Jump to content

Based on the interview... (WARNING: POSSIBLE PHILOSOPHICAL DEBATES!)


oghond2112
 Share

Recommended Posts

Anyways... if you read the Four-Temperament Ensemble thing...

 

Basically, from what I have seen in interviews, Alex is sanguine, Neil is melancholic, and Geddy, as has already been established, is phlegmatic. There are no choleric members (unless you count John Rutsey, but I don't know what he was like...).

 

Is anyone else here in agreement?

I'm more into the Myers-Briggs approach to personality analysis. We've had several discussions about Neil being an INTJ, and the fact that here on the Forum there are an inordinate number of INTJs (typically 1% of the population).

 

Good thread!

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyways... if you read the Four-Temperament Ensemble thing...

 

Basically, from what I have seen in interviews, Alex is sanguine, Neil is melancholic, and Geddy, as has already been established, is phlegmatic. There are no choleric members (unless you count John Rutsey, but I don't know what he was like...).

 

Is anyone else here in agreement?

I'm more into the Myers-Briggs approach to personality analysis. We've had several discussions about Neil being an INTJ, and the fact that here on the Forum there are an inordinate number of INTJs (typically 1% of the population).

 

Good thread!

 

Thanks!

 

A few questions:

 

1: What's Myers-Briggs?

2: What's an INTJ?

3: If Neil is an INTJ, what are Alex and Geddy?

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyways... if you read the Four-Temperament Ensemble thing...

 

Basically, from what I have seen in interviews, Alex is sanguine, Neil is melancholic, and Geddy, as has already been established, is phlegmatic. There are no choleric members (unless you count John Rutsey, but I don't know what he was like...).

 

Is anyone else here in agreement?

I'm more into the Myers-Briggs approach to personality analysis. We've had several discussions about Neil being an INTJ, and the fact that here on the Forum there are an inordinate number of INTJs (typically 1% of the population).

 

Good thread!

 

Thanks!

 

A few questions:

 

1: What's Myers-Briggs?

2: What's an INTJ?

3: If Neil is an INTJ, what are Alex and Geddy?

 

I was wondering the same thing but was too lazy to ask!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyways... if you read the Four-Temperament Ensemble thing...

 

Basically, from what I have seen in interviews, Alex is sanguine, Neil is melancholic, and Geddy, as has already been established, is phlegmatic. There are no choleric members (unless you count John Rutsey, but I don't know what he was like...).

 

Is anyone else here in agreement?

I'm more into the Myers-Briggs approach to personality analysis. We've had several discussions about Neil being an INTJ, and the fact that here on the Forum there are an inordinate number of INTJs (typically 1% of the population).

 

Good thread!

 

Thanks!

 

A few questions:

 

1: What's Myers-Briggs?

2: What's an INTJ?

3: If Neil is an INTJ, what are Alex and Geddy?

 

I was wondering the same thing but was too lazy to ask!

There's this really cool website called Google... ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyways... if you read the Four-Temperament Ensemble thing...

 

Basically, from what I have seen in interviews, Alex is sanguine, Neil is melancholic, and Geddy, as has already been established, is phlegmatic. There are no choleric members (unless you count John Rutsey, but I don't know what he was like...).

 

Is anyone else here in agreement?

I'm more into the Myers-Briggs approach to personality analysis. We've had several discussions about Neil being an INTJ, and the fact that here on the Forum there are an inordinate number of INTJs (typically 1% of the population).

 

Good thread!

 

Thanks!

 

A few questions:

 

1: What's Myers-Briggs?

2: What's an INTJ?

3: If Neil is an INTJ, what are Alex and Geddy?

 

I was wondering the same thing but was too lazy to ask!

There's this really cool website called Google... ;)

 

Cool?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyways... if you read the Four-Temperament Ensemble thing...

 

Basically, from what I have seen in interviews, Alex is sanguine, Neil is melancholic, and Geddy, as has already been established, is phlegmatic. There are no choleric members (unless you count John Rutsey, but I don't know what he was like...).

 

Is anyone else here in agreement?

I'm more into the Myers-Briggs approach to personality analysis. We've had several discussions about Neil being an INTJ, and the fact that here on the Forum there are an inordinate number of INTJs (typically 1% of the population).

 

Good thread!

 

Thanks!

 

A few questions:

 

1: What's Myers-Briggs?

