Jump to content

A Farewell to Kings vs Presto


treeduck
 Share

AFTK vs Presto  

26 members have voted

  1. 1. Which album is best?



Recommended Posts

the fact Presto has any votes baffles me

Because it doesn't have songs about dragons or rocket ships?

at least it's better than talking about painting a mirror black or rock paper scissors

I like the idea of painting the mirror black as a pushback against how society pressures us to judge ourselves. As for rock paper scissors, I don't like it as a song, but I do like the imagery used in the album art to represent the three members playing their instruments.

 

presto-wm2.jpg

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

the fact Presto has any votes baffles me

Because it doesn't have songs about dragons or rocket ships?

at least it's better than talking about painting a mirror black or rock paper scissors

I like the idea of painting the mirror black as a pushback against how society pressures us to judge ourselves. As for rock paper scissors, I don't like it as a song, but I do like the imagery used in the album art to represent the three members playing their instruments.

 

presto-wm2.jpg

the only song on the album with excellent lyrics is "The Pass" and maybe "Presto" and "Red Tide"
Link to comment
Share on other sites

the fact Presto has any votes baffles me

Because it doesn't have songs about dragons or rocket ships?

at least it's better than talking about painting a mirror black or rock paper scissors

I like the idea of painting the mirror black as a pushback against how society pressures us to judge ourselves. As for rock paper scissors, I don't like it as a song, but I do like the imagery used in the album art to represent the three members playing their instruments.

 

presto-wm2.jpg

 

I like the imagery because it's a comment on appearances, and putting up a façade. The album narrative is about concealment, artifice and underlying troubles.

 

Paper beats rock because it HIDES the rock. I don't know, maybe that's silly, but I dig it.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

the fact Presto has any votes baffles me

Because it doesn't have songs about dragons or rocket ships?

at least it's better than talking about painting a mirror black or rock paper scissors

I like the idea of painting the mirror black as a pushback against how society pressures us to judge ourselves. As for rock paper scissors, I don't like it as a song, but I do like the imagery used in the album art to represent the three members playing their instruments.

 

presto-wm2.jpg

 

I like the imagery because it's a comment on appearances, and putting up a façade. The album narrative is about concealment, artifice and underlying troubles.

 

Paper beats rock because it HIDES the rock. I don't know, maybe that's silly, but I dig it.

so Neil was a shit lyricist wasn't he? :eh:
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

the fact Presto has any votes baffles me

Because it doesn't have songs about dragons or rocket ships?

at least it's better than talking about painting a mirror black or rock paper scissors

I like the idea of painting the mirror black as a pushback against how society pressures us to judge ourselves. As for rock paper scissors, I don't like it as a song, but I do like the imagery used in the album art to represent the three members playing their instruments.

 

presto-wm2.jpg

 

I like the imagery because it's a comment on appearances, and putting up a façade. The album narrative is about concealment, artifice and underlying troubles.

 

Paper beats rock because it HIDES the rock. I don't know, maybe that's silly, but I dig it.

so Neil was a shit lyricist wasn't he? :eh:

 

No way. When he misses, he misses big. When he hits, he nails it.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

the fact Presto has any votes baffles me

Because it doesn't have songs about dragons or rocket ships?

at least it's better than talking about painting a mirror black or rock paper scissors

I like the idea of painting the mirror black as a pushback against how society pressures us to judge ourselves. As for rock paper scissors, I don't like it as a song, but I do like the imagery used in the album art to represent the three members playing their instruments.

 

presto-wm2.jpg

the only song on the album with excellent lyrics is "The Pass" and maybe "Presto" and "Red Tide"

Scars has good lyrical imagery, as do Available Light, Chain Lightning, War Paint. In their respective lyrics, Presto stacks up very well against AFTK as an album.
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

the fact Presto has any votes baffles me

Because it doesn't have songs about dragons or rocket ships?

at least it's better than talking about painting a mirror black or rock paper scissors

I like the idea of painting the mirror black as a pushback against how society pressures us to judge ourselves. As for rock paper scissors, I don't like it as a song, but I do like the imagery used in the album art to represent the three members playing their instruments.

