Eel Yddeg Posted January 27, 2016 Share Posted January 27, 2016 One mystery that has always raged in the Rush bootleg community is with the Seattle 1976 show.The show has been bootlegged under the namesAnthem of SeattleBattle in SeattleBy-Tor's BattleSeattle SupersonicOne, Two, Buckle My Shoe2112 DaysParamount EveSeattle NightsThe mystery revolves around the date of the show. Was it recorded on March 28, 1976, on the 2112 Tour, or on October 25, 1976, on the All The World's A Stage Tour?The venue is the main thing agreed on, the Paramount Theater in Seattle. However, there are a lot of holes in the theory. The tour dates on the official website list a show on March 28, 1976, at the Paramount Theater, but it is the Paramount Theater in Portland, not the Paramount Theater in Seattle. To make things even more confusing, Rush did not perform any concerts on October 25, 1976! However, it does list a date at the Paramount Theater in Seattle on the 28th.So it's definitive that the concert was not recorded on the 25th, as no shows were on that date. The two candidates now seem to be March 28 and October 28.So what tour was it recorded on? I lean towards the 2112 tour.This show was a headlining gig, as Styx, the original headliner, cancelled their set, allowing Rush to perform a full show.The set for this concert consisted ofBastille DayAnthemLakeside Park2112Fly By NightIn The MoodSomething For NothingIn The EndBy-Tor and the Snow DogWorking ManFinding My WayDrum Soloand Best I Can.This set is exactly the same as the other 2112 tour gig (Tuning Man, 5/30/1976, another headlining gig) except that the encore is different (What You're Doing instead of Best I Can) and In The End and By-Tor switch places. The headlining set lists for the All The World's A Stage tour, on the other hand, were very different.The headlining set list for the 1976 All The World's A Stage tour gigs consisted of Bastille DayAnthemLakeside Park2112The Twilight ZoneSomething For NothingBest I CanBy-Tor and the Snow DogThe NecromancerIn The EndWorking ManFinding My WayDrum SoloFly By NightIn The MoodThis set list is very different. The Twilight Zone and the Necromancer, which were nowhere to be found on the 2112 gigs, are in, Fly By Night and In The Mood are encores, and other songs have their orders swapped.So this solves the mystery that the show was recorded on the 2112 tour, in Portland Oregon's Paramount Theater, on March 28, 1976.I hope that this clears up everything about the recording. 6 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kamrahai Posted January 28, 2016 Share Posted January 28, 2016 I'm not disagreeing with you and you may be right but just wanted to say that the 5 versions of this show that I have all have the Oct 25th date. I am aware of the debate over the dates but personally I just enter them on my bootlist with the documented date to avoid confusion. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Blue J Posted January 28, 2016 Share Posted January 28, 2016 I'm not disagreeing with you and you may be right but just wanted to say that the 5 versions of this show that I have all have the Oct 25th date. I am aware of the debate over the dates but personally I just enter them on my bootlist with the documented date to avoid confusion.  Yep, this is my vote, too. I'm sure it's October 25th. I believe we have a poster on TRF who attended that show. Several months back, maybe a year ago, he was surprised to find out that a recording of it existed (and its a fairly well known one, at that). I offered to send a copy to him, but I never got a reply,  kam- five versions of the same gig?  ;) 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kamrahai Posted January 28, 2016 Share Posted January 28, 2016 I'm not disagreeing with you and you may be right but just wanted to say that the 5 versions of this show that I have all have the Oct 25th date. I am aware of the debate over the dates but personally I just enter them on my bootlist with the documented date to avoid confusion.  Yep, this is my vote, too. I'm sure it's October 25th. I believe we have a poster on TRF who attended that show. Several months back, maybe a year ago, he was surprised to find out that a recording of it existed (and its a fairly well known one, at that). I offered to send a copy to him, but I never got a reply,  kam- five versions of the same gig?  ;) Yeah I'm a bit fanatical in my boot collecting...lolCheck my sig link out ;) 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ytserush Posted January 28, 2016 Share Posted January 28, 2016 I'm not disagreeing with you and you may be right but just wanted to say that the 5 versions of this show that I have all have the Oct 25th date. I am aware of the debate over the dates but personally I just enter them on my bootlist with the documented date to avoid confusion.  Yep, this is my vote, too. I'm sure it's October 25th. I believe we have a poster on TRF who attended that show. Several months back, maybe a year ago, he was surprised to find out that a recording of it existed (and its a fairly well known one, at that). I offered to send a copy to him, but I never got a reply,  kam- five versions of the same gig?  ;) Yeah I'm a bit fanatical in my boot collecting...lolCheck my sig link out ;) I think I have more than six versions of this if you count cassettes. But yeah, I was under the impression that it's the March 28, 1976 date for nearly 20 years now. At least one of my cassette versions has the October date which the early CDs likely referenced without a fact check. Someone may have transcribed the date wrong originally or made an honest mistake and it propagated from there. That happens sometimes. You still get dates for the Grace Under Pressure Tour bootleg being in 1986 because that's when it was originally simulcast on radio and MTV (I taped this from radio either in March, April or May of 1986) even though the show was recorded on Sept. 20/21 1984. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kamrahai Posted January 28, 2016 Share Posted January 28, 2016 (edited) I also lean towards the March 28 date but like I stated above I keep it listed with the October date simply because that's the way it usually circulates. As anyone can and has probably read on the DRE the following comment tends to support that... Jim Burleigh Regarding the 1976, Seattle shows. I was at the October 25, 1976 show at the Paramount Theatre in Seattle, WA. I will never forget that show as long as I live. You see it was the second time I had seen Rush live; the first time was an accident. A friend asked me to accompany him to the March 27, 1976 show at Gonzaga University in Spokane to see Styx. Neither of us knew that Rush existed prior to that fateful spring evening. The shows that are on the Seattle Supersonic and By-Tor's Battle CD's are identical. I was able to play them simultaneously, and they are absolutely the same right down to the little guitar chord ?chops? that Alex does while Geddy is introducing songs. The set is precisely the same as the Spokane show (with the exception of ?The Jam?) and I am convinced that this is the March show. The instrumental jam DID NOT happen at the October 25, 1976 show, I assure you of that without reservation. Additionally, at the October show, Geddy introduces "In The End" by saying "We'd like to mellow out for a few minutes, if you will allow us..." and the crowd expresses it's displeasure at that statement very loudly. Never the less, Geddy is brought a stool from off-stage and he sits to play the first section of the song, then stands for the second part. I have a photographic memory and I also made a list of the songs that they did at the October show, because I was still becoming familiar with their first three albums (I bought 2112 on the Sunday night after I returned to Seattle from Spokane, in fact there was a poster in the window of the record store ? Tower Records on 5th Ave. N. and Mercer St. ? advertising the Rush show that very evening, the 28th of March) and I found my little notebook with that list in it while going through some boxes stored in my parents basement. I have no doubt whatsoever that this is, in fact, the March 1976 show on both of these CD?s. (2002-03-24) Edited January 28, 2016 by kamrahai Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
78jazz Posted January 28, 2016 Share Posted January 28, 2016 IIRC there was a Japanese collector who did some fairly in-depth analysis to attempt to answer this question. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Blue J Posted January 30, 2016 Share Posted January 30, 2016 Reading the white letters on the black background makes my eyes hurt. Â I read the whole thing, and I'm still seeing black lines everywhere, a couple minutes later. Â :blink: Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Blue J Posted January 30, 2016 Share Posted January 30, 2016 I'm not disagreeing with you and you may be right but just wanted to say that the 5 versions of this show that I have all have the Oct 25th date. I am aware of the debate over the dates but personally I just enter them on my bootlist with the documented date to avoid confusion.  Yep, this is my vote, too. I'm sure it's October 25th. I believe we have a poster on TRF who attended that show. Several months back, maybe a year ago, he was surprised to find out that a recording of it existed (and its a fairly well known one, at that). I offered to send a copy to him, but I never got a reply,  kam- five versions of the same gig?  ;) Yeah I'm a bit fanatical in my boot collecting...lolCheck my sig link out ;) I used to be, but not anymore. I just go by the date of a show, and if I already have a performance, I don't need to get two or three or four or five of the same one, hahaha...but to each his own. :cheers: I will check out your whole list, though. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kamrahai Posted January 30, 2016 Share Posted January 30, 2016 I'm not disagreeing with you and you may be right but just wanted to say that the 5 versions of this show that I have all have the Oct 25th date. I am aware of the debate over the dates but personally I just enter them on my bootlist with the documented date to avoid confusion.  Yep, this is my vote, too. I'm sure it's October 25th. I believe we have a poster on TRF who attended that show. Several months back, maybe a year ago, he was surprised to find out that a recording of it existed (and its a fairly well known one, at that). I offered to send a copy to him, but I never got a reply,  kam- five versions of the same gig?  ;) Yeah I'm a bit fanatical in my boot collecting...lolCheck my sig link out ;) I used to be, but not anymore. I just go by the date of a show, and if I already have a performance, I don't need to get two or three or four or five of the same one, hahaha...but to each his own. :cheers: I will check out your whole list, though. Yeah I hear ya. With a few exceptions the only band I want multiples of the same date of is :rush: 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