2: What's an INTJ?

3: If Neil is an INTJ, what are Alex and Geddy?

 

I was wondering the same thing but was too lazy to ask!

There's this really cool website called Google... ;)

 

Cool?

Hot?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyways... if you read the Four-Temperament Ensemble thing...

 

Basically, from what I have seen in interviews, Alex is sanguine, Neil is melancholic, and Geddy, as has already been established, is phlegmatic. There are no choleric members (unless you count John Rutsey, but I don't know what he was like...).

 

Is anyone else here in agreement?

I'm more into the Myers-Briggs approach to personality analysis. We've had several discussions about Neil being an INTJ, and the fact that here on the Forum there are an inordinate number of INTJs (typically 1% of the population).

 

Good thread!

 

Thanks!

 

A few questions:

 

1: What's Myers-Briggs?

2: What's an INTJ?

3: If Neil is an INTJ, what are Alex and Geddy?

 

I was wondering the same thing but was too lazy to ask!

There's this really cool website called Google... ;)

 

Cool?

Tony R has had his say in the thread everyone, now we can all rest easy in our beds again after days of anxious waiting, staring at the ceiling night after night waiting for his verdict... :hi:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyways... if you read the Four-Temperament Ensemble thing...

 

Basically, from what I have seen in interviews, Alex is sanguine, Neil is melancholic, and Geddy, as has already been established, is phlegmatic. There are no choleric members (unless you count John Rutsey, but I don't know what he was like...).

 

Is anyone else here in agreement?

I'm more into the Myers-Briggs approach to personality analysis. We've had several discussions about Neil being an INTJ, and the fact that here on the Forum there are an inordinate number of INTJs (typically 1% of the population).

 

Good thread!

 

Thanks!

 

A few questions:

 

1: What's Myers-Briggs?

2: What's an INTJ?

3: If Neil is an INTJ, what are Alex and Geddy?

 

I was wondering the same thing but was too lazy to ask!

There's this really cool website called Google... ;)

 

Cool?

Tony R has had his say in the thread everyone, now we can all rest easy in our beds again after days of anxious waiting, staring at the ceiling night after night waiting for his verdict... :hi:

You leave Tony R alone you bully. :D-13:

Edited by Lorraine
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyways... if you read the Four-Temperament Ensemble thing...

 

Basically, from what I have seen in interviews, Alex is sanguine, Neil is melancholic, and Geddy, as has already been established, is phlegmatic. There are no choleric members (unless you count John Rutsey, but I don't know what he was like...).

 

Is anyone else here in agreement?

I'm more into the Myers-Briggs approach to personality analysis. We've had several discussions about Neil being an INTJ, and the fact that here on the Forum there are an inordinate number of INTJs (typically 1% of the population).

 

Good thread!

 

Thanks!

 

A few questions:

 

1: What's Myers-Briggs?

2: What's an INTJ?

3: If Neil is an INTJ, what are Alex and Geddy?

 

I was wondering the same thing but was too lazy to ask!

There's this really cool website called Google... ;)

 

Cool?

Tony R has had his say in the thread everyone, now we can all rest easy in our beds again after days of anxious waiting, staring at the ceiling night after night waiting for his verdict... :hi:

You leave Tony R alone you bully. :D-13:

It's only bullying if you pick on someone who you know is scared to fight back. Like you...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In the Dan Rather interview with Geddy Lee, he described each member's interaction with the fans, and effectively, their personalities: Neil is perpetually shy and introverted, and VERY uncomfortable around fans, Alex is gregarious, talkative, and goofy, and Geddy himself is right smack-dab in the middle: very polite, friendly, and humble, yet somewhat reserved. Not as gregarious as Alex, but not as shy as Neil.

 

Meaning, effectively, that they can be considered the new Freudian trio (seen here: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/FreudianTrio -though that may be a bit of a stretch). Specifically:

 

Id: Alex

Superego: Neil

Ego: Geddy

 

If not that, then it is ALMOST CERTAIN that they represent 3/4 of a four-temperament ensemble (seen here: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/FourTemperamentEnsemble). Hint: there are no choleric members of RUSH. Hint: one's sanguine, one's melancholic, one's phlegmatic. Hint: it shouldn't take long to figure out who's who based on reading the descriptions.

 

Who else here agrees?

