Clash of two songs from 1976: Aerosmith vs. Zeppelin!

[Texas King]

Take your pick.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ze6h1t7Z734

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hJeGrLJ6dOI

[Lorraine]

That is very courteous of you, Tex, to always provide videos of the songs.

[The Cat 3]

Aeroburgers all the way!

[treeduck]

I think Zeppelin in this case.

[canadianice]

Zep.

[J2112YYZ]

Aerosmith easily for me. One of my favorite tunes by them. The fact that they actually wrote the song and didn't rip someone else off and pass it off as their own like Zeppelin did here also gives them the edge.

[1-0-0-1-0-0-1]

Went with Aerosmith here. The main riff in the Zep tune is way too repetitive (I have the same complaint about "Black Dog"). Besides, the Aerosmith tune is one of my favorites -- it has attitude for days and the solos are really good.

[Rick N. Backer]

Rocks blows Presence away. But Nobody's Fault But Mine is the best song on Presence. It gets the nod from me.

[J2112YYZ]

Rocks blows Presence away. But Nobody's Fault But Mine is the best song on Presence. It gets the nod from me.

 

Do you usually skip track one on Presence?

[1-0-0-1-0-0-1]

Rocks blows Presence away. But Nobody's Fault But Mine is the best song on Presence. It gets the nod from me.

 

Do you usually skip track one on Presence?

 

Yeah, exactly. Achilles would like a word with you, Rick.

[Derek19]

With, and for this one, I've liked, and felt had to vote "Led Zeppelin".

[Rick N. Backer]

Rocks blows Presence away. But Nobody's Fault But Mine is the best song on Presence. It gets the nod from me.

 

Do you usually skip track one on Presence?

 

I don't listen to Presence too often at all. But Achilles is one of those songs that I find to be overrated tbh.

[Lorraine]

Rocks blows Presence away. But Nobody's Fault But Mine is the best song on Presence. It gets the nod from me.

 

Do you usually skip track one on Presence?

 

I don't listen to Presence too often at all. But Achilles is one of those songs that I find to be overrated tbh.

 

That's sad.

Edited February 21, 2019 by Lorraine

[goose]

Both songs have a similar vibe to them, but Bonzo's playing on the Zep track is just too good, and Plant's vocals are amazing.

 

Zep for the win.

[HemiBeers]

Not that fond of either track because of their faults, but that's nobody's fault.

 

Went with Aerosmith for being less faulty.

[HemiBeers]

Rocks blows Presence away. But Nobody's Fault But Mine is the best song on Presence. It gets the nod from me.

 

Do you usually skip track one on Presence?

 

Yeah, exactly. Achilles would like a word with you, Rick.

I put Achilles pretty close on the Epicness list with LaVilla.

 

Oh snap I think we have our next poll question.

Edited February 22, 2019 by HemiBeers

[treeduck]

Ironically Aerosmith sound like Zeppelin on Nobody's Fault.

[Lorraine]

Rocks blows Presence away. But Nobody's Fault But Mine is the best song on Presence. It gets the nod from me.

 

Do you usually skip track one on Presence?

 

Yeah, exactly. Achilles would like a word with you, Rick.

I put Achilles pretty close on the Epicness list with LaVilla.

 

Oh snap I think we have our next poll question.

That would be a good poll. Why don't you do the thread?

[HemiBeers]

Rocks blows Presence away. But Nobody's Fault But Mine is the best song on Presence. It gets the nod from me.

 

Do you usually skip track one on Presence?

 

Yeah, exactly. Achilles would like a word with you, Rick.

I put Achilles pretty close on the Epicness list with LaVilla.

 

Oh snap I think we have our next poll question.

That would be a good poll. Why don't you do the thread?

I'm just the idea guy around here. That would require heavy lifting. :codger:

 

Actually might be good to include up to 5 tracks in the battle of epicness.

[custom55]

Love both but went with the Toxic Twins. Rocks>Presence

[Lorraine]

Rocks blows Presence away. But Nobody's Fault But Mine is the best song on Presence. It gets the nod from me.

 

Do you usually skip track one on Presence?

 

Yeah, exactly. Achilles would like a word with you, Rick.

I put Achilles pretty close on the Epicness list with LaVilla.

 

Oh snap I think we have our next poll question.

That would be a good poll. Why don't you do the thread?

I'm just the idea guy around here. That would require heavy lifting. :codger:

 

Actually might be good to include up to 5 tracks in the battle of epicness.

 

I hope one of our pollsters sees this and does it.

Edited February 22, 2019 by Lorraine

[1-0-0-1-0-0-1]

Love both but went with the Toxic Twins. Rocks>Presence

 

Because of this thread I listened to all of Rocks today. That album holds up really well. Brad Whitford's influence is all over it, and that's a good thing.

[pjbear05]

Yep. It's Zep.

[Lorraine]

Rocks blows Presence away. But Nobody's Fault But Mine is the best song on Presence. It gets the nod from me.

 

Do you usually skip track one on Presence?

 

Yeah, exactly. Achilles would like a word with you, Rick.

I put Achilles pretty close on the Epicness list with LaVilla.

 

Oh snap I think we have our next poll question.

That would be a good poll. Why don't you do the thread?

I'm just the idea guy around here. That would require heavy lifting. :codger:

 

Actually might be good to include up to 5 tracks in the battle of epicness.

 

I hope one of our pollsters sees this and does it.

 

I sent Tex a message.

[Syrinx]

Aerosmith! Rocks is one of the best lp's of all time!