Song Battle: Where's My Thing vs Leave That Thing Alone vs Limbo

[prolix]

The 3 instrumentals from 3 consecutive albums. Which one is your favorite?

 

I go with Leave That Thing Alone.

[Bigbobby10]

I always thought Where's My Thing is very catchy, but i like Leave that Thing Alone more

[fraroc]

Wheres My Thing BY FAR

[Entre_Perpetuo]

Where's My Thing, followed by Limbo, then the well-produced elevator music.

[Digital Dad]

LTTA

 

Love the ambiance of that one. I like all three of Alone gets the nod here.

[YYZumbi]

I have always liked Limbo, its a underrated song.

[Disk98]

Leave That Thing Alone, by a wide margin.

[Digital Dad]

I have always liked Limbo, its a underrated song.

 

Underrated song. Underrated album.

[YYZumbi]

I have always liked Limbo, its a underrated song.

 

Underrated song. Underrated album.

 

I agree! It´s even underrated by the band!

[Relayer2112]

I've always liked Limbo because it sounds like it could have been the intro to a 1995 version of 2112. The only thing that detracts from it is the Monster Mash sound effects.

[EagleMoon]

LTTA first by a slim margin, then WMT, then a distant third would be Limbo.

[prolix]

LTTA first by a slim margin, then WMT, then a distant third would be Limbo.

 

I would agree.

[Blue J]

Where's My Thing, pretty handily. I do like Leave That Thing Alone, a lot. But Where's My Thing does more for me.

[laughedatbytime]

Where's "none of the above"?

[prolix]

Where's "none of the above"?

 

Just don't vote if you don't like any of the songs.

[TheAccountant]

I went with Limbo but if there had been a "None of the above" choice that would have been my pick. None of them really thrill me. Limbo is just the best of a ho-hum lot.

[maplelevy]

Surprised no one has pointed out Geddy's unreal bass work in LTTA. Again, the live version is the clincher for LTTA for me!

[Fridge]

Where's the "Who Cares" button?

[Disk98]

Where's the "Who Cares" button?

You know, you could just not vote and leave us alone.

Edited May 15, 2016 by Disk98

[Fridge]

Where's the "Who Cares" button?

You know, you could just not vote and leave us alone.

 

Where's the fun in that? ;-)

[dan.hummel99]

I love the bass line at the beginning of Limbo but I love Leave That Thing Alone, close decision

[TexMike]

LTTA >>>>>>WMT >>>>>>>>>>>Limbo

[Super25Smasher]

Where's My Thing, pretty handily. I do like Leave That Thing Alone, a lot. But Where's My Thing does more for me.

This.

[Verena]

I simply can't battle these songs. I love all the three. :rush:

[LakesideShark]

This one was kinda hard for me to choose. I went with "Limbo" but "Leave That Thing Alone" is right behind it.

Geddy's bass is amazing on "Leave That Thing Alone", though. And I really liked the live version on the TIme Machine DVD.

But, I still go with "Limbo". There's just something about it I really really love.