Jump to content

The David Lee Roth end of the road retirement poll - 1991 revisited vs Van Hagar


treeduck
 Share

DLR poll 1991 edition  

17 members have voted

  1. 1. Which 1991 album do you think is better?

    • David Lee Roth - A Little Ain't Enough
    • Van Halen - For Unlawful Carnal Knowledge
  2. 2. Which guitarist produced the better performance on the aforementioned albums?

    • Jason Becker
    • Edward Van Halen
  3. 3. Which singer was nearer to the top of his game in 1991?



Recommended Posts

Excellent quick poll.

 

I need to quickly listen to Edward's guitar on FUKK and Jason's on Ain't Enough.

 

As the Terminator used to say...

 

 

"I'll be back......."

Thanks Earl.

 

I think I know where my votes are going!

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Eddie's guitar tone will always be my favorite however on F.U.C.K. I don't really care for the production.

 

Jason's guitar production is much better in comparison to these two albums.

 

JMO

Yeah I like F.U.C.K. but the production is very tinny and flat and boxy-sounding, and it's an issue throughout the album.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Eddie's guitar tone will always be my favorite however on F.U.C.K. I don't really care for the production.

 

Jason's guitar production is much better in comparison to these two albums.

 

JMO

Yeah I like F.U.C.K. but the production is very tinny and flat and boxy-sounding, and it's an issue throughout the album.

 

Very true Pat. I feel the same way about F.U.C.K. Production sucks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

ROTH > HAGAR

Hagar thinks that because he plays guitar he has the edge over Dave.

 

Hahaha! That's a joke. I'll take Dave playing acoustic guitar on "Ice Cream Man" over Sammy playing on anything Van Hagar crap.

 

I do love Sammy's Montrose work. His Capital Records catalog. Oh and I do love every record he has on GEFFEN up to VOA!!

 

After that? CRAPGAR

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

ROTH > HAGAR

Hagar thinks that because he plays guitar he has the edge over Dave.

 

Hahaha! That's a joke. I'll take Dave playing acoustic guitar on "Ice Cream Man" over Sammy playing on anything Van Hagar crap.

 

I do love Sammy's Montrose work. His Capital Records catalog. Oh and I do love every record he has on GEFFEN up to VOA!!

 

After that? CRAPGAR

:lol:

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

ROTH > HAGAR

Hagar thinks that because he plays guitar he has the edge over Dave.

Sammy has a better singing voice, but Dave's got swagger.

^^

This here.

Edited by grep
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Of course the Sammy crap is winning here.

 

The Van Hagar Fans outweigh the real Van Halen Fans here on this site. Always have, always will.

We used to have some fun arguments about real Van Halen vs the Van Hagar crap.

The good old days.

 

David Lee Roth BLOWS Sammy Fairygar AWAY!!!!!

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Of course the Sammy crap is winning here.

 

The Van Hagar Fans outweigh the real Van Halen Fans here on this site. Always have, always will.

We used to have some fun arguments about real Van Halen vs the Van Hagar crap.

The good old days.

 

David Lee Roth BLOWS Sammy Fairygar AWAY!!!!!

I still listen to Dogtown Shuffle and Drop in the Bucket, It`s Showtime! They`re on my current playlist. Can`t risk listening to F.U.C.K in case I hear any part of Spanked. "Call me up on the spankline" :spitwater: Edited by IbanezJem
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Of course the Sammy crap is winning here.

 

The Van Hagar Fans outweigh the real Van Halen Fans here on this site. Always have, always will.

We used to have some fun arguments about real Van Halen vs the Van Hagar crap.

The good old days.

 

David Lee Roth BLOWS Sammy Fairygar AWAY!!!!!

I think the Van Halen fans on here back Eddie over Roth and that's the true deciding factor. Sammy is just a bystander.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Earl I'm listening to the POLICE now, can you think of many rock drummers that can match Copeland?

