Jump to content

Signals vs Moving Pictures


AnEggplant
 Share

  

56 members have voted

  1. 1. Which do you prefer?

    • Signals
      15
    • Moving Pictures
      41


Recommended Posts

Confession: I don't really like Signals

 

And heaven forbid I also be a Springsteen fan with an opinion. Woe is me!

 

Anyway, MP wins.

 

Overall I like it, although I find it very overrated. Most of it is eh to me with the exception of Subdivisions, Analog Kid, and New World Man.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Confession: I don't really like Signals

 

And heaven forbid I also be a Springsteen fan with an opinion. Woe is me!

 

Anyway, MP wins.

 

Overall I like it, although I find it very overrated. Most of it is eh to me with the exception of Subdivisions, Analog Kid, and New World Man.

 

I only really enjoy Losing It and Countdown. The Weapon is good, but I don't think I love it.

 

Everything else is OK, bordering mediocre.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Confession: I don't really like Signals

 

And heaven forbid I also be a Springsteen fan with an opinion. Woe is me!

 

Anyway, MP wins.

 

Overall I like it, although I find it very overrated. Most of it is eh to me with the exception of Subdivisions, Analog Kid, and New World Man.

 

I only really enjoy Losing It and Countdown. The Weapon is good, but I don't think I love it.

 

Everything else is OK, bordering mediocre.

 

I'm sure several forum members are aware of my feelings towards The Weapon...

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Confession: I don't really like Signals

 

And heaven forbid I also be a Springsteen fan with an opinion. Woe is me!

 

Anyway, MP wins.

 

Overall I like it, although I find it very overrated. Most of it is eh to me with the exception of Subdivisions, Analog Kid, and New World Man.

 

I only really enjoy Losing It and Countdown. The Weapon is good, but I don't think I love it.

 

Everything else is OK, bordering mediocre.

 

I'm sure several forum members are aware of my feelings towards The Weapon...

 

I don't mind your opinion. I don't think Xanadu is the greatest thing since the bread got hacked either.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Confession: I don't really like Signals

 

And heaven forbid I also be a Springsteen fan with an opinion. Woe is me!

 

Anyway, MP wins.

 

Overall I like it, although I find it very overrated. Most of it is eh to me with the exception of Subdivisions, Analog Kid, and New World Man.

 

I only really enjoy Losing It and Countdown. The Weapon is good, but I don't think I love it.

 

Everything else is OK, bordering mediocre.

 

I'm sure several forum members are aware of my feelings towards The Weapon...

 

I don't mind your opinion. I don't think Xanadu is the greatest thing since the bread got hacked either.

 

You mind other opinions though when music you happen to love gets crapped on?

Edited by Lorraine
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Confession: I don't really like Signals

 

And heaven forbid I also be a Springsteen fan with an opinion. Woe is me!

 

Anyway, MP wins.

 

Overall I like it, although I find it very overrated. Most of it is eh to me with the exception of Subdivisions, Analog Kid, and New World Man.

 

I only really enjoy Losing It and Countdown. The Weapon is good, but I don't think I love it.

 

Everything else is OK, bordering mediocre.

 

I'm sure several forum members are aware of my feelings towards The Weapon...

 

I don't mind your opinion. I don't think Xanadu is the greatest thing since the bread got hacked either.

 

You mind other opinions though when music you happen to love gets crapped on?

 

No I don't mean it that way, I just think it is refreshing when those who don't favour the favourites discreetly disagree. I just brought up Xanadu to say, whilst I disagree with The Weapon, I at least have a similar view on Xanadu (which I love less than most here)

 

Sorry, I didn't mean to sound harsh.

 

In hindsight I just realised we brought up your two faves.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Besides, my favourite Rush song is Chain Lightning.
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think we can almost all admit that this was the peak of Rush and these 2 albums are definitely fantastic albums, whether or not we think one is greater than the other

 

I think Signals is a good album, overall. I think some of it is great. But I don't call it a fantastic album, overall.

 

I have very fond memories associated with when it was new. And I still hear some of the songs on it as if I'm hearing them for the first time, again- even 33 years later.

 

There are two songs out of eight that I'm not totally jazzed about. But it's still a good album.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think we can almost all admit that this was the peak of Rush and these 2 albums are definitely fantastic albums, whether or not we think one is greater than the other

I think this post might belong in the unpopular opinions thread... ;)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Confession: I don't really like Signals

 

And heaven forbid I also be a Springsteen fan with an opinion. Woe is me!

 

Anyway, MP wins.

 

Overall I like it, although I find it very overrated. Most of it is eh to me with the exception of Subdivisions, Analog Kid, and New World Man.

 

I only really enjoy Losing It and Countdown. The Weapon is good, but I don't think I love it.

 

Everything else is OK, bordering mediocre.

 

I'm sure several forum members are aware of my feelings towards The Weapon...

Very... :)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Confession: I don't really like Signals

 

And heaven forbid I also be a Springsteen fan with an opinion. Woe is me!

 

Anyway, MP wins.

 

Overall I like it, although I find it very overrated. Most of it is eh to me with the exception of Subdivisions, Analog Kid, and New World Man.

 

I only really enjoy Losing It and Countdown. The Weapon is good, but I don't think I love it.

 

Everything else is OK, bordering mediocre.

 

I'm sure several forum members are aware of my feelings towards The Weapon...

Very... :)

 

;)

Edited by AnEggplant
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...