 

presto-wm2.jpg

 

I like the imagery because it's a comment on appearances, and putting up a façade. The album narrative is about concealment, artifice and underlying troubles.

 

Paper beats rock because it HIDES the rock. I don't know, maybe that's silly, but I dig it.

so Neil was a shit lyricist wasn't he? :eh:

 

No way. When he misses, he misses big. When he hits, he nails it.

From cringe-worthy to the sublime.
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

the fact Presto has any votes baffles me

Because it doesn't have songs about dragons or rocket ships?

at least it's better than talking about painting a mirror black or rock paper scissors

I like the idea of painting the mirror black as a pushback against how society pressures us to judge ourselves. As for rock paper scissors, I don't like it as a song, but I do like the imagery used in the album art to represent the three members playing their instruments.

 

presto-wm2.jpg

 

I like the imagery because it's a comment on appearances, and putting up a façade. The album narrative is about concealment, artifice and underlying troubles.

 

Paper beats rock because it HIDES the rock. I don't know, maybe that's silly, but I dig it.

so Neil was a shit lyricist wasn't he? :eh:

 

No way. When he misses, he misses big. When he hits, he nails it.

From cringe-worthy to the sublime.

but lyrics aren't the reason I listen to Rush (unlike some people here)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Presto has actually got a vote. Its a funny old world!

 

That was me.

 

I love Xanadu.

 

That's it.

 

I enjoy Presto much more. Maybe because it was my first Rush studio release (after I became a fan, purchasing ASOF)

 

Available Light, Hand Over Fist, Show Me Don't Tell Me, The Pass - it's much more consistent record, though of course it doesn't have Cygnus or Xanadu ---But Presto also doen't include songs as cringe-worthy as Cinderella Man or Madrigal.

 

I think my drumming sensibilities have something to do with it. I just like the way NP plays on Presto - and I love that Copeland-inspired drum sound. On AFTK, the toms sound muted and dull, and snare doesn't have that CRACK that I love on Presto.

 

Of course I can't ignore how groundbreaking AFTK is, but it's Rush's Topographic Oceans Tormato to me. Great ideas that don't always cohere...

First purchases of a band's material will always make that album special to the individual ..... in my case I got Caress Of Steel and probably love it more than it deserves .... and in your case Presto.
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

the fact Presto has any votes baffles me

Because it doesn't have songs about dragons or rocket ships?

How about dragons IN rocket ships ... man that would be good!!
  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wasn't going to pick, and choose any particular one because I've liked them the same, and they've been uniquely different in each of their ways.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

the fact Presto has any votes baffles me

Because it doesn't have songs about dragons or rocket ships?

at least it's better than talking about painting a mirror black or rock paper scissors

I like the idea of painting the mirror black as a pushback against how society pressures us to judge ourselves. As for rock paper scissors, I don't like it as a song, but I do like the imagery used in the album art to represent the three members playing their instruments.

 

presto-wm2.jpg

 

I like the imagery because it's a comment on appearances, and putting up a façade. The album narrative is about concealment, artifice and underlying troubles.

 

Paper beats rock because it HIDES the rock. I don't know, maybe that's silly, but I dig it.

so Neil was a shit lyricist wasn't he? :eh:

 

No way. When he misses, he misses big. When he hits, he nails it.

From cringe-worthy to the sublime.

but lyrics aren't the reason I listen to Rush (unlike some people here)

 

Then why did you mention the lyrics? You are the one who brought them up, right?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A Farewell to Kings

http://www-eluniverso-com.cdn.ampproject.org/i/s/www.eluniverso.com/sites/default/files/styles/nota_ampliada_normal_foto/public/fotos/2020/06/retorno-de-captain-america-al-mcu.jpg?itok=nNcQvqRF

 

VS.

 

Presto

http://images.static-bluray.com/reviews/7875_1_large.jpg

Indeed! Overwraught and comically corny vs. A more mature and understated approach.

 

:P

 

:P

 

On a side trivia note, the “Presto” Captain America is J.D. Salinger’s kid, Matt. Has nothing to do with anything other than me just remembering that now.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...