chemistry1973 Posted February 24 Posted February 24 4 hours ago, Lurkst said: It's a very unusual bass pattern for Geddy. Really enjoyed going through these uploads, Presto could have been a much more vibrant sounding album. How could you listen to performances like those and decide that they needed to be suppressed? And that’s exactly what happened. They were suppressed. Covered in reverb and unnecessary keyboards.
ytserush Posted February 28 Posted February 28 On 2/23/2026 at 8:06 PM, Lurkst said: It's a very unusual bass pattern for Geddy. Really enjoyed going through these uploads, Presto could have been a much more vibrant sounding album. How could you listen to performances like those and decide that they needed to be suppressed? It's definitely a revelation. It would be great if these and others exist somewhere and someone can sign off on them. 1
Todem Posted February 28 Posted February 28 It’s cool to hear these rough mixes. Final product though was much better. Presto gets a ton of flak for being engineered too soft and I don’t disagree….but the final mix the songs are complete and polished. This is a cool thing to just hear the “process” of the evolution of an album being produced. 1
PurpleHayes Posted March 1 Posted March 1 They should let Broon take a whack at remixing it...and then release it under the title of Change-o. 2 2
Lurkst Posted October 23 Posted October 23 (edited) These have been professionally uploaded to YouTube now and sound incredible . Much more like a record Edited October 23 by Lurkst 4
chemistry1973 Posted October 24 Posted October 24 17 hours ago, Lurkst said: These have been professionally uploaded to YouTube now and sound incredible . Much more like a record Yeah I’m digging it! 1
chemistry1973 Posted October 24 Posted October 24 Without the solos you get to hear more of Al’s rhythm playing. Hand Over Fist sounds awesome. 2
Jaminbenb Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Wow! Hearing these actually makes me like these songs a bit more! Suppressing some of engineering and effects makes this sound a LOT better! Getting ready to give it a second spin! 1
Jaminbenb Posted October 27 Posted October 27 Ok, so in my own geeky way I decided to put the "Album" track, and the "demo" track side by side on two cdr's to A/B them one after the other. So tomorrow I'll give them a nice critical listen! I've always wondered what happened to the rough mixes from most albums that the band got to take home after sessions just to evaluate on their own. You KNOW there has to be tapes like this from most of, if not EVERY album! (I'd be willing to bet someone has a rough copy of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight on tape somewhere) I know the band claims that they don't have any unreleased material, but stuff like this totally exists, and you know there are people that have copies! THIS is what the box sets REALLY need! (Signals, cough cough) My Recording III professor was Billy Joel's engineer during his BIG years, (dude was a MASTER at tape editing with a razor blade!) and said that any engineer worth his salt has either 1/4" or DAT tapes that ran during sessions for moments when someone said "WAIT, what did you just play?" He brought in great tapes with Billy getting mad and saying "OK, I'M DONE, just order a pizza and we can listen to these tracks again" So I'm sure that there are more things like this out there, we just need to find them!! The live stuff is great, but there are so many awesome boots out there, that even an official live release for some albums isn't as exciting as this! 3
losingit2k Posted October 27 Posted October 27 On 2/21/2026 at 8:02 PM, Papa Emeritus said: From this post on Facebook. Listen to the songs here. Very Cool! I'm still waiting for them to play Available Light. You'd think with a Keyboardist on board they would attempt to play that one live! 2
chemistry1973 Posted October 27 Posted October 27 5 hours ago, losingit2k said: Very Cool! I'm still waiting for them to play Available Light. You'd think with a Keyboardist on board they would attempt to play that one live! It’s such a good song. 1
Jaminbenb Posted October 27 Posted October 27 So giving the A/B a quick listen today while driving and waiting to go into work, I noticed that the drums seemed to be a bit more up front, some of the background and extra parts were missing which gave the tunes a different sound. Show Don't Tell has a totally different feel to it. Superconductor sounds very different with Geddy doing the "Superconductor" vocal rather than (who was it Peter Henderson, I don't have my copy handy) Anagram has some missing stuff, but Neil's drums are WAY up in the mix!! Just a cool difference to hear the songs this way. 3
