Jump to content

Progressive Bands Poll #2


_hi_water._
 Share

  

7 members have voted

  1. 1. What's your least favorite band out of all of these?

    • Camel
      0
    • Dream Theater
    • Emerson, Lake & Palmer
      0
    • Genesis
      0
    • Gentle Giant
    • Jethro Tull
      0
    • Kansas
      0
    • King Crimson
      0
    • Opeth
    • Pink Floyd
      0
    • Porcupine Tree
      0
    • Supertramp
      0
    • Tool
      0
    • Van Der Graaf Generator
    • Yes
      0
  2. 2. What's your least favorite album out of all of these?

    • ...And Then There Were Three (Genesis)
      0
    • Astonishing (Dream Theater)
    • Black Moon (Emerson, Lake & Palmer)
      0
    • Civilian (Gentle Giant)
    • Construkcution Of Light (King Crimson)
      0
    • Final Cut (Pink Floyd)
      0
    • In Cauda Venenum (Opeth)
    • Nod And A Wink (Camel)
      0
    • Power (Kansas)
      0
    • Present (Van Der Graaf Generator)
      0
    • Salival (Tool)
      0
    • Some Things Never Change (Supertramp)
    • Under Wraps (Jethro Tull)
      0
    • Union (Yes)
      0
    • We Lost The Skyline (Porcupine Tree)
      0
  3. 3. What's your least favorite song out of all of these?

    • Cat Food (King Crimson)
    • Dog's Life (Gentle Giant)
      0
    • Eye In The Sky (Camel)
      0
    • Horizons (Genesis)
      0
    • I Believe In Father Christmas (Emerson, Lake & Palmer)
    • Jets Overhead (Kansas)
      0
    • L.A.M.C. (Tool)
      0
    • La Rossa (Van Der Graaf Generator)
      0
    • Nervana (Pink Floyd)
    • Our Song (Yes)
      0
    • Poor Boy (Supertramp)
      0
    • To Rid The Disease (Opeth)
    • Watching Me Watch You (Jethro Tull)
      0
    • Wedding Nails (Porcupine Tree)
      0
    • You Not Me (Dream Theater)


Recommended Posts

Cookie Monster vocals are an abomination.

 

I've never heard any of these songs but the one I voted for.

Edited by laughedatbytime
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I haven't heard many of these albums or most of these songs, and the only songs I have heard I really do love. So I can't really vote here. Huge prog fan. If it's long and weird and in a strange time signature, it's got my name on it.
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

 

I don't think prog is really unpopular, it's just generally second fiddle to classic rock. There are some around here who don't like it at all, but I think most people at least like Yes and Pink Floyd quite a bit.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

 

I don't think prog is really unpopular, it's just generally second fiddle to classic rock. There are some around here who don't like it at all, but I think most people at least like Yes and Pink Floyd quite a bit.

 

Pink Floyd is NOT prog! lol

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

 

I don't think prog is really unpopular, it's just generally second fiddle to classic rock. There are some around here who don't like it at all, but I think most people at least like Yes and Pink Floyd quite a bit.

 

Pink Floyd is NOT prog! lol

 

Yes they are, Dad!

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

 

I don't think prog is really unpopular, it's just generally second fiddle to classic rock. There are some around here who don't like it at all, but I think most people at least like Yes and Pink Floyd quite a bit.

I guess you're right..... some of the older, classic prog bands like Yes, Floyd, Tull, ELP etc. will resonate with most members, but some of the newer, less 'fashionable' prog bands will probably be unknown quantities to the forum members.
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

 

I don't think prog is really unpopular, it's just generally second fiddle to classic rock. There are some around here who don't like it at all, but I think most people at least like Yes and Pink Floyd quite a bit.

 

Pink Floyd is NOT prog! lol

Err ..... possibly more commercial sounding than some prog ................ but prog nonetheless.
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

 

I don't think prog is really unpopular, it's just generally second fiddle to classic rock. There are some around here who don't like it at all, but I think most people at least like Yes and Pink Floyd quite a bit.

 

Pink Floyd is NOT prog! lol

 

Yes they are, Dad!

prg_p1(42).jpg

A cover from the UK's leading Prog magazine.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

 

I don't think prog is really unpopular, it's just generally second fiddle to classic rock. There are some around here who don't like it at all, but I think most people at least like Yes and Pink Floyd quite a bit.

 

Pink Floyd is NOT prog! lol

go home, you're drunk
  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

 

I don't think prog is really unpopular, it's just generally second fiddle to classic rock. There are some around here who don't like it at all, but I think most people at least like Yes and Pink Floyd quite a bit.

 

Pink Floyd is NOT prog! lol

go home, you're drunk

:hail: :hail: :hail: :hail: :zzz:
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

 

I don't think prog is really unpopular, it's just generally second fiddle to classic rock. There are some around here who don't like it at all, but I think most people at least like Yes and Pink Floyd quite a bit.

