
Link to comment
Share on other sites

....It's a bit harder to rate 'BU2B2', isn't it? Should it be rated for what it is, in the context of the album, or as a stand-alone song as the other songs are? If the latter, then it is going to be really quite low, because it's not really a stand-alone song alone. It's popped up randomly on my ipod, and without the flow of the entire album, it's kind of odd, a little moody nugget-of-a-song.

 

But good to see many people ranking the songs so high! It'd be interesting to compare album play counts between those that give the songs 9s and those that give them mostly 5s... but, as is obvious, everyone has their own opinions and nobody's right or wrong! trink39.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Caravan - 8/10

BU2B - 9/10

Clockwork Angels - 9/10

The Anarchist - 9/10

Carnies - 9/10

Halo Effect - 6/10

Seven Cities of Gold - 9/10

The Wreckers - 10/10

Headlong Flight - 10/10

BU2B2 - 4/10

Wish Them Well - 9/10

The Garden - 5/10

 

Been trying to see in "The Garden" what so many others see. (Or "hear" rather.) It just isn't happening for me. Absolutely love "Headlong Flight". Too bad there's no such thing as great radio anymore, otherwise that song would be all over the airwaves. It's right up there with Tom, Spirit, Sub, Lime, Closer and Working.

 

I would have to say that for me, this album ranks a great 9/10.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Caravan - 7/10

BU2B - 10/10

Clockwork Angels - 9/10

The Anarchist - 10/10

Carnies - 8/10

Halo Effect - 7/10

Seven Cities of Gold - 8/10

The Wreckers - 8/10

Headlong Flight - 10/10

BU2B2 - 9/10 (as a key transitional piece, not a song on its' own)

Wish Them Well - 9/10

The Garden - 9/10

 

Album as a whole (9/10)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Caravan - 7

BU2B - 7

Clockwork Angels - 10

The Anarchist - 8

Carnies - 6

Halo Effect - 5

Seven Cities of Gold - 5

The Wreckers - 8

Headlong Flight - 9

BU2B2 - 8

Wish Them Well - 6

The Garden - 8

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Caravan - 10

BU2B - 7

Clockwork Angels - 9

The Anarchist - 10

Carnies - 9

Halo Effect - 8

Seven Cities of Gold - 7

The Wreckers - 7

Headlong Flight - 10

BU2B2 - 5

Wish Them Well - 8

The Garden - 9

 

8.54/10 excluding BU2B2

 

Where's the love for Halo Effect? It's short and sweet, I really like it confused13.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Caravan - 10/10

BU2B - 10/10

Clockwork Angels - 9/10

The Anarchist - 11/10

Carnies - 9/10

Halo Effect - 10/10

Seven Cities of Gold - 12/10

The Wreckers - 12/10

Headlong Flight - 12/10

BU2B2 - 8/10

Wish Them Well - 9/10

The Garden - 12/10

 

...in my totally unbiased and objective opinion.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...