 

Also it's obvious that when RUSH heard the Police they decided to totally rip off their sound from about 1982 onwards.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Of course the Sammy crap is winning here.

 

The Van Hagar Fans outweigh the real Van Halen Fans here on this site. Always have, always will.

We used to have some fun arguments about real Van Halen vs the Van Hagar crap.

The good old days.

 

David Lee Roth BLOWS Sammy Fairygar AWAY!!!!!

I think the Van Halen fans on here back Eddie over Roth and that's the true deciding factor. Sammy is just a bystander.

Eddie and Dave > Eddie and Sammy, Dave > Sam. It`s simple, whatever Dave`s on brings the best out of Ed.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Of course the Sammy crap is winning here.

 

The Van Hagar Fans outweigh the real Van Halen Fans here on this site. Always have, always will.

We used to have some fun arguments about real Van Halen vs the Van Hagar crap.

The good old days.

 

David Lee Roth BLOWS Sammy Fairygar AWAY!!!!!

I think the Van Halen fans on here back Eddie over Roth and that's the true deciding factor. Sammy is just a bystander.

Eddie and Dave > Eddie and Sammy, Dave > Sam. It`s simple, whatever Dave`s on brings the best out of Ed.

Yeah but my point is as long as it's Eddie on one side and Roth on the other, a lot of VH fans will always back Eddie come what may.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Of course the Sammy crap is winning here.

 

The Van Hagar Fans outweigh the real Van Halen Fans here on this site. Always have, always will.

We used to have some fun arguments about real Van Halen vs the Van Hagar crap.

The good old days.

 

David Lee Roth BLOWS Sammy Fairygar AWAY!!!!!

I think the Van Halen fans on here back Eddie over Roth and that's the true deciding factor. Sammy is just a bystander.

Eddie and Dave > Eddie and Sammy, Dave > Sam. It`s simple, whatever Dave`s on brings the best out of Ed.

Yeah but my point is as long as it's Eddie on one side and Roth on the other, a lot of VH fans will always back Eddie come what may.

I get it, I know some people here think that and lots on VHND did too. I love Eddie more than any other musician but it`s nuts to say anything after 1986 was as good as `78-84. Edited by IbanezJem
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Of course the Sammy crap is winning here.

 

The Van Hagar Fans outweigh the real Van Halen Fans here on this site. Always have, always will.

We used to have some fun arguments about real Van Halen vs the Van Hagar crap.

The good old days.

 

David Lee Roth BLOWS Sammy Fairygar AWAY!!!!!

I think the Van Halen fans on here back Eddie over Roth and that's the true deciding factor. Sammy is just a bystander.

Eddie and Dave > Eddie and Sammy, Dave > Sam. It`s simple, whatever Dave`s on brings the best out of Ed.

Yeah but my point is as long as it's Eddie on one side and Roth on the other, a lot of VH fans will always back Eddie come what may.

I get it, I know some people here think that and lots on VHND did too. I love Eddie more than any other musician but it`s nuts to say anything after 1986 was as good as `78-84.

I know. After 1984 there was something missing from Eddie's playing, the tone wasn't the same, the energetic attack, the swing wasn't there, the grit was missing.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Of course the Sammy crap is winning here.

 

The Van Hagar Fans outweigh the real Van Halen Fans here on this site. Always have, always will.

We used to have some fun arguments about real Van Halen vs the Van Hagar crap.

The good old days.

 

David Lee Roth BLOWS Sammy Fairygar AWAY!!!!!

I think the Van Halen fans on here back Eddie over Roth and that's the true deciding factor. Sammy is just a bystander.

Eddie and Dave > Eddie and Sammy, Dave > Sam. It`s simple, whatever Dave`s on brings the best out of Ed.

Yeah but my point is as long as it's Eddie on one side and Roth on the other, a lot of VH fans will always back Eddie come what may.

I get it, I know some people here think that and lots on VHND did too. I love Eddie more than any other musician but it`s nuts to say anything after 1986 was as good as `78-84.