 

Pink Floyd is NOT prog! lol

go home, you're drunk

:hail: :hail: :hail: :hail: :zzz:

I was talking to the guy who said Pink Floyd wasn't prog
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

 

I don't think prog is really unpopular, it's just generally second fiddle to classic rock. There are some around here who don't like it at all, but I think most people at least like Yes and Pink Floyd quite a bit.

 

Pink Floyd is NOT prog! lol

go home, you're drunk

:hail: :hail: :hail: :hail: :zzz:

I was talking to the guy who said Pink Floyd wasn't prog

 

I was just having fun with EP (I do enjoy beer tho .. cheers!)

 

but truthfully they have never struck me as prog

 

they seem a bit too mellow-ish on the well known tunes (that's about all I know)

 

at least as far as someone with a cursory understanding of what prog means, they seem to be on the fringes of it

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I haven't heard many of these albums or most of these songs, and the only songs I have heard I really do love. So I can't really vote here. Huge prog fan. If it's long and weird and in a strange time signature, it's got my name on it.

Same here, no vote.

And what's up with Cat Food and Construktion of Light? The song dates back to Wake of Posideon.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

 

I don't think prog is really unpopular, it's just generally second fiddle to classic rock. There are some around here who don't like it at all, but I think most people at least like Yes and Pink Floyd quite a bit.

 

Pink Floyd is NOT prog! lol

go home, you're drunk

:hail: :hail: :hail: :hail: :zzz:

I was talking to the guy who said Pink Floyd wasn't prog

Hehehe ... yeah .. I know!! .... so was I!!
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

 

I don't think prog is really unpopular, it's just generally second fiddle to classic rock. There are some around here who don't like it at all, but I think most people at least like Yes and Pink Floyd quite a bit.

 

Pink Floyd is NOT prog! lol

go home, you're drunk

:hail: :hail: :hail: :hail: :zzz:

I was talking to the guy who said Pink Floyd wasn't prog

 

I was just having fun with EP (I do enjoy beer tho .. cheers!)

 

but truthfully they have never struck me as prog

 

they seem a bit too mellow-ish on the well known tunes (that's about all I know)

 

at least as far as someone with a cursory understanding of what prog means, they seem to be on the fringes of it

Hehe ... we were only messin' !!! I think to be honest the term Prog nowadays is all encompassing, and covers a lot of different styles from the total chill-out mellow like some of Floyd, Camel or Renaissance to complete heavyness like Haken, Dream Theater or Anekdoten. Anyway, lets drink on it! :cheers: Cheers!! Edited by zepphead
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

 

I don't think prog is really unpopular, it's just generally second fiddle to classic rock. There are some around here who don't like it at all, but I think most people at least like Yes and Pink Floyd quite a bit.

 

Pink Floyd is NOT prog! lol

go home, you're drunk

:hail: :hail: :hail: :hail: :zzz:

I was talking to the guy who said Pink Floyd wasn't prog

 

I was just having fun with EP (I do enjoy beer tho .. cheers!)

 

but truthfully they have never struck me as prog

 

they seem a bit too mellow-ish on the well known tunes (that's about all I know)

 

at least as far as someone with a cursory understanding of what prog means, they seem to be on the fringes of it

Hehe ... we were only messin' !!! I think to be honest the term Prog nowadays is all encompassing, and covers a lot of different styles from the total chill-out mellow like some of Floyd, Camel or Renaissance to complete heavyness like Haken, Dream Theater or Anekdoten. Anyway, lets drink on it! :cheers: Cheers!!

 

 

My thing with Pink Floyd is they are so huge with just casual rock fans, who I know wouldn't get thru a few minutes of Suppers Ready or 2112

 

I think my mind goes to that thought when I hear them mentioned along side of bands like Rush and Genesis

 

seem to be more bluesy and less jazzy

 

Prog covers a lot of ground tho .. you are correct

 

Cheers!!

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

 

I don't think prog is really unpopular, it's just generally second fiddle to classic rock. There are some around here who don't like it at all, but I think most people at least like Yes and Pink Floyd quite a bit.

 

Pink Floyd is NOT prog! lol

 

Yes they are, Dad!

 

Just thought of a good comparison at lunch EP .. Pink Floyd is to prog what Green Day is to punk .. thoughts?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

 

it's only good if it's on classic rock radio around here

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

 

it's only good if it's on classic rock radio around here

:no:
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

 

it's only good if it's on classic rock radio around here

:no:

 

But those are the only songs that we as the general public are given permission to like. You mean there's more out there than what has been preapproved for us to listen to?

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted

- VDGG

- Supertramp album

- ELP Christmas monstrosity.

 

This could be an awkward poll as i get the impression that Prog is not that popular with many TRF members.

I however think it's great and is reminding me of some real Prog clunkers!!

 

it's only good if it's on classic rock radio around here

:no:

 

But those are the only songs that we as the general public are given permission to like. You mean there's more out there than what has been preapproved for us to listen to?

:yes:
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...