chemistry1973 Posted October 28 Posted October 28 5 hours ago, Jaminbenb said: So giving the A/B a quick listen today while driving and waiting to go into work, I noticed that the drums seemed to be a bit more up front, some of the background and extra parts were missing which gave the tunes a different sound. Show Don't Tell has a totally different feel to it. Superconductor sounds very different with Geddy doing the "Superconductor" vocal rather than (who was it Peter Henderson, I don't have my copy handy) Anagram has some missing stuff, but Neil's drums are WAY up in the mix!! Just a cool difference to hear the songs this way. Listened to it at the gym today on my headphones. The drums are incredible. Shame the final wasn’t closer to this mix and song arrangements. 1
losingit2k Posted October 28 Posted October 28 On 10/23/2026 at 5:04 PM, Lurkst said: These have been professionally uploaded to YouTube now and sound incredible . Much more like a record Thanks for this! Nice Changes there! Loved Available Light
PurpleHayes Posted October 30 Posted October 30 On 2/22/2026 at 2:58 PM, PurpleHayes said: Rupert Hine really wasn't a good fit for Rush, was he? Hine was good for The Fixx, but of course he insisted on adding his annoying background vocals to their songs as well on a few occasions. Hine did one good thing for Rush: he got Geddy to use his voice in a more melodic fashion. Geddy's vocals are truly emotional on songs like The Pass, Presto, and Available Light. But yeah...I LOVE the demo version of Show Don't Tell more than the original. Just add Alex's guitar solo and make a few minor tweaks and it's a much more dynamic song...you can really hear Alex's arpeggios, something he has always excelled at...but thanks to Hine he's buried under a tsunami of synths.
JCW555VT Posted October 30 Posted October 30 I love Presto and Roll the Bones but it felt like both the band and Rupert Hine didn't know how to move Rush back into a rock direction like the band wanted so you're left with two albums that have rock elements but are still keyboard heavy sometimes. It's like a weird combination of what Rush did on Signals-Hold Your Fire and some portends of what the band would sound like from Counterparts-onward.
TheGhostRider Posted Monday at 03:54 PM Posted Monday at 03:54 PM (edited) On 10/26/2026 at 8:04 PM, Jaminbenb said: Ok, so in my own geeky way I decided to put the "Album" track, and the "demo" track side by side on two cdr's to A/B them one after the other. So tomorrow I'll give them a nice critical listen! I've always wondered what happened to the rough mixes from most albums that the band got to take home after sessions just to evaluate on their own. You KNOW there has to be tapes like this from most of, if not EVERY album! (I'd be willing to bet someone has a rough copy of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight on tape somewhere) I know the band claims that they don't have any unreleased material, but stuff like this totally exists, and you know there are people that have copies! THIS is what the box sets REALLY need! (Signals, cough cough) My Recording III professor was Billy Joel's engineer during his BIG years, (dude was a MASTER at tape editing with a razor blade!) and said that any engineer worth his salt has either 1/4" or DAT tapes that ran during sessions for moments when someone said "WAIT, what did you just play?" He brought in great tapes with Billy getting mad and saying "OK, I'M DONE, just order a pizza and we can listen to these tracks again" So I'm sure that there are more things like this out there, we just need to find them!! The live stuff is great, but there are so many awesome boots out there, that even an official live release for some albums isn't as exciting as this! More demos definitely exist. The "Classic Albums" DVD for Moving Pictures plays a tiny snippet of the demo for Tom Sawyer, and I remember seeing a rough cut or "cutting room copy" or something along those lines of Permanent Waves selling online to a "collector" about a year or so ago. Collector in quotes because its more like a hoarder who will never share what they have. I have also heard rumors of earlier demos Pre Permanent Waves existing. I have a photo of the PW demo saved somewhere on my desktop. Edited Monday at 03:57 PM by TheGhostRider
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now