 

*NOTE: If I offend anyone with this, I sincerely apologize in advance. This thread was not meant to be offensive.*

 

Delete this thread you racist bigot. Don't you know that Geddy Lee is a Nazi Commie????

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyways... if you read the Four-Temperament Ensemble thing...

 

Basically, from what I have seen in interviews, Alex is sanguine, Neil is melancholic, and Geddy, as has already been established, is phlegmatic. There are no choleric members (unless you count John Rutsey, but I don't know what he was like...).

 

Is anyone else here in agreement?

I'm more into the Myers-Briggs approach to personality analysis. We've had several discussions about Neil being an INTJ, and the fact that here on the Forum there are an inordinate number of INTJs (typically 1% of the population).

 

Good thread!

 

Thanks!

 

A few questions:

 

1: What's Myers-Briggs?

2: What's an INTJ?

3: If Neil is an INTJ, what are Alex and Geddy?

 

I was wondering the same thing but was too lazy to ask!

There's this really cool website called Google... ;)

 

Cool?

Tony R has had his say in the thread everyone, now we can all rest easy in our beds again after days of anxious waiting, staring at the ceiling night after night waiting for his verdict... :hi:

You leave Tony R alone you bully. :D-13:

It's only bullying if you pick on someone who you know is scared to fight back. Like you...

Go climb a tree you jerk.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jokes aside, they're just regular dudes. Overanalyzing them as Gods is dumb. They have families, regular lives besides being in a band. We have threads regarding them as the holy Trinity every week and yeah, Rush is good, but come on theyre not superhumans, they're Canadian
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyways... if you read the Four-Temperament Ensemble thing...

 

Basically, from what I have seen in interviews, Alex is sanguine, Neil is melancholic, and Geddy, as has already been established, is phlegmatic. There are no choleric members (unless you count John Rutsey, but I don't know what he was like...).

 

Is anyone else here in agreement?

I'm more into the Myers-Briggs approach to personality analysis. We've had several discussions about Neil being an INTJ, and the fact that here on the Forum there are an inordinate number of INTJs (typically 1% of the population).

 

Good thread!

 

Thanks!

 

A few questions:

 

1: What's Myers-Briggs?

2: What's an INTJ?

3: If Neil is an INTJ, what are Alex and Geddy?

 

I was wondering the same thing but was too lazy to ask!

There's this really cool website called Google... ;)

 

Cool?

Tony R has had his say in the thread everyone, now we can all rest easy in our beds again after days of anxious waiting, staring at the ceiling night after night waiting for his verdict... :hi:

You leave Tony R alone you bully. :D-13:

It's only bullying if you pick on someone who you know is scared to fight back. Like you...

Go climb a tree you jerk.

Well you see I wasn't talking to you, you butted in, so all you have to do is not butt in and all will be well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyways... if you read the Four-Temperament Ensemble thing...

 

Basically, from what I have seen in interviews, Alex is sanguine, Neil is melancholic, and Geddy, as has already been established, is phlegmatic. There are no choleric members (unless you count John Rutsey, but I don't know what he was like...).

 

Is anyone else here in agreement?

I'm more into the Myers-Briggs approach to personality analysis. We've had several discussions about Neil being an INTJ, and the fact that here on the Forum there are an inordinate number of INTJs (typically 1% of the population).

 

Good thread!

 

Thanks!

 

A few questions:

 

1: What's Myers-Briggs?

2: What's an INTJ?

3: If Neil is an INTJ, what are Alex and Geddy?

 

I was wondering the same thing but was too lazy to ask!

There's this really cool website called Google... ;)

 

Cool?

Tony R has had his say in the thread everyone, now we can all rest easy in our beds again after days of anxious waiting, staring at the ceiling night after night waiting for his verdict... :hi:

You leave Tony R alone you bully. :D-13:

It's only bullying if you pick on someone who you know is scared to fight back. Like you...

Go climb a tree you jerk.

Well you see I wasn't talking to you, you butted in, so all you have to do is not butt in and all will be well.

This is a forum and this is a thread. This isn't your private domain. I'll do what I damn well please here bucko.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jokes aside, they're just regular dudes. Overanalyzing them as Gods is dumb. They have families, regular lives besides being in a band. We have threads regarding them as the holy Trinity every week and yeah, Rush is good, but come on theyre not superhumans, they're Canadian

 

Canadians can't be superheroes, eh? :LOL: I think their super power is being polite, right? :D

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyways... if you read the Four-Temperament Ensemble thing...

