condemned2bfree Posted October 31 Posted October 31 I amΒ not connected with this channel. Rush albums dethroned of their synths. The songs still stand up for me. Completely removing them as opposed to reducing them, seems to work more. It's all orΒ nothing. Power Windows and Grace sound great. Alex is really revealed. Β Β Β Β 1
Lurkst Posted October 31 Posted October 31 Wow two very different sounding albums. This is excellent use of AI π 1
condemned2bfree Posted October 31 Author Posted October 31 24 minutes ago, Lurkst said: Wow two very different sounding albums. This is excellent use of AI π Yeah usually hate AI.Β
Lurkst Posted October 31 Posted October 31 Decent job although it does sound like some guitar tracks have been removed too.
Unattractive Truth Posted October 31 Posted October 31 Wellβ¦ Β Iβll say itβs an interesting listen. Β Full disclosure: I love the βsynthβ albums just the way they are. Β Listening to The Big Money, I think it sounds terrible without the keyboards. Β So if anything, these have shown me how important the keyboards are to the overall sound of these albums. Β Thanks for posting them! 2
chemistry1973 Posted October 31 Posted October 31 1 hour ago, Lurkst said: Decent job although it does sound like some guitar tracks have been removed too. Yeah like the ovation strum in Mystic Rhythms. Dumb AI thought it was a keyboard.Β Β What I found interesting was how little bass Geddy plays on so many of the songs. Lots of bass Taurus pedal. When he does play itβs so noticeable and killer. I think this was a cool, innovative move too.
condemned2bfree Posted October 31 Author Posted October 31 1 hour ago, chemistry1973 said: Yeah like the ovation strum in Mystic Rhythms. Dumb AI thought it was a keyboard.Β Β What I found interesting was how little bass Geddy plays on so many of the songs. Lots of bass Taurus pedal. When he does play itβs so noticeable and killer. I think this was a cool, innovative move too. Mystic really misses the keys. For me i like these versions without keys, yea the bass keys sound great. 1
BastillePark Posted October 31 Posted October 31 Don't like it. That's not how they recorded it. How about remove the bass and see how that sounds too? Lame. 3
ZachenFoot Posted November 2 Posted November 2 (edited) On 10/31/2026 at 3:02 PM, BastillePark said: Don't like it. That's not how they recorded it. How about remove the bass and see how that sounds too? Lame. Β Yeah aside from using a content grinder to create some weird facsimile of original music that none of us own, it also fundamentally betrays the artistic intent of these albums. It's not interesting, it's fraudulent. Edited November 2 by ZachenFoot 1
Disco Posted November 3 Posted November 3 For me, these de-synthed albums are a revalation.Β I love being able to hear more clearly what the guitar, bass and voice were doing. Β Signals is revealed to be an awesome Police-style album.Β Β Β Hold Your Fire.Β I can see why this isn't a favourite of Alex's.Β After opening with a couple of storming tracks, he is reduced to a sideman serving up only ornamentation and solos. 2
1-0-0-1-0-0-1 Posted November 3 Posted November 3 Β On 10/31/2026 at 3:02 PM, BastillePark said: Don't like it. That's not how they recorded it. How about remove the bass and see how that sounds too? Lame. Β On 11/2/2026 at 11:17 AM, ZachenFoot said: This sucks for so many reasons. Β 23 hours ago, ZachenFoot said: Β Yeah aside from using a content grinder to create some weird facsimile of original music that none of us own, it also fundamentally betrays the artistic intent of these albums. It's not interesting, it's fraudulent. Β I don't think these versions are meant to replace the originals for those who don't like synths. They're meant to be a forensic exercise -- a deconstruction of what these songs sounded like before the keyboards were added. You take them for the exercise that they are and you move on and listen to the album versions. Β On 10/31/2026 at 11:54 AM, Unattractive Truth said: Listening to The Big Money, I think it sounds terrible without the keyboards. Β So if anything, these have shown me how important the keyboards are to the overall sound of these albums. Β Yes. A lot of the synth era songs were built around the keys -- a song like Subdivisions isn't a song without them, and the de-synth version is simply demonstrating that. 4
ZachenFoot Posted November 3 Posted November 3 (edited) 4 hours ago, 1-0-0-1-0-0-1 said: I don't think these versions are meant to replace the originals for those who don't like synths. They're meant to be a forensic exercise -- a deconstruction of what these songs sounded like before the keyboards were added. You take them for the exercise that they are and you move on and listen to the album versions. Β Never accused these of intending to replace anything. I think they inherently suck. I think these are lazy, half-hearted deconstructions that even commenters here are saying aren't entirely accurate due to missing elements. I think things like this open the door to greater abuses of material that--critical point--none of us own. Β People are welcome to feel however they want but I'm certainly not about to start making allowances for slop just because it appeals to one of my niche interests. If others want to that's their prerogative. Edited November 3 by ZachenFoot
BlairC45 Posted November 4 Posted November 4 I was just listening toΒ π²πππππ ππ πππππ - Wide Stereo. Wow, I like this version more than the original (IMO)
condemned2bfree Posted November 4 Author Posted November 4 Yes, these versions areΒ not intended to replace the originals, they couldn't. Rush created their work as intended - the originals. These versions merely reveal aspects more, highlight them, even how essential keys are on some songs. Interesting different perspective.Β 1
condemned2bfree Posted November 5 Author Posted November 5 (edited) On 11/3/2026 at 9:50 PM, ZachenFoot said: Β Never accused these of intending to replace anything. I think they inherently suck. I think these are lazy, half-hearted deconstructions that even commenters here are saying aren't entirely accurate due to missing elements. I think things like this open the door to greater abuses of material that--critical point--none of us own. Β People are welcome to feel however they want but I'm certainly not about to start making allowances for slop just because it appeals to one of my niche interests. If others want to that's their prerogative. I only intepret them as any other Rush track on Youtube, with say the drums removed, or guitars removed so i can jam. This form as presented goes no further, as is, having very little merit compared to the original. Edited November 5 by condemned2bfree
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now