You Choose III

[JohnRogers]

Easy this time. PeW is my favorite album and there are too many synth era songs I enjoy to give up.

[laughedatbytime]

I didn't even think about Feedback as part of the group. I guess that means it carries 0 weight for me. Not that I think it's bad, but I just don't get the urge to listen to it.

Hell, it kicks S&A and Presto all to hell.

[rocket ignites]

Well, I love S&A and Presto...I actually forgot Feedback even exists.

[Digital Dad]

Im cool with anyone who loves SnA. Its really a wonderful album. Edited May 6, 2015 by Digital Dad

[Disk98]

I'd take Permanent Waves and Moving Pictures by themselves over the first six albums, even if they include Xanadu.

[Narps]

15 to 14. Just about what I expected. Lot's of lovers of the great 70's...

[Verena]

It was difficult to choose, but I voted from Permanent Waves till Clockwork Angels.

[gypsy muse]

My incentive is getting rid of CA

 

I want to wipe it from existance.

 

Mick

[iamtoughtobeat]

Well Hemispheres and AFTK are 2 of my top 4 albums still, and I prefer their first 4 albums over the last 10 they have released....

[Entre_Perpetuo]

Incredibly difficult, but I'd miss 2112 and AFTK way too much to justify getting rid of them. I'd miss a lot of the later stuff a heap too, but never hearing those two album again...just can't do it.

[AnEggplant]

Hemispheres and Caress of Steel are brilliant, but Clockwork Angels is my favorite album and between Vapor Trails, Snakes and Arrows, Counterparts, Test for Echo, and of course Permanent Waves, Moving Pictures and Grace, I had to choose group 2.

[Fridge]

very nasty choice this, but you have to way up killer to filler ratios

 

Rush - Hemispheres is 6 killer, zero filler

 

permanent waves- CA is 5 killer, 8 filler

 

so it has to be the first option, but never hearing pew -pw again would be dire.