 

Basically, from what I have seen in interviews, Alex is sanguine, Neil is melancholic, and Geddy, as has already been established, is phlegmatic. There are no choleric members (unless you count John Rutsey, but I don't know what he was like...).

 

Is anyone else here in agreement?

I'm more into the Myers-Briggs approach to personality analysis. We've had several discussions about Neil being an INTJ, and the fact that here on the Forum there are an inordinate number of INTJs (typically 1% of the population).

 

Good thread!

 

Thanks!

 

A few questions:

 

1: What's Myers-Briggs?

2: What's an INTJ?

3: If Neil is an INTJ, what are Alex and Geddy?

 

I was wondering the same thing but was too lazy to ask!

There's this really cool website called Google... ;)

 

Cool?

Tony R has had his say in the thread everyone, now we can all rest easy in our beds again after days of anxious waiting, staring at the ceiling night after night waiting for his verdict... :hi:

You leave Tony R alone you bully. :D-13:

It's only bullying if you pick on someone who you know is scared to fight back. Like you...

Go climb a tree you jerk.

Well you see I wasn't talking to you, you butted in, so all you have to do is not butt in and all will be well.

This is a forum and this is a thread. This isn't your private domain. I'll do what I damn well please here bucko.

Well you say what you want, but I'm saying what I want regardless and don't expect anything else because you ain't going to get it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyways... if you read the Four-Temperament Ensemble thing...

 

Basically, from what I have seen in interviews, Alex is sanguine, Neil is melancholic, and Geddy, as has already been established, is phlegmatic. There are no choleric members (unless you count John Rutsey, but I don't know what he was like...).

 

Is anyone else here in agreement?

I'm more into the Myers-Briggs approach to personality analysis. We've had several discussions about Neil being an INTJ, and the fact that here on the Forum there are an inordinate number of INTJs (typically 1% of the population).

 

Good thread!

 

Thanks!

 

A few questions:

 

1: What's Myers-Briggs?

2: What's an INTJ?

3: If Neil is an INTJ, what are Alex and Geddy?

 

I was wondering the same thing but was too lazy to ask!

There's this really cool website called Google... ;)

 

Cool?

Tony R has had his say in the thread everyone, now we can all rest easy in our beds again after days of anxious waiting, staring at the ceiling night after night waiting for his verdict... :hi:

You leave Tony R alone you bully. :D-13:

It's only bullying if you pick on someone who you know is scared to fight back. Like you...

Go climb a tree you jerk.

Well you see I wasn't talking to you, you butted in, so all you have to do is not butt in and all will be well.

This is a forum and this is a thread. This isn't your private domain. I'll do what I damn well please here bucko.

Well you say what you want, but I'm saying what I want regardless and don't expect anything else because you ain't going to get it.

Okie dokie

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jokes aside, they're just regular dudes. Overanalyzing them as Gods is dumb. They have families, regular lives besides being in a band. We have threads regarding them as the holy Trinity every week and yeah, Rush is good, but come on theyre not superhumans, they're Canadian

 

Canadians can't be superheroes, eh? :LOL: I think their super power is being polite, right? :D

 

Wolverine-Angry.jpg

Wrong, bitch!

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyways... if you read the Four-Temperament Ensemble thing...

 

Basically, from what I have seen in interviews, Alex is sanguine, Neil is melancholic, and Geddy, as has already been established, is phlegmatic. There are no choleric members (unless you count John Rutsey, but I don't know what he was like...).

 

Is anyone else here in agreement?

I'm more into the Myers-Briggs approach to personality analysis. We've had several discussions about Neil being an INTJ, and the fact that here on the Forum there are an inordinate number of INTJs (typically 1% of the population).

 

Good thread!

 

Thanks!

 

A few questions:

 

1: What's Myers-Briggs?

2: What's an INTJ?

3: If Neil is an INTJ, what are Alex and Geddy?

 

http://www.therushforum.com/index.php?/topic/99842-personality-test/page__hl__+myers%20+briggs#entry4081081

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jokes aside, they're just regular dudes. Overanalyzing them as Gods is dumb. They have families, regular lives besides being in a band. We have threads regarding them as the holy Trinity every week and yeah, Rush is good, but come on theyre not superhumans, they're Canadian

 

Canadians can't be superheroes, eh? :LOL: I think their super power is being polite, right? :D

 

Wolverine-Angry.jpg

Wrong, bitch!

