Pink Floyd: Albums Elimination (Round 2)

[_hi_water._]

The Final Cut got 8 'eliminate' votes and 3 'immune' votes. That counts as 5 'eliminate' votes. A few other albums were close to this.

The Endless River got a whopping number of 21 'eliminate' votes and 0 'immune' votes! So now we know that many people will be voting on this.

 

15. The Endless River (2014)

14. The Final Cut (1983)

[Stormtron]

The appeal of Ummagumma and AHM is completely lost on me. Easy picks for me right now.

[Lurkst]

The live half of Ummagumma is peak Floyd IMO. The studio half on the other hand should've been torn off and left in the record store.

 

[custom55]

The appeal of Ummagumma and AHM is completely lost on me. Easy picks for me right now.

 

I listen to AHM while driving through snow-covered farmlands in VT. Perfect

[Timbale]

Wow, I can't believe Final Cut is gone before some of the others! I am not often in the mood for it - it's quite oppressive - but it is really good.

 

I picked More and UmmaGumma - albums that never really grabbed me.

[pjbear05]

The live half of Ummagumma is peak Floyd IMO. The studio half on the other hand should've been torn off and left in the record store.

Yup,^this. Which is why it got a "tank" vote from me.

[goose]

I can't see anything pre-Meddle surviving much further.

[Rick N. Backer]

I can't see anything pre-Meddle surviving much further.

 

You misspelled Dark Side of the Moon.

[The Analog Cub]

More and Ummagumma gotta go next. After those two:

 

1. WYWH

2. Animals

3. DSOTM

4. The Wall

5. The Division Bell

6. Meddle

7. AMLOR

8. AHM

9. Obscured By Clouds

10. ASFOS

11. Piper

[goose]

I can't see anything pre-Meddle surviving much further.

 

You misspelled Dark Side of the Moon.

I think Meddle might hold its own against the late stuff.

[zepphead]

More & Ummagumma get the thumbs down from me.