290 replies to this topic

[Permanent-Rush]

What the f**k people! I understand Neil is not an original member, but no one is better on drums than him. That also means no one can replace him. would not be without Neil.

[Phantom]

Yes, Rush would not be Rush without Neil. Ged and Al seem interested in writing and recording and maybe even touring. I for one would have interest in hearing new material written by Ged and Al. If they record it with Neil on drums, it's Rush. In my opinion, If they record it with someone else on drums, they should call it something other than Rush. Either way, I'd be into checking it out.  Side note.... if it's not Neil, PLEASE let it be Gavin Harrison.

[GabesCavesOfIce]

Although I agree its best the Rush name be retired along with Neil, however Geddy and Alex have certainly earned the right to continue with the name if THEY chose.

[GabesCavesOfIce]

Surrender74, on 17 June 2016 - 04:03 PM, said:

What the f**k people! I understand Neil is not an original member, but no one is better on drums than him. That also means no one can replace him. would not be without Neil.

Actually is a fine album and does not include one extraordinary note from Neil. That was Rush delivered by Rush without actually being Rush.

[Phantom]

Gabrielgil513, on 17 June 2016 - 08:21 PM, said:

Although I agree its best the Rush name be retired along with Neil, however Geddy and Alex have certainly earned the right to continue with the name if THEY chose.

That's a great point. They have earned that right. I recall Ged's interview in Beyond the Lighted Stage where he said there is no replacing anyone in this band. It's just not possible. I think that speaks volumes, and I interpret that to mean if they do record with someone else, Ged wouldn't want to call it Rush

[GabesCavesOfIce]

Yes, its Geds call, with Alex. Not us.

[Xanadoood]

None of them would ever be replaced. It just won't happen.

I just heard an interview on the local radio with Peter Wolf, of J Geils..he revealed that The Police approached him as a Sting replacement..WTF.. I just can't see Geddy and Alex ever doing that

[GabesCavesOfIce]

I agree its very unlikely.

I like the idea of G n A recording a few songs, take them on the road with a female singer to see how the old material could sound with a fresh voice singing with Ged. Maybe, maybe not. But experimentation is what made them great back in the day.

They could also say lets do Lee Lifeson perform an evening of Rush music, and then think, why are addimg all these other words to our name? Yes, distinction that Rush can only be those three. Too bad Neil wanted to hurry to retirement, so much so he stunned Ged.

[Jaminbenb]

Xanadoood, on 18 June 2016 - 09:48 AM, said:

None of them would ever be replaced. It just won't happen.

I just heard an interview on the local radio with Peter Wolf, of J Geils..he revealed that The Police approached him as a Sting replacement..WTF.. I just can't see Geddy and Alex ever doing that

No.... I can't see it either... I CAN honestly see Alex and Geddy doing something at some point, and I honestly think that it will NOT be called "Rush", but they will work together....

[Jaminbenb]

Gabrielgil513, on 19 June 2016 - 01:58 PM, said:

Too bad Neil wanted to hurry to retirement, so much so he stunned Ged.

You know, I've given that a LOT of thought, and when I think of it, I always think of the Yes show I saw last summer and how badly Alan White played...he definitely affected the show, and it was disheartening to see him like that.  When I went to see them a week ago, Alan wasn't playing due to some injury/surgery that he's had, and they had a replacement.  It was a much better show...  (granted...Yes has had a revolving door of characters over the years, so it's not like it's three guys and three guys alone, that make up the band)

Saying that, if you went to a show, and Neil wasn't playing up to his usual standard, wouldn't you be extremely upset?  I think it's good that he knew enough to get out of it while he was still on top, and not try to come out and fake his way through a performance.....

[Eth2345131]

Digital Dad, on 21 November 2015 - 10:35 PM, said:

Mieko8, on 21 November 2015 - 10:30 PM, said:

Weren't they called Rush long before they ever met Neil? ������������

Yes and they were a two bit bar band from Toronto who couldn't even score a record deal.

"We played in coffee shops for chips and gravy" i feel that sums it all up

[GabesCavesOfIce]

Jaminbenb, on 01 August 2016 - 07:37 AM, said:

Gabrielgil513, on 19 June 2016 - 01:58 PM, said:

Too bad Neil wanted to hurry to retirement, so much so he stunned Ged.

You know, I've given that a LOT of thought, and when I think of it, I always think of the Yes show I saw last summer and how badly Alan White played...he definitely affected the show, and it was disheartening to see him like that.  When I went to see them a week ago, Alan wasn't playing due to some injury/surgery that he's had, and they had a replacement.  It was a much better show...  (granted...Yes has had a revolving door of characters over the years, so it's not like it's three guys and three guys alone, that make up the band)

Saying that, if you went to a show, and Neil wasn't playing up to his usual standard, wouldn't you be extremely upset?  I think it's good that he knew enough to get out of it while he was still on top, and not try to come out and fake his way through a performance.....

