Rank the Led Zeppelin albums

[Texas King]

I will rank them like this:

 

1.LZ II

2.Physical Graffiti

3.LZ IV

4.LZ I

5.LZ III

6.HOTH

 

7.Presence

8.ITTOD

 

9.Coda

[Lucas]

Top 3 - in no particular order

 

- Houses Of The Holy

- III

- II

 

IV would be next, then their debut

 

I'm not a big fan of Physical Graffiti and by Presence there was no gas left in the tank ... actually, I'd probably rate In Through The Out Door over Presence

[Entre_Perpetuo]

_____

Led Zeppelin II

Houses Of The Holy

Led Zeppelin III

Physical Graffiti

Led Zeppelin

 

those are the ones I've heard

[treeduck]

II

IV

III

I

Holy

Presence

Graffiti

Door

Coda

[Stormtron]

III

Houses of the Holy

II

IV

Physical Graffiti

I

Presence

In Through the Out Door

Coda

[laughedatbytime]

I

II

IV

Physical Graffiti

III

HOTH

Presence

In Through the Out Door

Coda

Edited August 27, 2017 by laughedatbytime

[HemiBeers]

IV

Houses

PG

[custom55]

IV

II

HOTH

[The Cat 3]

Houses of the Holy

 

I

 

IV

 

II

 

III

 

Presence

 

Physical Graffiti

 

In Through the Outdoor

 

Coda

[Presto-digitation]

My picks were III, IV, and PG.

 

Houses would be next.

[vital signz]

IV

II

I

PG = HOTH

III

Presence

ITTOD

 

CODA

[Narps]

Physical Graffiti tops and ITTOD way at the bottom...

[Steevo]

I'd probably rate In Through The Out Door over Presence

 

EH??!! :o Ye Gods man, have you forgotten the genius of Achilles, For Your Life or even Tea for One???? Ok I know there's some stinkers in there but hardly running out of steam! ITTOD, ack I've argued this with TD from time to time, it's still got some killer Zep vibe in there but yep, probably their weakest album overall.

[Ancient Ways]

PG

HotH

IV

[Oracle]

For me:

 

1. Houses of the Holy

2. LZ3

3. LZ4

4. Physical Graffiti

5. LZ2

6. LZ1

7. Presence

8. ITTOD

9. Coda

[Chronos]

_____

Led Zeppelin II

Houses Of The Holy

Led Zeppelin III

Physical Graffiti

Led Zeppelin

 

those are the ones I've heard

 

Wait...what? You've never heard IV?

 

What are you waiting for? Get on that. Now.

[Entre_Perpetuo]

_____

Led Zeppelin II

Houses Of The Holy

Led Zeppelin III

Physical Graffiti

Led Zeppelin

 

those are the ones I've heard

 

Wait...what? You've never heard IV?

 

What are you waiting for? Get on that. Now.

 

Led Zeppelin IV is not the actual name of the record to which you refer. You see that space at the top of my list? ;)

Edited August 28, 2017 by Entre_Perpetuo

[Na na na]

Physical Graffiti

Houses Of The Holy

Led Zeppelin III

Presence

Led Zeppelin II

Led Zeppelin IV

Led Zeppelin

In Through The Out door

[Lorraine]

Debut

PG

Presence

[Bigbobby10]

I

House of the Holy

IV

[ReRushed]

Hmmm. This is difficult.

 

Top tier: Led Zeppelin, Led Zeppelin IV, Physical Graffiti

Middle tier: Led Zeppelin II, Houses of the Holy, In Through the Out Door

Bottom tier: Led Zeppelin III, Presence, Coda

 

Personally, I can't rank them because it's the thinnest of margins that separates my preference. And my preference is determined by my mood.

[vaportrailer]

fave 3:

Phys Graf

IV

III

 

bottom 2:

II

Coda

[Entre_Perpetuo]

fave 3:

Phys Graf

IV

III

 

bottom 2:

II

Coda

 

II in the bottom two?

[Lucas]

I'd probably rate In Through The Out Door over Presence

 

EH??!! :o Ye Gods man, have you forgotten the genius of Achilles, For Your Life or even Tea for One???? Ok I know there's some stinkers in there but hardly running out of steam! ITTOD, ack I've argued this with TD from time to time, it's still got some killer Zep vibe in there but yep, probably their weakest album overall.

 

It's probably sentiment that puts In Through The Out Door a little higher

 

I was 12 years old on the Boardwalk in Asbury Park, NJ, and I won ITTOD throwing a bean bag at a stack of bottles

 

 

true story .. great memories

 

Plus, Hot Dog rocks

[toymaker]

Coda! For Poor Tom and Ozone Baby alone!