Who Will Have The Better Career?

[presto123]

So now that we know that Indy is taking Luck and Washington is taking RG3 who will have the better career when it's all said and done? Do you see either one as a bust?

[laughedatbytime]

Luck will be on a bad team to start with, and I don't know how good their new GM will be at building a good team, but if he's fairly competent there's a good chance that in a couple of years they'll be decent and he willl be above average to great.

 

The dysfunction in Washington will, I believe, hamper RG III throughout his career. I think in a better situation he would succeed, I believe he's an outstanding prospect, but the ownershi situation puts his probability for success at severe risk.

[apetersvt]

QUOTE (laughedatbytime @ Apr 20 2012, 04:44 AM)

Luck will be on a bad team to start with, and I don't know how good their new GM will be at building a good team, but if he's fairly competent there's a good chance that in a couple of years they'll be decent and he willl be above average to great. The dysfunction in Washington will, I believe, hamper RG III throughout his career. I think in a better situation he would succeed, I believe he's an outstanding prospect, but the ownershi situation puts his probability for success at severe risk.

 

I think the last time the Redskins had a 'good' quarterback, RG3 was in diapers. Organization/ownership will ruin his potential.

[treeduck]

I did a poll like this the other week...

 

http://www.therushforum.com/index.php?show...c=72638&hl=luck

[Bastille Dave]

QUOTE (apetersvt @ Apr 20 2012, 01:14 PM)

QUOTE (laughedatbytime @ Apr 20 2012, 04:44 AM) Luck will be on a bad team to start with, and I don't know how good their new GM will be at building a good team, but if he's fairly competent there's a good chance that in a couple of years they'll be decent and he willl be above average to great. The dysfunction in Washington will, I believe, hamper RG III throughout his career.    I think in a better situation he would succeed, I believe he's an outstanding prospect, but the ownershi situation puts his probability for success at severe risk.   I think the last time the Redskins had a 'good' quarterback, RG3 was in diapers. Organization/ownership will ruin his potential. I agree on both.   I hate the Redskins so I hope RG3 is a bust, at least early on. Nothing against the guy, I hope he leaves in 4 years or so and goes to, I don't know, maybe Miami or some team and does well.

[Weakly Criminal]

I'm not a Baylor fan, I'm an Aggie. (your pity if appreciated) But I love me some RGIII and the fact that he went to DC is an absolute nut crusher. He deserves much better and minnny me in DC deserves much worse.

 

I think that RG has more potential, but Luck is the safer bet.

[Rick N. Backer]

:bump:

[LedRush]

Luck will be on a bad team to start with, and I don't know how good their new GM will be at building a good team, but if he's fairly competent there's a good chance that in a couple of years they'll be decent and he willl be above average to great.

 

The dysfunction in Washington will, I believe, hamper RG III throughout his career. I think in a better situation he would succeed, I believe he's an outstanding prospect, but the ownershi situation puts his probability for success at severe risk.

 

Holy shit that was prophetic!

[liquidcrystalcompass]

Luck will be on a bad team to start with, and I don't know how good their new GM will be at building a good team, but if he's fairly competent there's a good chance that in a couple of years they'll be decent and he willl be above average to great.

 

The dysfunction in Washington will, I believe, hamper RG III throughout his career. I think in a better situation he would succeed, I believe he's an outstanding prospect, but the ownershi situation puts his probability for success at severe risk.

 

Holy shit that was prophetic!

But he's in a better situation. He's in Cleveland for God's sake!!

[JohnRogers]

I laughed at this poll question then realized it's from 2012.