I fully agree, but believe the end was hurried. The only tour in decades without a second leg, and that happens to be their last tour ever?

He was more than capable of doing 30 more this year, based on his 2015 performances, giving the international audience a chance to see them one last time, and a handful of final shows in US/Canada.

[Permanent-Rush]

Jaminbenb, on 01 August 2016 - 07:37 AM, said:

Gabrielgil513, on 19 June 2016 - 01:58 PM, said:

Too bad Neil wanted to hurry to retirement, so much so he stunned Ged.

Saying that, if you went to a show, and Neil wasn't playing up to his usual standard, wouldn't you be extremely upset?

I would not be upset if he was not playing up to his usual standerd. I would be upset if he was not playing with Geddy and Alex.

Edited by Surrender74, 01 August 2016 - 09:02 PM.

[Jaminbenb]

Gabrielgil513, on 01 August 2016 - 07:02 PM, said:

Jaminbenb, on 01 August 2016 - 07:37 AM, said:

Gabrielgil513, on 19 June 2016 - 01:58 PM, said:

Too bad Neil wanted to hurry to retirement, so much so he stunned Ged.

You know, I've given that a LOT of thought, and when I think of it, I always think of the Yes show I saw last summer and how badly Alan White played...he definitely affected the show, and it was disheartening to see him like that.  When I went to see them a week ago, Alan wasn't playing due to some injury/surgery that he's had, and they had a replacement.  It was a much better show...  (granted...Yes has had a revolving door of characters over the years, so it's not like it's three guys and three guys alone, that make up the band)

Saying that, if you went to a show, and Neil wasn't playing up to his usual standard, wouldn't you be extremely upset?  I think it's good that he knew enough to get out of it while he was still on top, and not try to come out and fake his way through a performance.....

I fully agree, but believe the end was hurried. The only tour in decades without a second leg, and that happens to be their last tour ever?

He was more than capable of doing 30 more this year, based on his 2015 performances, giving the international audience a chance to see them one last time, and a handful of final shows in US/Canada.

Yeah, THAT'S probably what actually upset me more than anything else. I figured that they'd have at least another leg of the tour, then have one massive blow out show in Pittsburgh or somewhere with some sort of significance...

Surrender74, on 01 August 2016 - 09:02 PM, said:

Jaminbenb, on 01 August 2016 - 07:37 AM, said:

Gabrielgil513, on 19 June 2016 - 01:58 PM, said:

Too bad Neil wanted to hurry to retirement, so much so he stunned Ged.

Saying that, if you went to a show, and Neil wasn't playing up to his usual standard, wouldn't you be extremely upset?

I would not be upset if he was not playing up to his usual standerd. I would be upset if he was not playing with Geddy and Alex.

Sorry....I'd be sick if I saw him playing the way I saw Alan White at that Yes show....and Alan doesn't play HALF as hard as Neil ever did!

[New_World_Man]

Apparently the new drummer for Rush will be Meg White from the White Stripes.

https://www.ncscoope...shs-neil-peart/

[losingit2k]

I don t think they should ever tour as without Neil! However Geddy and Alex sure deserve to tour on their own. They both have Solo Albums and a slough of great unplayed RUSH songs to choose from, They can bring along a great drummer like Mike Portnoy to cover the Epic RUSH songs. They can even record a joint Album called L.L.P.

(Lee, Lifeson & Portnoy Tour) would be cool! anything to hear Geddy and Alex at it again!!!

[Pound of Obscure]

Ancient Ways, on 21 November 2015 - 10:19 PM, said:

No.  Don't forget that they need a lyricist as well.  Unless you want geddy to return to writing lyrics telling women what time it is and that he fancies some sex.

I'd take that over a tortoise from Gallapagos, or I like that show where they solve all the murders. His lyrics "mostly" suck since about 1985.

[Permanent-Rush]

No one will ever be the replacement and he will never be replaced, Rush is not a band anymore, they called it quits so that's that.

[Fridge]

Permanent-Rush, on 11 June 2018 - 03:41 PM, said:

No one will ever be the replacement and he will never be replaced, Rush is not a band anymore, they called it quits so that's that.

I love it when people speak with absolute certainty about something they have no control over whatsoever.

[grasbo]

L.L.P?Portney,Carl Palmer or if he was alive Cozy Powell.Handy having a surname starting with P.