troutman Posted January 30, 2016 Share Posted January 30, 2016 I'm not disagreeing with you and you may be right but just wanted to say that the 5 versions of this show that I have all have the Oct 25th date. I am aware of the debate over the dates but personally I just enter them on my bootlist with the documented date to avoid confusion.  Yep, this is my vote, too. I'm sure it's October 25th. I believe we have a poster on TRF who attended that show. Several months back, maybe a year ago, he was surprised to find out that a recording of it existed (and its a fairly well known one, at that). I offered to send a copy to him, but I never got a reply,  kam- five versions of the same gig?  ;) I want a copy!! :madra: :D 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Blue J Posted January 30, 2016 Share Posted January 30, 2016 I'm not disagreeing with you and you may be right but just wanted to say that the 5 versions of this show that I have all have the Oct 25th date. I am aware of the debate over the dates but personally I just enter them on my bootlist with the documented date to avoid confusion.  Yep, this is my vote, too. I'm sure it's October 25th. I believe we have a poster on TRF who attended that show. Several months back, maybe a year ago, he was surprised to find out that a recording of it existed (and its a fairly well known one, at that). I offered to send a copy to him, but I never got a reply,  kam- five versions of the same gig?  ;) Yeah I'm a bit fanatical in my boot collecting...lolCheck my sig link out ;) I used to be, but not anymore. I just go by the date of a show, and if I already have a performance, I don't need to get two or three or four or five of the same one, hahaha...but to each his own. :cheers: I will check out your whole list, though. Yeah I hear ya. With a few exceptions the only band I want multiples of the same date of is :rush:  I think if it's a difference between a soundboard and an AUD, then yeah, that's truly different. But anyway... :haz: Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Blue J Posted January 30, 2016 Share Posted January 30, 2016 I'm not disagreeing with you and you may be right but just wanted to say that the 5 versions of this show that I have all have the Oct 25th date. I am aware of the debate over the dates but personally I just enter them on my bootlist with the documented date to avoid confusion.  Yep, this is my vote, too. I'm sure it's October 25th. I believe we have a poster on TRF who attended that show. Several months back, maybe a year ago, he was surprised to find out that a recording of it existed (and its a fairly well known one, at that). I offered to send a copy to him, but I never got a reply,  kam- five versions of the same gig?  ;) I want a copy!! :madra: :D I'm on it. ;) 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
troutman Posted January 30, 2016 Share Posted January 30, 2016 I'm not disagreeing with you and you may be right but just wanted to say that the 5 versions of this show that I have all have the Oct 25th date. I am aware of the debate over the dates but personally I just enter them on my bootlist with the documented date to avoid confusion.  Yep, this is my vote, too. I'm sure it's October 25th. I believe we have a poster on TRF who attended that show. Several months back, maybe a year ago, he was surprised to find out that a recording of it existed (and its a fairly well known one, at that). I offered to send a copy to him, but I never got a reply,  kam- five versions of the same gig?  ;) I want a copy!! :madra: :D I'm on it. ;) I can pay for the postage. :D Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Blue J Posted January 30, 2016 Share Posted January 30, 2016  I just went and found my disc, and according to the information that kam posted, then what I have is, in fact the March gig. I've had it for years, and I never knew! :doh: It has something labeled 'Alex and Neil Jam' just prior to In the End. Let me know if you still want it, troutman. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
troutman Posted January 30, 2016 Share Posted January 30, 2016  I just went and found my disc, and according to the information that kam posted, then what I have is, in fact the March gig. I've had it for years, and I never knew! :doh: It has something labeled 'Alex and Neil Jam' just prior to In the End. Let me know if you still want it, troutman. I do, I am not picky.At my age I will take any of the older stuff. :codger: :rush: Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kamrahai Posted January 30, 2016 Share Posted January 30, 2016 (edited) This topic should be moved to the more appropriate Different Stages forum ;) Edited January 30, 2016 by kamrahai 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BetterCallSaul Posted February 1, 2016 Share Posted February 1, 2016  So this solves the mystery that the show was recorded on the 2112 tour, in Portland Oregon's Paramount Theater, on March 28, 1976.I hope that this clears up everything about the recording.  This mystery was solved a while back. This recording is from March 26, 1976 in Seattle. Ged refers to Seattle after Bastille Day. Check out the Power Windows site for more details. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ron2112 Posted February 2, 2016 Share Posted February 2, 2016  So this solves the mystery that the show was recorded on the 2112 tour, in Portland Oregon's Paramount Theater, on March 28, 1976.I hope that this clears up everything about the recording.     This mystery was solved a while back. This recording is from March 26, 1976 in Seattle. Ged refers to Seattle after Bastille Day. Check out the Power Windows site for more details. Uh, no.....conventional wisdom in trading circles still places this show in Oct 1976. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BetterCallSaul Posted February 2, 2016 Share Posted February 2, 2016 So this solves the mystery that the show was recorded on the 2112 tour, in Portland Oregon's Paramount Theater, on March 28, 1976.I hope that this clears up everything about the recording.     This mystery was solved a while back. This recording is from March 26, 1976 in Seattle. Ged refers to Seattle after Bastille Day. Check out the Power Windows site for more details. Uh, no.....conventional wisdom in trading circles still places this show in Oct 1976. Oh.....you again.  "Conventional wisdom", huh? Anyone with common sense and a functioning set of ears can determine the differences in their instrumentation and playing on this show vs. gigs from late '76.  It's just like your claim that Binghamton is from Apr '77. Yeah, you have that incorrect, too, btw. I won't even bother to point out the holes in that notion. You're simply too thick. You've proven w/ this Seattle nonsense that it's not worth the trouble. And aren't you the guy who swore that the circulating Hartford '81 tape is off the soundboard? Keep telling yourself all that, expert! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Eel Yddeg Posted February 2, 2016 Author Share Posted February 2, 2016 That was kind of harsh... 3 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Blue J Posted February 3, 2016 Share Posted February 3, 2016 That was kind of harsh... Indeed...especially for someone whose only two posts on TRF are in this very thread. That second one especially...quite a way to introduce yourself to the community here, buddy. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
troutman Posted February 3, 2016 Share Posted February 3, 2016 That was kind of harsh... Indeed...especially for someone whose only two posts on TRF are in this very thread. That second one especially...quite a way to introduce yourself to the community here, buddy. Let me know, When you ship the package. And a tracking number if you have one. :cheers: Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ron2112 Posted February 3, 2016 Share Posted February 3, 2016 So this solves the mystery that the show was recorded on the 2112 tour, in Portland Oregon's Paramount Theater, on March 28, 1976.I hope that this clears up everything about the recording.     This mystery was solved a while back. This recording is from March 26, 1976 in Seattle. Ged refers to Seattle after Bastille Day. Check out the Power Windows site for more details. Uh, no.....conventional wisdom in trading circles still places this show in Oct 1976. Oh.....you again.  "Conventional wisdom", huh? Anyone with common sense and a functioning set of ears can determine the differences in their instrumentation and playing on this show vs. gigs from late '76.  It's just like your claim that Binghamton is from Apr '77. Yeah, you have that incorrect, too, btw. I won't even bother to point out the holes in that notion. You're simply too thick. You've proven w/ this Seattle nonsense that it's not worth the trouble. And aren't you the guy who swore that the circulating Hartford '81 tape is off the soundboard? Keep telling yourself all that, expert!So this solves the mystery that the show was recorded on the 2112 tour, in Portland Oregon's Paramount Theater, on March 28, 1976.I hope that this clears up everything about the recording.     This mystery was solved a while back. This recording is from March 26, 1976 in Seattle. Ged refers to Seattle after Bastille Day. Check out the Power Windows site for more details. Uh, no.....conventional wisdom in trading circles still places this show in Oct 1976. Oh.....you again.  "Conventional wisdom", huh? Anyone with common sense and a functioning set of ears can determine the differences in their instrumentation and playing on this show vs. gigs from late '76.  It's just like your claim that Binghamton is from Apr '77. Yeah, you have that incorrect, too, btw. I won't even bother to point out the holes in that notion. You're simply too thick. You've proven w/ this Seattle nonsense that it's not worth the trouble. And aren't you the guy who swore that the circulating Hartford '81 tape is off the soundboard? Keep telling yourself all that, expert!  These arguments never get old..... Don't believe what I say. BUT, you can find an interview by Skip Daly with Ian Grandy on this very site, circa 2009. In that interview, Ian confirms the Binghamton date and the existence of a crew-made soundboard recording from Hartford 1981. That Hartford recording is NOT the same nice AUD source that everyone has, but a SBD from that night DOES exist, and is rumored to exist in the collections of some way-old-school traders. As for the original subject of this thread, it's an objective call, and one can find evidence that supports either date. And that's the most accurate thing anyone can say until more definitive evidence is available. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ron2112 Posted February 3, 2016 Share Posted February 3, 2016 Did the research for you. http://www.therushforum.com/index.php?/topic/50615-ian-grandy-interview-outtakes-comments-on-l/page__hl__grandy#entry1749326 The Hartford '91 SBD was dubbed "The Incredible Stunned Man" by the Rush crew. It appears the be one of the only band-recorded SBD sources that isn't widely circulated now. So yeah....regarding the Binghamton '77 date and the existence of a Hartford '81 SBD recording: Game, set, match for Ron. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now