 

Haha!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jokes aside, they're just regular dudes. Overanalyzing them as Gods is dumb. They have families, regular lives besides being in a band. We have threads regarding them as the holy Trinity every week and yeah, Rush is good, but come on theyre not superhumans, they're Canadian

 

Canadians can't be superheroes, eh? :LOL: I think their super power is being polite, right? :D

 

Wolverine-Angry.jpg

Wrong, bitch!

 

Haha!

 

http://static.adweek.com/adweek.com-prod/files/imagecache/node-blog/blogs/ck-bieber-hed-2014.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyways... if you read the Four-Temperament Ensemble thing...

 

Basically, from what I have seen in interviews, Alex is sanguine, Neil is melancholic, and Geddy, as has already been established, is phlegmatic. There are no choleric members (unless you count John Rutsey, but I don't know what he was like...).

 

Is anyone else here in agreement?

I'm more into the Myers-Briggs approach to personality analysis. We've had several discussions about Neil being an INTJ, and the fact that here on the Forum there are an inordinate number of INTJs (typically 1% of the population).

 

Good thread!

 

Thanks!

 

A few questions:

 

1: What's Myers-Briggs?

2: What's an INTJ?

3: If Neil is an INTJ, what are Alex and Geddy?

 

http://www.therushforum.com/index.php?/topic/99842-personality-test/page__hl__+myers%20+briggs#entry4081081

 

Ah. Thanks!!

 

So what do you think Alex and Geddy would be and why?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyways... if you read the Four-Temperament Ensemble thing...

 

Basically, from what I have seen in interviews, Alex is sanguine, Neil is melancholic, and Geddy, as has already been established, is phlegmatic. There are no choleric members (unless you count John Rutsey, but I don't know what he was like...).

 

Is anyone else here in agreement?

I'm more into the Myers-Briggs approach to personality analysis. We've had several discussions about Neil being an INTJ, and the fact that here on the Forum there are an inordinate number of INTJs (typically 1% of the population).

 

Good thread!

 

Thanks!

 

A few questions:

 

1: What's Myers-Briggs?

2: What's an INTJ?

3: If Neil is an INTJ, what are Alex and Geddy?

 

http://www.therushforum.com/index.php?/topic/99842-personality-test/page__hl__+myers%20+briggs#entry4081081

 

Ah. Thanks!!

 

So what do you think Alex and Geddy would be and why?

 

Your welcome.

 

Too hard to say. I've taken that test 4 times over a 25 or so year period and got 4 different results. 1 result was extremely different from the other 3. I guess it shouldn't be too surprising since people can change over time. So it'd be a bit tough to nail it down to specifics other than to say that Alex is extroverted.

 

Anyway, I might've said this earlier, it's hard to judge their personalities based on their public personas which is basically all we have to go by.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jokes aside, they're just regular dudes. Overanalyzing them as Gods is dumb. They have families, regular lives besides being in a band. We have threads regarding them as the holy Trinity every week and yeah, Rush is good, but come on theyre not superhumans, they're Canadian

 

Canadians can't be superheroes, eh? :LOL: I think their super power is being polite, right? :D

 

Wolverine-Angry.jpg

Wrong, bitch!

 

Haha!

 

http://static.adweek.com/adweek.com-prod/files/imagecache/node-blog/blogs/ck-bieber-hed-2014.jpg

 

Your pillow case cover?

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyways... if you read the Four-Temperament Ensemble thing...

 

Basically, from what I have seen in interviews, Alex is sanguine, Neil is melancholic, and Geddy, as has already been established, is phlegmatic. There are no choleric members (unless you count John Rutsey, but I don't know what he was like...).

 

Is anyone else here in agreement?

I'm more into the Myers-Briggs approach to personality analysis. We've had several discussions about Neil being an INTJ, and the fact that here on the Forum there are an inordinate number of INTJs (typically 1% of the population).

 

Good thread!

 

Thanks!

 

A few questions:

 

1: What's Myers-Briggs?

2: What's an INTJ?

3: If Neil is an INTJ, what are Alex and Geddy?

http://www.myersbriggs.org/my-mbti-personality-type/mbti-basics/the-16-mbti-types.htm?bhcp=1

 

I think you'll find it interesting.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...