I know. After 1984 there was something missing from Eddie's playing, the tone wasn't the same, the energetic attack, the swing wasn't there, the grit was missing.

Yes, some of notes he`d play, little pinch harmonics and things, just the fun of it wasn`t there for me. Big grin turned into moody and sunglasses :( Edited by IbanezJem
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Of course the Sammy crap is winning here.

 

The Van Hagar Fans outweigh the real Van Halen Fans here on this site. Always have, always will.

We used to have some fun arguments about real Van Halen vs the Van Hagar crap.

The good old days.

 

David Lee Roth BLOWS Sammy Fairygar AWAY!!!!!

I think the Van Halen fans on here back Eddie over Roth and that's the true deciding factor. Sammy is just a bystander.

Eddie and Dave > Eddie and Sammy, Dave > Sam. It`s simple, whatever Dave`s on brings the best out of Ed.

Yeah but my point is as long as it's Eddie on one side and Roth on the other, a lot of VH fans will always back Eddie come what may.

I get it, I know some people here think that and lots on VHND did too. I love Eddie more than any other musician but it`s nuts to say anything after 1986 was as good as `78-84.

I know. After 1984 there was something missing from Eddie's playing, the tone wasn't the same, the energetic attack, the swing wasn't there, the grit was missing.

 

Absolutely! The Brown Sound turned into the Frown Sound! What the Fukk Eddie? Greatest guitar player ever.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Of course the Sammy crap is winning here.

 

The Van Hagar Fans outweigh the real Van Halen Fans here on this site. Always have, always will.

We used to have some fun arguments about real Van Halen vs the Van Hagar crap.

The good old days.

 

David Lee Roth BLOWS Sammy Fairygar AWAY!!!!!

I think the Van Halen fans on here back Eddie over Roth and that's the true deciding factor. Sammy is just a bystander.

Eddie and Dave > Eddie and Sammy, Dave > Sam. It`s simple, whatever Dave`s on brings the best out of Ed.

Yeah but my point is as long as it's Eddie on one side and Roth on the other, a lot of VH fans will always back Eddie come what may.

I get it, I know some people here think that and lots on VHND did too. I love Eddie more than any other musician but it`s nuts to say anything after 1986 was as good as `78-84.

I know. After 1984 there was something missing from Eddie's playing, the tone wasn't the same, the energetic attack, the swing wasn't there, the grit was missing.

 

Absolutely! The Brown Sound turned into the Frown Sound! What the Fukk Eddie? Greatest guitar player ever.

Sammy took his balls!

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Of course the Sammy crap is winning here.

 

The Van Hagar Fans outweigh the real Van Halen Fans here on this site. Always have, always will.

We used to have some fun arguments about real Van Halen vs the Van Hagar crap.

The good old days.

 

David Lee Roth BLOWS Sammy Fairygar AWAY!!!!!

I think the Van Halen fans on here back Eddie over Roth and that's the true deciding factor. Sammy is just a bystander.

Eddie and Dave > Eddie and Sammy, Dave > Sam. It`s simple, whatever Dave`s on brings the best out of Ed.

Yeah but my point is as long as it's Eddie on one side and Roth on the other, a lot of VH fans will always back Eddie come what may.

I get it, I know some people here think that and lots on VHND did too. I love Eddie more than any other musician but it`s nuts to say anything after 1986 was as good as `78-84.

I know. After 1984 there was something missing from Eddie's playing, the tone wasn't the same, the energetic attack, the swing wasn't there, the grit was missing.

 

Absolutely! The Brown Sound turned into the Frown Sound! What the Fukk Eddie? Greatest guitar player ever.

Sammy took his balls!

 

Totally! That's "One Testicle Out The Door!"

 

That fuckking Hammy Sagar record with Eddie on the bass. Pure SHITE.

 

Sammy needs to be "Spanked."

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...